The Government’s decision today to cancel all allotments made since January 2000 is no doubt an unprecedented sweeping order but experts say this is just the first in a series of corrective measures it will have to take to extricate itself from the petrol-pump scam.
The most serious fallout the Government will have to tackle is if the affected allottees file writ petitions in high courts. They have quite a few arguments:
8226; It violates the most basic principle of natural justice: they got no hearing.
8226; The agreement they have signed with the PSU provides for termination only when the dealer fails to comply with any of the clauses. The blanket decision makes no pretence of a case-by-case evaluation.
If such petitions are filed in more than one high court as it happened with Balco disinvestment issue, the Govt may request the Supreme Court to bunch them together. The Govt will have to act with urgency if any of the courts issues a stay order either on the decision on on the cancellation of an allotment.
In fact, it may even have to file caveats in the courts to ensure that no ex parte order is passed on the petiton of an aggrieved allottee.Given the larger public interest involved in cancelling the allotments, the very Government that perpetrated the scam, ironically, stands a fair chance of succeeding in countering any legal challenge to today’s corrective action.
There are any number of precedents when the Supreme Court has admitted that a few people can be ‘‘martyred’’ by a policy decision taken in public interest.Legal experts say that if the Government is earnest about implementing today’s decision, the most effective option would be to resort to legislation.
Once it passes a law introducing competitive bidding in this regard with retrospective effect from January 2000, the Government will have little difficulty in dealing with any legal objections that the affected allottees may raise.
There are doubts about whether the Government will genuinely contest petitions filed by allottees belonging to or connected with the BJP. Whatever the fate of the existing allottees, the Government has shown greater resolve to ensure transparency in future allotments.
Going by the statement today from thePMO, the Government has committed itself to withdraw the controversial guidelines issued by Ram Naik in October 2000 leading to the scam. Those guidelines, which let Ram Naik make arbitrary allotments under the cover of the DSBs, will be replaced by the more transparent system of competitive bidding.A more challenging task will be for the Petroleum Ministry to evolve, as mentioned in the PMO’s statement, ‘‘modalities for the re-allotment on competitive bidding’’ of the existing petrol pumps and LPG agencies.