Premium
This is an archive article published on July 3, 1998

Film Review — MajorSaab

It's really quite unfair-these streams of protests that have been pouring in from the defence services regarding Major Saab' and all the br...

.

It’s really quite unfair-these streams of protests that have been pouring in from the defence services regarding Major Saab’ and all the brouhaha accompanying it that the films tends to distort the image of the National Defence Academy. Is it that some people cannot recognise a good deed done to them even when it is so obvious?

I mean, here we have the defence authorities lamenting about the fact that very few youngsters are opting for the forces these days with the ministry spending a huge amount on advertisement extolling the present generation to join the army. And here is Amitabh doing all this and more for them totally free of cost! If all the youngsters in the country do not make a beeline for NDA after this movie there is something seriously amiss.

For where else can you get an academy that apparently has no recruitment procedure, no great educational qualification requirements and an obviously flexible age limit for aspirants, where the training comprises mainly song and dance sequences, where there are open gutters with underground tunnels leading you out of the academy whenever you desire, and most important, where the motto is to ensure that the cadets get to marry their beloved, to which end the entire machinery of the academy can be put to use if required, with everyone from the cadets to instructors pitching in their mite?

Where Operation Brass Tacks means breaking into the house of your sweetheart with high-tech weapons belonging to the Indian Army to thwart her marriage with someone else, where first-termers of 16 to 17 years of age can, not only get married, but even have the instructors and commandant doing an enthusiastic bhangra at the wedding and where femme-fatales pictures are nailed on trees by the drill instructor to put some zest in your drill routine?

As soon as the movie starts, your mind is flooded with sinking feelings that this is going to be one of those army-inspired films’ that make you cringe at every frame. And you are not disappointed. From spoilt brat Ajay Devgun snapping his fingers at his lawyer with a “Make arrangements for me to join the Military Academy” to Sonali Bendre walking through the corridors of the academy with no questions asked to pour out her love for Devgun to Major Jaspal Rana Bachchan and his cadets donning on the war paint to fight underworld dons and rescue Bendre from her wedding venue, the film is one that goes from the unbelievable to the ludicrous, without a moment’s respite.

To say that the movie does not connect to NDA life is a gross understatement. The lapses are far too glaring and far too many to be excused under the umbrella of cinematic liberties. Amitabh Bachchan as Major Jaspal Singh Rana supports a beard not allowed except on religious or medical grounds, an attitude not encouraged on any grounds and an amazingly colourful ceremonial uniform not seen at any ceremony as he strides around the academy referring to the cadets as my army’. Later as he takes them out to fight local dons you realise he actually meant it. Then of course there is the unforgivable scene of Bachchan whacking Devgun with his baton, the inexplicable shot of him leading cadets on a drill singing Jaan par hum khelenge even as the cadets chorus Khelenge khelenge! and the preposterous act of nailing Bendre’s picture on a tree to inspire a injured Devgun on drill.

You further have the man, who is referred to as the paradigm of discipline and decorum, lowering himself and his cadets into a tunnel through the gutter in a bid to secretly leave the academy without permission, to thwart the marriage of his cadet’s sweetheart to someone else. If that is not enough, he then even arranges this first termer’s baraat later on, that has not only him and the cadets, but even the academy’s commandant who has been given the rank of a mere Brigadier instead of the regulatory Maj General or Lt General shaking an inspired leg. Keeping with the spirit of things, the academy too is lit up like a Christmas tree for the momentous occasion.

Story continues below this ad

Devgun on his part is an over-age, pampered brat who has apparently been expelled from every college in town and makes it to NDA on the basis of instructions issued to his lawyer. UPSC Examination -Whazzatt? Services Selection Board – come again? Dividing his time between the hospital at NDA and Sonali Bendre outside NDA, he moves around the academy with an unshorn look, sloppy gait and a lovelorn expression. One scene even has him winning the marathon his daily routine, notwithstanding and running up the steps of the Sudan Block exchanging high fives’ with proud instructor Bachchan rather than the obviously out-dated salute. In fact the student-instructor camaraderie gets stronger by the frame, with scenes like Devgun walking upto Bachchan after his legs have been fractured by local hoodlums and Bachchan reciprocating the sentiment by actually coming back from the dead on Devgun’s express request.

