The Delhi High Court today directed the Government to conduct laboratory tests on the soft drinks of PepsiCo and submit its report within three weeks.
Justice B D Ahmed maintained that the issue concerns public health, and directed the government to carry out the test of the samples of Pepsi’s products manufactured in India in a laboratory which had the required facilities and equipment.
PepsiCo in its petition, filed on Friday, had sought an independent inquiry to determine the veracity of the Centre for Science and Environment CSE report claiming presence of pesticides in aerated drinks much above the permitted limits in the US and Europe.
The court observed that the CSE has, in particular, brought to the notice of the people that there is no such standard in India for the limit of pesticides in beverages.
The Government today accepted before the court that sufficient quality tests did not exist for soft drinks in the country. Taking note of Additional Solicitor General K K Sud’s submission that the government would have the products tested, Justice Ahmed directed that the testing ‘‘should be done immediately.’’
For once, both parties seem to be satisfied. The petitioner PepsiCo India and the CSE welcomed the High Court decision calling for an expert committee to review the findings. CSE welcomed the fact that random samples would be collected from the market and would be tested in government laboratories. ‘‘The Court has also endorsed CSE’s concern over the lack of standards for permissible pesticide residues in soft drinks,’’ said a statement from CSE.
PepsiCo said that the Court had recognised their demand to have independent tests in accredited laboratories. PepsiCo, which had urged in its petition that the CSE be restained from publishing its report, today withdrew this plea.
The court also asked PepsiCo to file its response to the August 6 letter of the Canteen Stores department of the Defence Ministry by which it had stopped purchasing Pepsi products. The response should contain the scientific and technical data and other relevant facts in view of the CSE report, the court said.
Counsel for Pepsi Harish Salve maintained that the report furnished by the CSE was ‘‘incorrect’’ and ‘‘unreliable’’. ASG Sud said, ‘‘We cannot close our eyes. We cannot ignore the CSE report.
Counsel for PepsiCo submitted that it was an admitted position that there were no Indian standards in the regard, so why should the norms prevailing in the US, where, for instance, DDT was banned, be compared with norms here.
The ASG informed the court that a central committee has been constituted under the provisions of Prevention of Food Adulteration Act.
The committee will be taking up the issue for prescribing the standards for soft drinks with regard to the pesticides limit.