Seething over the very limited portrayal of Indian women as vamps, doormats and schemers and the impact these serials and cinema would have on the masses, they have decided to get their views across. Of course, they do feel a watchdog committee on the lines of the Censor Board of Film Certification, might help to keep matters under check.
And to put the point across to the entertainment industry, the FICCI Ladies Organisation FLO is organising a seminar on Women Empowerment through Cinema on April 9. Among the people invited from the entertainment industry are Ekta Kapoor, Suhasini Maniratnam, Tanuja Chandra, Mrinal Sen, Vyjayantimala Bali, Deepti Naval, Mahesh Bhatt, Neena Gupta amd Shashi Kapoor.
Says Surekha Kothari, director of Kothari Industrial Corporation Limited and managing director of Vaibhava India Private Limited, who also happens to be the president of FLO, ‘‘the sheer negative portrayal of women in some of the serials is a matter of great concern to us and to Indian women.’’ As for Hindi films, Kothari says directors are confused about the manner in which they want to portray the Indian woman. ‘‘They are either modern, superfluous or traditional,’’ she says.
While actress-dancer Vyjayantimala Bali, who believes Indian mythology is replete with good and evil women, advocates moderation, Abha Dalmia is blunt: ‘‘All this portrayal of bejewelled women who can’t think for themselves doesn’t make any sense. I think these are highly overrated serials which may be popular among some classes, but not the thinking, discerning class.’’
For Kusum Ansal, the real problem lies with the producers of films and serials. ‘‘Even when women are shown as heading organisations, they are frivolous and wealthy, slipping from one extra-marital affair to another. Is this the way we want to see women portrayed,’’ she asks.
As a filmmaker, Tanuja Chandra feels the saas-bahu genres are just tactics to get TRPs and sponsors. ‘‘I do feel bad that television is being misused because it provides an excellent opportunity to experiment but that has unfortunately not happened,’’ she says, adding TRPs may not mean anything in the long run.
Mrinal Sen puts the excessive negative portrayal to the male chauvinistic society that we live in. ‘‘Unfortutely, male chauvinism is acute in India. In degrees higher than what is prevalant in the West,’’ he says.
For all the criticism, Kothari says there are redeeming features in Kapoor’s brand of soaps. The case for joint family and some of the values that hold the families together, which come across in the soaps, is good. By the way, Kapoor is a special invitee but she’s keeping her guests guessing. As of Sunday, she hadn’t confirmed her participation. Neither was she willing to comment when The Indian Express reached her.