And so it carries on. There not being any open convenient manhole in the theatre for you to make an escape a la Devgun you just sit helplessly and watch NDA being reduced to an unforgivable mockery. You wonder why Bachchan bellows to a cop Don’t mess with the army’ when he himself has proceeded to do just that from reel one to nineteen, how a Gypsy jeep could follow the Major and cadets through the manhole to enable them to bundle into it outside the NDA gates and most of all what made Bachchan choose this most prestigious institution of all as the setting, when he did not even have the slightest of inclination to do some homework about it or incorporate anything of importance about NDA in his movie. Or are we being overtly critical? Perhaps there is a logical explanation for all this. Like it not being revealed to the Big B that NDA stands for National Defence Academy and not National Dance Academy.

Sunanda Mehta is the Resident Editor of The Indian Express in Pune. She is a distinguished journalist, columnist, and author with over three decades of experience in the media industry. Educational background: A merit-lister in her 12 th in CBSE (5th rank in Humanities) Sunanda stood first in History in the Board for which she was awarded the Dr Tarachand Gold Medal. She is a triple-graduate with a Bachelor of Arts (History Honours) from Lady Shri Ram College, New Delhi, Bachelor of Education, Delhi University (on scholarship) and Bachelor of Communication and Journalism, University of Pune. Professional Background Role: As Resident Editor, she oversees the Pune edition of The Indian Express, managing local news coverage, investigative features, and editorial direction for the city. Author: She is an accomplished author, known for her biographies. Her notable books include: The Extraordinary Life and Death of Sunanda Pushkar published by Pan Macmillan (2019). The book was long-listed for the Atta Galatta award for nonfiction and Auther award for best debut author. Majestic Musings - Translation of poems from 100 year old Badshaian from Punjabi to English (2023) Behind the Big Screen- the untold stories of child actors published by Bloomsbury India (2024) Focus Areas: While Sunanda has reported on various subjects from civic to political to investigative and crime, her forte remains long-form human-interest stories, heritage and gender issues. Core Column: "Against All Odds" Sunanda curates and writes a signature series titled "Against All Odds," which profiles individuals who have overcome significant personal, medical, or professional challenges. Recent notable articles (2025) The Story of Dr. Harinder Dhaliwal (July 2025): A Pune AFMC topper who became a neurologist in Canada despite becoming paraplegic. Jayoo Patwardhan’s Cancer Journey (Jan 2025): How the National Film Award-winning designer defeated cancer. Partha Iyengar’s Emergency mid-air (Aug 2025): The story of how Gartner’s India head survived a massive heart attack during a long-haul flight. Recent Notable Articles (Late 2025) Her recent reportage continues to explore deep personal narratives and Pune’s socio-environmental landscape: 1. Personal Narratives & Closure "'I grieved for him 10 years after his murder, found closure to unsolved case'" (Dec 14, 2025): A poignant feature on Vineet Alurkar, son of the late Pune music legend Suresh Alurkar, and how digitizing his father’s collection helped him heal. "A 40-day journey home: how Christopher Benninger's partner gave him the gift of memories" (Nov 23, 2025): A moving tribute to the late acclaimed architect Christopher Benninger and his final trip to the US. "'After 38 years I finally met my biological mother'" (Sept 28, 2025): Chronicling the journey of an adopted daughter from Zurich searching for her roots in Pune. 2. Civic & Heritage "'Vetal Tekdi belongs to common citizens'" (Oct 20, 2025): An interview with environmental activist Dr. Sushma Date on the community-led protection of Pune’s vital green lungs. "'Military village' Apshinge recalls living through war days" (Aug 12, 2025): A report from a village in Maharashtra where nearly every household has a member in the armed forces, focusing on their legacy and current anxieties. 3. High-Profile Commentary & Investigations "Malegaon blast acquittals: 'I was expecting this verdict'" (July 31, 2025): An interview with former special public prosecutor Rohini Salian following the controversial acquittals. "Grounded, license cancelled... she decided to soar higher" (March 30, 2025): The story of Dr. Harpreet A De Singh, Air India’s first woman pilot from 1988, and her transition to leadership and meditation. Signature Style Sunanda Mehta is known for her empathetic storytelling. Unlike standard news reporting, her features often read like narrative non-fiction, focusing on the psychological and emotional resilience of her subjects. One of her articles in The Indian Express titled 'The Quality of Mercy' was converted into a film Rubaru Roshini produced by actor Aamir Khan. She is a strong advocate for Pune's heritage and environment, frequently using her platform to amplify citizen-led movements. X (Twitter): @sunandamehta and @ExpressPune ... Read More

 

Advertisement
Loading Recommendations...
Advertisement
Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments