Upholding the death sentence of Mohammad Afzal in the December 13 Parliament attack case, the Supreme Court today dismissed his curative petition filed last year. Last September, the court had dismissed his review petition against its August 4, 2005 verdict by which it had confirmed the capital punishment of Afzal awarded by the trial court and upheld by the Delhi High Court.
After an in-chamber hearing this evening, a four-judge bench of Chief Justice Y K Sabharwal and Justices K G Balakrishanan, B N Agarwal and P P Naolekar ruled that the “plea had no merits.”
Afzal’s mercy petition is pending with President A P J Abdul Kalam.
The bench also declined to review the 10-year prison sentence awarded to Shaukat Hussain Guru who had also filed a curative petition. The High Court had concurred with the death penalty awarded by the trial court to Shaukat but the apex court had reduced it to a prison term.
In his curative petition filed through advocate Kamini Jaiswal, Afzal claimed he was denied a fair trial in the Sessions Court as the judge failed to follow the procedure laid down by Delhi Legal Aid Rules. He argued that despite his opposition, a counsel not of his choice was appointed amicus curiae. The denial of counsel of his choice resulted in a Constitutional error, Afzal’s petition said, because it affected the framework within which a trial proceeded and required no proof of prejudice.
He alleged there was a miscarriage of justice as the August 4, 2005 judgment departed from the norms laid down by the Supreme Court and thereby violated his fundamental right to have competent legal representation.
Quoting rights contained in the International Conventions, in particular the International Convention on Civil and Political Rights, Afzal’s petition said that a person accused of a criminal offence had a right to be defended by effective counsel during detention, trial and appeal.