From their seats in the gallery, wide-eyed boys and girls stared at the spectacle below. This was very different from textbook passages on lively Parliament debates. Teacher never told them they would get to hear such an earful. But then Teacher couldn’t be blamed. It was the day for Gujarat in the Lok Sabha.
Running perilously close to the line that divides accepted speech from unparliamentary, proceedings in the Lok Sabha had members digging deep into the mind’s recesses to nail the other with descriptions ranging from a Nazi volunteer to an LTTE agent to a creature which can see only in the night. There was even a big squabble over Sonia Gandhi chewing gum, leaving many wondering how was it in any way connected to Rule 184.
Union Sports and Youth Affairs Minister Uma Bharti, known more for her fiery speeches, was fielded by the treasury benches as their first speaker. And she led the charge from the word go. ‘‘Hindus were always secular, as secular as pure ghee. Dalda came in because of pseudo-secularists like you,’’ she told the Opposition.
In a no-holds barred attack, she also had a direct swipe at Mulayam Singh, who had earlier moved the motion on behalf of Ramjilal Suman, saying, ‘‘I am amazed by my elder brother Mulayam Singhji’s speech today. He once had Mayawati dragged by her hair in the rest house…’’
From the galleries, Rajya Sabha members Shabana Azmi husband Javed Akhtar sat in the gallery opposite, Ghulam Nabi Azad, Praful Patel, T Subbirami Reddy, Vijay Mallya, Rajiv Shukla watched — many RS members hopped across to watch the big fight in the LS — as members tried to shout down each other.
A distinct pattern emerged. Opting for aggression rather than defence, NDA members ensured the ghosts of the 1983 Nellie massacre and the 1984 anti-Sikh riots were around to leave the Opposition squirming. For a while, the Gujarat talk would get derailed, overtaken by images of horrors from the past or drowned in the din over an unacceptable accusation.
Sonia Gandhi, Chandrashekhar, Somnath Chatterjee led the initial Opposition charge, singling out BJP and the Hindutva forces on the rampage in Gujarat. Sonia was more direct, making another pointed attack at the Prime Minister for what she said had been his doublespeak.
Reading from a prepared text, she finished quickly but not before she had slammed the Sangh Parivar for its ‘‘technique of repeating a falsehood so that it eventually passes off as a truth.’’
But the treasury benches, who had been watching her intently, struck back later. George Fernandes and Uma Bharti said the Leader of Opposition was not only provoking her party members but also chewing gum. She had no business to do that because it would lower the dignity of the House, they said.
Sonia kept her cool, pacifying annoyed partymen to take it easy and not make it an issue.
The House had earlier been treated to some choice descriptions. Uma Bharti recoiled in horror when Chandrashekhar compared her to a Nazi volunteer. But the former Prime Minister had reserved the unkindest cut for George Fernandes, the NDA firefighter in Gujarat. ‘‘I am told he has been quoting Jaya Prakash Narain as having said that he saw a ray of hope in Narendra Modi. I don’t know whether JP said this. As for this person, I am reminded of a creature which can only see in the night.’’
Between them, Vaiko and Mani Shankar Aiyar stalled the proceedings for quite some time. Aiyar’s remark about Vaiko being an LTTE agent even had L K Advani on his feet, protesting only to be shouted down by the Opposition.
Outside the House, parliament staff checked with journalists whether the TDP had made its stand clear. Are they going to abstain or will they come to the government’s rescue? Has Yerran Naidu spoken, they all wanted to know. But that was exactly what the hacks were trying to figure out. As the day wore on, it became clear the list of speakers was long. Very long. Many moved out, realising they had some time on hand to unwind before the vote to end the debate.