William Dalrymple calls his new book — The Last Mughal: The Fall of a Dynasty, 1857 — a “reconciliation letter” to the city of Delhi, about which he first wrote in City of Djinns. In a vivid street-level portrait of the city on the cusp of its passage from Mughal to British rule, he gathers documents in the National Archives translated for the first time. He spoke to Mini Kapoor about the book and his fascination with the Mughals, on whom he plans to write three more books.
8226; This is a portrait of Delhi, isn’t it?
Yes, despite its title, it’s not a biography. I barely touch on the first 70 years of Bahadur Shah Zafar’s life. The book is about the fall of Delhi. It’s divided very simply into three sections: Delhi before the Uprising, the Uprising, and the aftermath — the apocalyptic British revenge and the uprooting of Indo-Islamic civilisation. Zafar is a central character but he’s only one of a cast of 12 characters who run through the book, six Indians and six British. They were selected because they were people whose lives one can trace from before the fall, during and after. In that sense it’s got the kind of structure of one of those really terrible disaster movies. On a more serious basis, its model is my favourite history book, Steven Runciman’s The Fall of Constantinople 1453. Obviously there are many ways of writing history. For my personal taste, that Runciman’s style is how I like history to be written. I want to know that the writer is in command of his sources, has new material and has done his work. But equally, it’s important to know that he can write, that he can interest you. What one finds with Indian history at the moment is that in general historians seem to be writing for each other. They are doing spectacular work, but it is not written for the general reader. In particular I find that the jargon which academic historians have come to use — particularly in post-colonial studies — obscures rather than illuminates.
8226; Yes, you indict them in the introduction by noting how they have failed to access the “Mutiny Papers” in the Indian National Archives.
By no means am I seeking to indict anyone, but it does seem to me extraordinary that one can have an archive sitting in the main National Archives at the very centre of Delhi and in it lie the complete records of the largest uprising against any colonial power at any point in the 19th century — the records of the court, almost complete records of five different sepoy accounts, the records of the kotwal, the different police thanas and the courts of justice. This The Imperial Record Department’s Press-List of Mutiny Papers 1857 is what started the whole thing off, beautifully catalogued in 1921 when the papers were discovered in a series of trunks in Calcutta. I originally came across it in the National Archives. And if you look at any book on 1857, they always start saying, sadly there are no Indian records. Now it’s all there in this book the catalogue which has been around for more than 80 years. I’ve been working breakneck for four years with two very fine scholars of Urdu and Persian, but have scraped no more than 10 per cent of that archive. I cannot believe that there is any city at any period in India’s history which has quite the density of street-level material that is available for Delhi of that time. It’s a snapshot at every level of society of a city brightly lit up just before it is swept away.
8226; Was it a serendipitous discovery, or did the catalogue determine your choice of 1857?
No, this I found in the process of researching for White Mughals. I would be lying if I claimed this was completely virgin source. What is true though is that no one has spent a period of time trying to get an overall picture of Delhi using this source. It’s the first book on 1857 in Delhi for a generation. Unlike Lucknow and Kanpur, there’s nothing on Delhi. This is very, very odd because of the 167,000 sepoys who rose up against their own officers, at least 100,000 went straight to Delhi, very specifically to put the Mughal emperor back on the throne. Who are these sepoys? They are 85 per cent upper-caste Hindus. It’s well worth it to compare 1857 to 1992. There is a widespread and deep ambivalence about Mughal rule in India today. And 1857 certainly shows the limits of Mughal rule — there is no doubt that the fiasco that ensued in Delhi was at least partially the result of inadequate leadership — but it does show that there was a very different view of the Mughals in the pre-modern period.
8226; You draw strong parallels with today’s Iraq by mentioning a dodgy dossier prepared to annex Avadh.
It’s extraordinary, this report on Avadh — eventually published as the parliamentary Oude Blue Book — was clearly a complete stitch-up. The East India Company wanted to annex Avadh, it knew there was huge financial incentive to annex Avadh. The other most obvious parallel with today was the role played in 1857 by the jihadis. This is not my term, this is how they described themselves. These people are completely separate from the sepoys. At the beginning of the Uprising they are of relatively minor importance, in that you have successive waves of sepoys coming into the city. But as the months progress, and as the logistical failure of the Mughals to provide food, pay and munitions for the sepoys becomes more and more apparent, you find that the number of sepoys in Delhi begins to drop. By the time the British actually attack the city in mid-September, around two-thirds have gone home. In the meantime the city has begun filling with ordinary Muslim civilians, who are not trained soldiers. But when it is streetfighting with bayonets against battle-axes, the jihadis come into their own. And there is a moment, around the 17th of September, when it looks as if the British are actually going to retreat.
8226; And through it all is Ghalib, who almost appears to be the central character, watching his city change?
What’s interesting about Ghalib is that as a poet he is so complex and often very difficult, but as prose writer he is wonderfully clear and urbane and amusing. And what’s wonderful about him is that he does see the whole story through.
