The Election Commission today urged the Supreme Court to return the Gujarat reference unanswered and reiterated its view that the only remedy available to the Centre in the first week of October is to impose President’s Rule in the state.
Addressing a five-judge Constitution bench, headed by Chief Justice B N Kirpal, the EC’s counsel, K K Venugopal, said the Court should decline to answer the reference because, from the arguments made yesterday by Solicitor General Harish Salve, the Centre appears to have changed its interpretation of Article 174, which stipulates that there can’t be a gap of more than six months between two sessions of an Assembly.
The reference was made on ‘‘the basic assumption’’ that the six-month rule of Article 174 applied both to a prorogued House and to a dissolved Assembly. Since Salve said yesterday that there was force in the contrary view that Article 174 applied only to a prorogued House, Venugopal said the questions raised in the reference were no more valid.
Venugopal also took objection to the ‘‘distortion’’ the Centre made in the manner in which it raised the question about interplay between Articles 174 and 324 which empowers the EC to hold elections.
In its August 16 order, the EC said ‘‘Article 174 of the Constitution must yield to Article 324 in the interest of genuine democracy and purity of elections.’’ The question the Centre framed on this basis is: ‘‘Is Article 174 subject to the decision of the Election Commission under Article 324 as to the schedule of elections of the Assembly?’’ Venugopal said if the question had included the terms ‘‘genuine democracy’’ and ‘‘purity of elections’’, the answer would have been ‘‘self-evident.’’
Denying the allegation that the EC gave its August 16 order ‘‘on the premise that any infraction of the mandate of Article 174 would be remedied by a resort to Article 356,’’ Venugopal said the EC’s intention was only to point out that there need be no apprehension of a ‘‘constitutional impasse’’ in Gujarat as ‘‘Article 356 could provide a solution in such a situation.’’
He said if elections could not be held due to a natural calamity or a serious law and order situation in a state within the six-month period as prescribed under Article 174, then ‘‘the court should perceive that the safety valve is provided under Article 356 for imposing President’s Rule to avoid any constitutional crisis.’’
As for Salve’s charge that the EC erred in presuming that Parliament would have endorsed President’s Rule in Gujarat, Venugopal said ‘‘there is nothing wrong in presuming that Parliament will act responsibly.’’
Further, Venugopal questioned Salve’s argument that Article 164, which allows a minister to carry on without being a member of the legislature for six months, imposes a time limit for holding elections as well. Giving parawise reply to the three questions referred by the President for the apex court opinion, the EC counsel said ‘‘there is basic error on the hypothesis to which the reference has been made and court should decline to answer it.’’
Venugopal said Article 324 giving the Commission power to hold elections was a basic feature of the Constitution and was independent of the provision of Article 174. ‘‘It cannot be subject to the provisions of Article 174 but both have to be harmonised in their applicability,’’ he said.
The Gujarat government’s counsel, Kirit Raval, alleged that the EC had failed to fulfil any of the three preconditions for putting off the elections: one, to assess the situation; two, to remove the deficiencies with the help of state and central government and, three, to draw a conclusion after taking these steps.
Raval also clarified for the record that while it concurred with the views of the Centre on the reference, the Gujarat government was ‘‘in total disagreement with the factual findings rendered by the Election Commission.’’
BJP counsel and former law minister Arun Jaitley challenged the EC’s contention that Article 324 would override Article 174. He will resume tomorrow.