Death of six-month-old clouds demolition drive by Railways, blame game begins

Spoke to Railway minister Sh Suresh Prabhu also just now. He said he was not aware of this operation. He was also shocked.

— Arvind Kejriwal (@ArvindKejriwal) December 12, 2015

Public Works Department Minister Satyendar Jain, who visited the area Sunday afternoon, said the government had set up two sub-divisional magistrate inquiries, the first of which would look into the child’s death. “Her autopsy shows she sustained injuries to her spine and other areas due to the demolition. This is unacceptable. We are considering legal options to register a criminal case against the railways,” he said. The second inquiry has been ordered into the drive.
Railway authorities, meanwhile, claimed the child’s death occurred before the demolition had begun.

Asked if the Delhi government had been informed about the incident earlier, Jain said, “Even if we were informed, what was the emergency to raze the jhuggis in this cold weather? We were told that only a few hutments that had come up recently would be removed. But they bulldozed through an entire field.”
Meanwhile, Delhi Urban Shelter Improvement Board (DUSIB) officials said they could not arrange for relief materials in advance as the railways had not intimated them of the demolition.

In a statement issued Sunday evening, the government said the drive was carried out without any survey or rehabilitation plan. “This is against the provisions of the extant Slum & JJ Rehabilitation and Relocation Policy of the Delhi government, provisions of DUSIB Act, 2010; Special Provisions Act, 2011, Master Plan of Delhi 2021 and various landmark judgments of the Supreme Court…,” said an official.

While the railways claimed the razed jhuggis belonged to fresh encroachers who were ineligible for relocation, the statement said that according to rules, “Jhuggis in Delhi cannot be demolished without rehabilitation of eligible JJ dwellers as per the provisions of said policy”.

“Whether the JJ dwellers are eligible or not can be ascertained only after a joint-survey and eligibility determination is done by DUSIB and the land-owing agency — in this case, the railways. Unfortunately no survey was conducted,” it added.

Coming back from the demolition site. Heart rending scenes. How cud our own countrymen do this to our poorest fellow countrymen(1/2)

— Arvind Kejriwal (@ArvindKejriwal) December 12, 2015

Suspended 2 SDMs n one SE for not providing relief. Ordered officers to provide blankets now n food from morn(2/2)

— Arvind Kejriwal (@ArvindKejriwal) December 12, 2015

The railways, in a statement, said encroachments had to be cleared to make space for a new terminal in the basti. It maintained that Delhi Police and DUSIB officials were informed in advance, as per rules. “In the last nine months, three notices had been issued to encroachers to vacate railway land. The first one was issued in March. The second notice directed them to vacate by September 30, but they did not do so. The last notice asked them to vacate by December 12,” it said.

“The drive began at 11.50 am (Saturday) under police protection and was completed by evening. Railway protection force (RPF) and officials at the site discovered that the child had died at about 10 am,” said officials.

“After assessing the situation, Ishwar Singh, the station house officer of Punjabi Bagh, had the go ahead at 11.50 am. The joint note issued by police RPF and railway officials indicated that the removal was done peacefully. DUSIB officials were also informed,” said the statement.

Senior railway officials, including Northern Railway General Manager A K Puthia and Delhi Divisional Railway Manager Arun Arora, met the CM Sunday and briefed him about the drive.

Our homes were demolished without any warning or notice,say residents of slum demolished in Shakur Basti(Delhi) pic.twitter.com/rvbeQdYVjs

— ANI (@ANI_news) December 13, 2015