All those who had believed that the three-day Delhi bandh sponsored by the traders aggrieved by the Supreme Court-ordered sealing of illegal shops and commercial buildings would have their say peacefully, especially in view of the unanimous support to their “cause” by all political parties, and then wait patiently for the law to take its course, have turned out to be naive. The agitators’ leaders threw to the winds their pious promises to abide by Gandhigiri, even if they had imbibed it from Munnabhai rather than the Mahatma.
In the event, as TV images framed so vividly, the so-called practitioners of commerce behaved more like unrestrained hooligans, holding the Capital to ransom and making it a prisoner of chaos. Their violence reached a crescendo on the third day when the authorities — somewhat hobbled by their own pathetic pleas for a suspension of the sealing campaign because of “tension” — had to call in para-military forces in certain areas.
There was no alternative to this step because the rowdies had blocked almost all major roads, stopped railway trains in at least one part of the city and made it impossible for the metro to function in several areas. Buses were casually burnt. Schools, optimistically reopened earlier in the day, had to be shut. Consequently, children had acute difficulty in finding transport to take them home. The mercantile mobs lit fires across the city. There could not have been a more telling bonfire of sanities. Ironically, at a time when the chemists decided that it was time to reopen their shop for the sick, Delhi’s Medical Council went on a ‘token strike’ in support of the bedlam.
At the time of writing on Wednesday afternoon, the panicky Union government had petitioned the apex court for “relief” to 40,000 traders affected by the sealing campaign due to begin on Thursday. To this the magisterial reaction of the bandh’s ring-leaders was that if this request were not granted unconditionally, they would make their agitation “indefinite”. Against this dismal backdrop, the Monitoring Committee of the Supreme Court went into a session and was expected to make recommendations in line with the government’s petition. The group of ministers appointed to deal with the nettlesome issue also held a meeting.
In fairness, it has to be conceded that while the bulk of the affected traders have indeed violated all laws and building bylaws, they were able to do so only because of collusion with municipal, DDA and police officials, to say nothing of political party leaders, many of whom are also owners of unlawfully built houses and business premises. It is also true that the officials and politicos have pocketed the hefty bribes and moved on, while the law has caught up with the erring shop owners. But is this to be made a justification for lawlessness, for the citizens to follow neither the laws enacted by legislatures nor the directives of the highest judiciary?
For that is the logic of what is being canvassed at policy making levels: ‘regularise’ all the illegal constructions completed before December 31, 2005. You can bet your bottom rupee that if this is done, there would be a replication of today’s sordid drama around this time in the year 2010.
There is yet another angle from which the deplorable developments in Delhi have to be viewed. The terrible disruption has come at a time when the economy promises to grow by 10 per cent. How can a high rate of growth be sustained if other cities and industrial centres are encouraged to imitate what has been happening in the nation’s capital?
There is usually comic relief in every tragedy. In the present case, the linguistic chauvinists of Karnataka have provided it by renaming the state’s capital Bengaluru. If this creates confusion to foreigners who only know of Bangalore as the world famous bastion of IT, then so be it.
Talk about our penchant to score self-goals. What is in evidence is a lot worse. It smacks of a lemming-like proclivity for self-destruction.
The writer is a senior political commentator