Premium

Man delivered old mobile phone instead of new, wins Rs 1.06 lakh from e-commerce site

A Visakhapatnam consumer commission held an e-commerce website liable for deficiency in service after a man received a used phone containing old contacts, photos and videos.

New mobile e-commerce website consumer dispute vishakhapatnamThe man lodged a complaint with the customer care, which directed him to the service centre. There he was told that the phone's manufacturing was stopped two years ago. (AI-generated image)
Written by: Somya Tyagi
5 min readNew DelhiOct 8, 2026 04:31 PM IST First published on: Oct 8, 2026 at 04:31 PM IST

An Andhra Pradesh consumer commission recently held an e-commerce website liable for deficiency in service and ordered it to pay Rs 1.06 lakh to a man who had ordered a new mobile phone but allegedly received a used device instead.

President Gudla Tanuja and member Varri Krishna Murthy of the Visakhapatnam District Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission were hearing a plea filed by a man alleging that he had placed the order for the mobile phone on an e-commerce website.

Advertisement

“Since the answering opposite party (the e-commerce website) is instrumental in selling and delivering the defective product, it cannot claim immunity to escape from the consequences. Merely because the answering opposite party is the intermediary, it cannot claim remissions without discharging its obligations, since its services are not yeomen services and it will be charging commission for each and every transaction,” the September 30 order read.

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments