Are the Tamil Tigers really on the verge of giving up Eelam for good? The LTTE has all along been equivocating on the issue, asserting that though they had taken to arms in order to establish an independent Tamil Eelam, they are willing to consider any ‘‘substantial, meaningful, concrete alternatives’’ offered by the Sri Lankan government.
For instance in 1999, striking a hawkish posture during his annual Heroes’ Day speech, LTTE supremo Velupillai Pirabhakaran had declared that there was no alternative to a separate state. But in the very same breath, he added that he kept his options open for a ‘‘peaceful, negotiated settlement with international mediation’’.
And pray what could have been such a peaceful settlement, if not something short of an independent Eelam? Right from Thimpu talks of 1984, the LTTE has been maintaining they are open to any solution offered by the Lankan government if only the formula offered would meet the aspirations of the Tamils.
A leading observer of the Lankan scene based in London, who wished to remain anonymous, told the The Indian Express: ‘‘I don’t understand what this ga ga is all about. They have always made it clear they are not mindless terrorists, that they have been pushed into a war by a chauvinist state and that they would seriously consider any scheme that would ensure the right of the Lankan Tamils to live with dignity…’’
Douglas Devananda, chief of the Eelam People’s Democratic Party and an inveterate critic of Pirabhakaran, pointed out that when it came to peace talks, the Tigers used to make out that they were all for any workable formula but would never offer any such thing themselves. ‘‘Talking high and mighty for peace and equitable settlement during negotiations but letting out blood-curdling war cries before their home audience has been their characteristic strategy. It’s too early to say anything. The proof of the pudding is in the eating,’’ he said.
Prof.V.Suryanarayan, a veteran commentator on Lankan affairs, sounded a note of caution: ‘‘There is nothing to get excited about Balasingham’s remarks. In fact, one should be wary of his concept of a homeland and self-determination, which could in fact be interpreted as the right to secede when it is convenient for them.’’
However, another observer based in Chennai argued this was the first time that the Tigers had talked in terms of Lankan Tamils and not Eelam Tamils and had stated categorically during a peace negotiation that they were not working towards an independent Eelam.
‘‘I concede this is only a small step, but a significant step nevertheless. There is a lot of room for hope now, but it all depends on how the Lankan government responds to the various demands of the LTTE in the days to come,’’ he said.
That the LTTE has explicitly stated that the Muslims too are part and parcel of the homeland concept is seen as another gesture that could go towards building a lasting peace in the strife-torn island.
At the moment, both the Ranil Wickremesinghe government and the LTTE have a stake in keeping up the momentum towards peace. If the overall incident-free cease-fire period thus far has raised people’s hopes, the statements at Sattahip only seek to reinforce the general impression that things are working well.
But then thus far both the sides have cleverly skirted discussing substantial constitutional issues. The crunch will come when they take up the issue of interim administration for the North and East.
Questions such as as how much leeway the Lankan government would be willing to give the Tigers and how far the LTTE is itself ready
to operate within a democratic system would then come to the fore. Prospects of peace in Sri Lanka would depend on the kind of answers one gets for such tricky questions. It is too early to celebrate.