scorecardresearch
Saturday, Feb 04, 2023
Advertisement
Premium

Bhopal Gas Tragedy: No private party can claim damages, Union Carbide tells SC

The UCC has sought clarification of an order passed by the court in April 2011 whereby five victims’ groups were allowed to intervene in the matter.

Bhopal Gas Tragedy, Union Carbide Corporation, supreme court, bhopal gas tragedy victims, ucc, ucc gas leak, ucc settlement, bhopal gas tragedy victims rehabilitation, indian express news, damage claim, bhopal gas tragedy damage claim, indian express bhopal gas tragedy, india news The Centre had in December 2010 filed the curative petition in the apex court seeking an order to the UCC for enhancing the settlement amount and reimbursement of relief and rehabilitation expenses incurred by the state and central governments.

Asserting that no private individual can lay a claim against it for damages, the Union Carbide Corporation (UCC) has moved the Supreme Court against letting the victims’ organisations intervene in the curative petition that was filed by the central government to seek additional compensation for the victims of the 1984 Bhopal gas tragedy.

The UCC has sought clarification of an order passed by the court in April 2011 whereby five victims’ groups were allowed to intervene in the matter. The Corporation, which entered into a settlement with the Union of India in 1989 regarding the damages, has claimed no distinct right was available with the victims’ organisations and NGOs leading the battles on behalf of those affected by the gas leak.

The Centre had in December 2010 filed the curative petition in the apex court seeking an order to the UCC for enhancing the settlement amount and reimbursement of relief and rehabilitation expenses incurred by the state and central governments. The petition was last heard four years ago and is pending final hearing. Now, the application filed by the UCC in the SC earlier this week has contended that in 1985 a scheme was framed under the Bhopal Act under which all individual claims were to be resolved through quasi-judicial proceedings.

WATCH VIDEO: White House Cites Clause To Keep Mum On Bhopal Gas Tragedy Plea

Subscriber Only Stories
UPSC Essentials | Weekly news express with MCQs: Adani-Hindenburg saga, M...
Anti-science movement is political but medicine also hasn’t conveyed its ...
In Jharkhand’s tribal villages, an online marketplace for local produce
Delhi Confidential: Mansukh Mandaviya gives a shout out to youngest Mitra

 

“The amount of compensation payable for the disaster, as defined under the Act, could only be litigated by the central government in respect of any claim…the disbursal of claims was governed by a statutory scheme, which is legislative in character, and it was placed before Parliament, and was given overriding effect over all other laws,” said the plea by senior lawyer Harish Salve.

Thus, the UCC argued, that any claim by anyone beyond the amount notified as payable under the scheme is misconceived. “The victims’ rights are now sounded in the Bhopal Act… and the notifications issued… by the central government under the scheme. If the non-applicants find fault with any of these (orders), they would have to challenge the actions of the Union of India — they cannot seek to become co-petitioners…all private parties have to appear through the Union of India and have no independent right of carriage of proceedings,” said the UCC.

Watch Video: What’s making news

Advertisement

 

It stated that these groups were neither parties to the original civil suit in Bhopal nor were they parties to the review petition in the SC whereby the settlement was affirmed. The UCC said that the bench had in 2011 allowed the impleadment of these groups but in the revised order, notices on the maintainability of these applications were also issued. Therefore, it said, until the court allows their impleadment, it should clarify that these groups were not co-petitioners.

First published on: 22-07-2016 at 04:54 IST
Next Story

Assets Case against Col Guraya: CBI special court rejects plea to summon defence witnesses

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
Advertisement
close