This World Cup, an overwhelming success in terms of sheer football and the endless capacity to surprise, is rapidly going down as one of the most controversial for a handful of questionable refereeing decisions. But the subtext to that is reminiscent of the controversy that shook the cricketing world a few months ago — racism: First World vs Third World.
The problem centres around the remarkable progress made by South Korea to reach the semi-fianls. Along the way, they’ve received some pretty dodgy decisions in their favour, especially when it counted, in the two knockout matches against Italy and Spain. In all, they’ve had five goals against them disallowed.
Allied to this is the fact that a large number of referees and referees’ assistants are from countries not represented at this tournament. Indeed, several from countries who’ve never made a mark on any footballing stage: Benin, Vanuatu, Antigua, India. The question arises: Why not more officials from, say, Europe and South America, from the world’s best footballing leagues, where the level of football would be similar?
The answer lies in FIFA president Sepp Blatter’s extraordinary abilities to see political advantage in almost any situation parallels with Jagmohan Dalmiya here?. Elections to his post were held just before the tournament; in these elections, every nation — from Brazil to Benin, Germany to Gambia —holds one vote. Blatter has long been a champion of Africa and Asia and is a shrewd player of the vote market there. Before this tournament, it was decided that smaller countries would send representatives, who would get valuable experience and exposure at this level. What has got exposed, however, is their sheer lack of experience. And Blatter’s plan.
Not surprisingly, he was among the first to come out strongly against the refereeing, issuing a statement last week — after Korea beat Italy — calling the officials’ performance pathetic and disgraceful. This helped him deflect the flak from himself but hasn’t done much to sort out the problem.
The result is that there are now a million conspiracy theories floating around East Asia, hinting or saying flatly that the host nation has been favoured by a bunch of Third World officials.
At one level, the facts seem to support this argument. The officials at the match against Spain were from Egypt, Trinidad and Uganda; against Italy, from Ecuador, Argentina and Hungary.
Yet there is the other side as well. Brazil have also benefited from mistakes — Jamaican referee Peter Prendergast denied Belgium’s Marc Wilmots a clear goal in the second-round match and later admitted he was wrong.
Third world country, third-world referee, you could point out.
So is it simply a matter of genuine human error? Not really. Experience at the highest levels will obviously reduce the margin of error; in the Primera Liga or the English Premiership, the football is fast. An official from Benin might have all the theoretical knowledge about what’s right and what’s wrong but simply wouldn’t be able to cope with the speed. A bit like asking a Coochbehar Trophy umpire to stand when Australia play South Africa.
FIFA is now considering changes in the refereeing process, though they have emphatically ruled out video replays, a la cricket and rugby. What might be consiered is putting additional officials behind each goal to assist the assistants.
A suitably chastened Blatter has promised ‘‘we can’t experiment any more in the World Cup, we’ll use the best referees.’’ It’s already put that plan into effect, picking two of the best — incidentally, both Europeans — for the two semi-finals.
That leaves, of course, the big one. Where, just by the way, the battle is on between an Italian, Pierluigi Collina, and the UAE’s Ali Bujsaim. Maybe, it’s time Mr Blatter gave Mr Dalmiya a call for help.