Full access at just Rs 3/day

Journalism of Courage
Advertisement
Premium

‘There are bigger problems we face… we need to be addressed the way we want to be’: Transgender community on misgendering

While the conversation over pronouns has been going on for long, transgender people still get misgendered.

preferred pronouns, transgenders, Saisha Shinde, Lock Upp, transgenders on preferred pronouns, indian expressThey agreed people do not ask for one’s preferred pronouns -- something that "really hurts, especially during the transition period".

Riled up over being misgendered by fellow contestants on the reality show Lock Upp, fashion designer Saisha Shinde raised the need for the usage of her pronouns to address her during an episode, while also highlighting how the members of the transgender community continue to be misgendered even as conversations over pronouns has been going on for long.

Shinde pointed out during the episode that the contestants did not make an effort to ask her about her pronouns. “It’s just that you guys need to understand I get annoyed when I have to correct someone four times, six times, ten times,” she said.

“A transwoman will go through so much pain just for something as simple as he and she. Imagine, KV I called you she, her,” the fashion designer said, addressing a co-contestant.

In another episode, comedian Munawar Faruqui claimed that actor Payal Rohtagi referred to Shinde as a man, to which Rohtagi said that while she does not remember the exact words used but she meant Shinde is strong like a man.

During a conversation with indianexpress.com, many members of the community echoed Shinde’s emotion. They agreed people do not ask for one’s pronouns — something that “really hurts, especially during the transition period”.

‘There is a lack of sensitivity and confusion on the matter’: Kalki Subramaniam

Kalki Subramaniam, transgender activist from Tamil Nadu said, “Pronoun is actually something we speak about only in a corporate circle. In ordinary lives, it poses a problem and a large part of the society addresses people, especially transgender people, as per their wish, without asking for permission. People judge a person based on one’s dress and appearance.”

“There is a lack of sensitivity and confusion on the matter,” added the author of ‘We are not others’. “It is difficult and very hurtful. It is important that we need to be addressed in the way we want to be addressed,” she continued.

Advertisement

“Sometimes, people within the family also use wrong pronouns. They use the pronouns of the gender we are born into and even if you tell them, they call you ‘he’,” the founder of Sahodari foundation said.

Subramaniam also mentioned about the struggle during the transition period. “We need to be given our due respect. We have been struggling through our transition period, coming out as transgender and we need to be acknowledged.”

Sharing her experience, Subramaniam, a poet, said, “A few of my friends did not use my pronoun and it really annoyed me. I told them that they need to respect me. After that, some of them changed their behaviour while some continued it with. It is very hurtful and I find their reason stupid. They are simply adamant that they can only consider me based on my old gender. If someone loves you for who you are, then they will address you the way you want. When someone calls me by my old name, it hurts even more.”

Advertisement

“Every day we raise the issue. It is a lifelong thing and it does not change in a couple of days. It is important for the well-being of transgender people in the longer run,” added the corporate trainer.

‘It took time for society to accept me’: Adam Harry

Meanwhile, the scenario is bit different for Adam Harry who rose to fame as the first Indian transman to have a private pilot license.

“At international level conferences and public programs, people have been asking me for my pronoun. Everyone should practise the polite behaviour of asking for one’s pronoun,” said Harry, a transgender activist.

“As I have gained media attention and recognition, people use my pronoun during public meetings and do not misgender me. It took time for society to accept me,” Harry told indianexpress.com.

“But, it is quite common for queer, non-binary people to get misgendered even during programs organised by the government. Transmen face it frequently,” he said.

Advertisement

Recounting his transition period, Harry said, “During my transition period, my friends used to call me by my old name. They could not accept my gender and used to block me on social media platforms.”

Suggesting the need for education on the same, Harry said: “Gender sensitization in every sector is the need of the hour. Comprehensive sexuality education needs to be provided and teachers should also be trained. Non-discriminatory policies need to be adopted and government hospitals and police officers need to follow a respectful approach.”

Advertisement

‘The need of explaining everything to people every day is distressing’: Sanjana Chandran

Sanjana Chandran, a college student and Miss Trans Global India runner-up 2021 told indianexpress.com that educational institutions also lack awareness. She finds the need of explaining everything to people on a daily basis distressing.

“Of course, you have to ask everybody, including cis genders, what their pronouns are. In this society, nobody asks for pronouns. People assume and use pronouns based on their instincts,” said Chandran, Kerala’s first transgender National award winner.

Advertisement

“The need of explaining everything to people every day is distressing and it results in mental trauma,” she said.

Chandran agreed that there are bigger problems transgender community faces and raising the need for pronoun usage comes with certain privileges. “We are deprived of our basic rights and our society has not yet developed enough to fathom that people prefer pronoun of their choice, ”she said.

“Among people who are aware and sensitized, there have been instances of people asking for pronouns and not being misgendered,” she said.

“The usage of our old pronouns is rampant among family members. They come up with the argument that they are used to it and cannot change,” she added.

Chandran recounted an ordeal during her transition period. “I had an excruciating experience during my transition period. Even though my parents were supportive, people had issues with my identity. While I was attending a marriage, children came up and asked if I am a man or woman. At that time, I wished no one should approach me and ask questions,” added the BA Functional English student.

‘Offensive comments flood social media posts’: Sisily George

Sisily George, founder of the Punarjani Cultural Society in Kerala, that works for transgender welfare, is periled with social media users’ sexist comments. George told this outlet that offensive comments asking if one is a man or woman flood in the comments section while we share posts on Facebook. Kozhikode district justice board member also said that there is a section of society which is still unversed of the transgender community.

Subscriber Only Stories
Premium
Premium
Premium
Premium

📣 For more lifestyle news, follow us on Instagram | Twitter | Facebook and don’t miss out on the latest updates!

First published on: 02-05-2022 at 05:00:02 pm
Next Story

Kartik Aaryan promotes Bhool Bhulaiyaa 2 in Chandigarh, asks fans, ‘Blockbuster hogi?’ Watch video

Home
ePaper
Next Story
close
X