Former Chief Minister Keshubhai Patel says that if Narendra Modi made the anti-Muslim remarks, as reported, it is ‘‘unfortunate.’’ Patel, or for that matter the National Commission for Minorities which asked for a copy of Modi’s speech, may never know.
For, the state government today expressed its inability to send the transcript. Chief Minister’s Principal Secretary P K Mishra told The Indian Express: ‘‘Since the government has neither any tapes nor a transcript of the CM’s speech, it is not in a position to send the same to the NCM.’’
Incidentally, just days ago, Additional Chief Secretary Home Ashok Narayan had said: ‘‘We are trying to procure the text of the speech. As soon as we get it, it will be sent to the Commission.’’
At Becharaji, Modi had reportedly distorted the family planning slogan Hum Do, Hamare Do to Hum Paanch, Hamare Pachchis in an apparent reference to Muslims in refugee camps.
Though yatra coordinator Jayanti Barot denied this, state BJP chief Rajendrasinh Rana had justified Modi’s remarks, claiming that he was ‘‘stating a fact.’’ Meanwhile, for Modi, the Keshubhai headache is growing as he has decided to stay away from the second leg of the gaurav yatra.
When asked by The Indian Express what he thought of Modi’s reported Hum paanch, hamare pachchis speech, Keshubhai said: ‘‘If the reports of the CM having made such remarks are true, then it’s unfortunate. There are several other ways to encourage members of the minority community to practise family planning.’’ He added that he had ‘‘learnt that Yatra convenor Jayanti Barot has refuted the reports.’’
Patel also made it clear today that he was not out of the political race. When told that BJP leaders were for Modi as Chief Minister if the BJP comes to power, he reacted angrily: ‘‘Who is saying this? It is not necessary that only Modi will become the Chief Minister. It is for the BJP’s elected MLAs to decide,’’ he said. ‘‘If the party leadership directs me, I may contest the elections,’’ he added.
On when he would join the yatra, he said: ‘‘I may join it in the coming days but definitely not during the second leg.’’
Meanwhile, Gujarat Congress chief Shankersinh Vaghela said his party had decided to videotape every speech of Modi’s and claimed that the BJP had a recording of the controversial speech.