Sunita Rani has returned to the track, her coach Renu Kohli has been recommended for the Dronacharya Award but the doping controversy that haunted the athlete is far from over.
Dr Y Kuroda, chairman of Medical Commission, Olympic Council of Asia, insists that the urine samples of the Indian middle- and long-distance runner had definite traces of the banned substance, nandrolone.
Kuroda, who was also in charge of the commission that conducted tests at the Seoul laboratory, said: ‘‘Yes, she went scot-free on technicalities but her urine samples definitely showed nandrolone in excess of the permissible limit.’’ Blaming the laboratory for the mess-up, he said the athlete escaped because the Seoul laboratory staff proved to be ‘‘inefficient.’’
Kuroda was in India on a three-day visit to inspect the facilities in Hyderabad, where the Afro-Asian Games will be held, and the Sports Authority of India SAI dope-testing laboratory in New Delhi. Dr Kuroda told The Indian Express that what really helped Sunita was the different levels of the banned substance in her A and B sample tests.
‘‘After your federation raised objection, I called for the papers and the officials who tested both samples and found discrepancies in the analysis reports. I even summoned the director of the laboratory. He was determined to fight the case but later withdrew when he realised the mistakes of his staff,’’ he said. Lalit Kumar Bhanot, secretary of the Amateur Athletics Federation of India AAFI, called Kuroda’s statement ‘‘all rubbish.’’ ‘‘I don’t want to discuss the procedural lapses. An individual has no locus standi to comment on it because all concerned — the International Olympic Committee, International Amateur Athletics Federation and the Olympic Council of Asia — have dismissed the case as something not worthy to pursue.’’
There were 794 tests carried out in the Busan Games and Sunita Rani was the only one who was ‘caught’. Her urine samples, tested after the 1,500 metres and 5,000m, showed nandrolone levels well above the limits prescribed by the IOC.
However, the report of the one-man Sushil Salwan Committee, appointed by AAFI, argued on the variation in the levels of nandrolone, in the A and B urine samples of the athlete.
The IOC permits a level of two nanograms of nandrolone per millilitre of urine for men and five nanograms for non-pregnant women. Nandrolone is known to be produced naturally by the body, though in very small quantiies. The IOC limits are actually well above the normal levels found in humans.
In Sunita Rani’s case, the nandrolone levels in the A and B samples were 21 ng/ml and 6 ng/ml, respectively. It is this variation that AAFI based its challenges on to get Sunita off the hook.