This is an archive article published on February 16, 2007
Premium

Masters of a planning mess

Delhi8217;s citizens should ask whether the planned expansion of their city will make it a safer and better place

.
Written by: P V Indiresan
5 min readFeb 16, 2007 12:00 AM IST First published on: Feb 16, 2007 at 11:45 PM IST

Public reaction to the government’s ‘Master Plan 2021’ for Delhi has been unusually muted. It appears that we are not sure about how to question its premise or how it can be improved. The Supreme Court, which first opened the can of worms that started the entire exercise, will no doubt look at the legality of the Plan. It should go deeper: it should enquire whether the Plan is constitutionally sound.

For instance, suppose a peasant in a backward state were to file a PIL questioning the government’s decision to invest more and more in Delhi deliberately, causing land costs to rise exponentially, even as the poor villager is denied even a tiny fraction of that patronage. The Court will then be forced to consider whether the disparity in state expenditure is so excessive that it contravenes the fundamental right of villagers to equality before the law. Is a citizen of Delhi more equal than a villager in Orissa?

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments