Updated: January 30, 2021 10:56:47 am
Anger against the three central farm legislations has been simmering since September. For the last three days, thousands of farmers from Punjab, Haryana, Rajasthan and Uttar Pradesh have been marching toward the national capital and are nearing the borders.
After failing to garner support from their respective state governments, the farmers have decided to mount pressure on the Union government, due to which they are coming to Delhi. While BJP governments in UP and Haryana have failed to convince farmers, governments of Rajasthan and Punjab have extended full support to their agitation. Farmers want the Union government to either withdraw the three legislations or guarantee them the minimum support price (MSP) for their crops by introducing a new law.
The Indian Express explains who these protestors are, and what has led to this situation where farmers are surrounding Delhi from all directions.
Farmers march to Delhi: Who is protesting?
Gurnam Singh Chaduni is leading the protestors from Haryana. Gurnam had contested the 2019 Assembly elections from Ladwa constituency in Kurukshetra district, but got only 1,307 votes. However, he was quite active in raising farmers’ issues and led several protests across the state. He entered the limelight again soon after the central government announced the three farm Bills. Gurnam is facing several criminal cases for leading the protests and causing disruption of law and order.
Apart from Gurnam, several national and regional farm unions, comprising many leaders, have joined hands under the umbrella banner of Samyukt Kisan Morcha.
This includes Rashtriya Kisan Mazdoor Sanghatan led by VM Singh; Jai Kisan Andolan led by Avik Saha and Dr Ashish Mital; All India Kisan Mazdoor Sabha led by V Venkataramaiah; All India Kisan Sabha led by Dr Ashok Dhawal, Hannan Mollah, Atul Kumar Anjaan and Bhupinder Samber; Krantikari Kisan Union led by Dr Darshan Pal; BKU (Dakaunda) led by Jagmohan Singh; ASHA-Kisan Swaraj led by Kavitha Kuruganti and Kiran Vissa; Karnataka Rajya Raitha Sangha led by Kodihalli Chandrasekhar; National Alliance for People’s Movements led by Medha Patkar; Lok Sangharsh Morcha led by Pratibha Shinde; All India Kisan Mahasabha led by Rajaram Singh and Premsingh Gehlawat; Swabhimani Shetkari Sanghatana led by Raju Shetti; Sangtin Kisan Mazdoor Sanghatan led by Richa Singh; Jamhoori Kisan Sabha led by Satnam Singh Ajnala; All India Kisan Khet Mazdoor Sanghatan led by Satyawan; Kisan Sangharsh Samiti led by Dr Sunilam; Terai Kisan Sabha led by Tajinder Singh Virk; and Jai Kisan Andolan led by Yogendra Yadav.
Other organisations include the BKU (Rajewal) led by Balbir Singh Rajewal; BKU (Chaduni) led by Gurnam Singh Chadhuni; Ganna Sangharsh Samiti in Bhadson led by Rampal Chahal; Ganna Sangharsh Samiti in Sahjadpur led by Vinod Rana; Kisan Sangharsh Samiti led by Satyawan Danoda; Rashtriya Kisan Mahasangh; and several factions of BKU and BKU (Ugrahan) led by Joginder Singh Ugrahan.
In a recent affidavit filed in the Punjab and Haryana High Court pertaining to the preventive arrests of several leaders, the Haryana government termed majority of these groups as “oganisations with history of indulging in criminal activities, creating law and order problems and disturbing public peace and order.”
Delhi Chalo march: Why are farmers angry?
Farmers do not accept the three new legislations — The Farmers’ Produce Trade and Commerce (Promotion and Facilitation); The Farmers (Empowerment and Protection) Agreement of Price Assurance; and Farm Services and The Essential Commodities (Amendment).
They believe the laws will open agricultural sale and marketing outside the notified Agricultural Produce Market Committee (APMC) mandis for farmers, remove the barriers to inter-state trade, and provide a framework for electronic trading of agricultural produce.
Since the state governments will not be able to collect market fee, cess or levy for trade outside the APMC markets, farmers believe the laws will gradually end the mandi system and leave farmers at the mercy of corporates.
Farmers believe that dismantling the mandi system will bring an end to the assured procurement of their crops at MSP. Similarly, farmers believe the price assurance legislation may offer protection to farmers against price exploitation, but will not prescribe the mechanism for price fixation.
Farmers are demanding the government guarantee MSP in writing, or else the free hand given to private corporate houses will lead to their exploitation.
The arhtiyas (commission agents) and farmers enjoy a friendship and bonding that goes back decades. On an average, at least 50-100 farmers are attached with each arhtiya, who takes care of farmers’ financial loans and ensures timely procurement and adequate prices for their crop. Farmers believe the new laws will end their relationship with these agents and corporates will not be as sympathetic towards them in times of need.
How did matters escalate to this situation?
Farmers in Punjab and Haryana are known for their adamant attitudes. Any use of force by the state further agitates them. In October, a month after the three farm legislations were enacted by the Centre, the Punjab Vidhan Sabha convened a special session and not only rejected the laws by a unanimous resolution but also passed three farm amendment Bills removing Punjab from the ambit of the central laws.
After Punjab did this, farmers in Haryana also sought support from their government. However, failing to get any response, farmers camped outside Deputy Chief Minister Dushyant Chautala and Power Minister Ranjit Chautala’s residences in Sirsa.
Dushyant and his party, the Jannayak Janata Party (JJP), have been calling themselves a farmer party and have a major vote bank among the rural population. But, Dushyant too sided with the BJP and supported the three central farm legislations.
Chief Minister Manohar Lal Khattar held talks with certain farmer unions, but failed to convince them of the new central laws. When farmers realised the Haryana government would not help them, they decided to march towards Delhi and mount pressure on the Union government.
In September too, farmers led by BKU president Gurnam Singh Chaduni blocked the Ambala-Delhi national highway for over three hours. Police cane-charged the protestors and registered criminal cases against them, including on charges of attempt to murder, further infuriating the farmers, who then subsequently called for a ‘Delhi Chalo’ march.
Do farmers have political backing? What has been the response of the governments at the Centre, Haryana and Punjab so far?
In Haryana, except for the ruling party BJP and its ally JJP, all political parties are backing farmers in their protest. The Congress, led by Bhupinder Singh Hooda, and INLD, led by Abhay Chautala, have openly supported the farmers’ agitation. It suits the opposition in Haryana to keep hammering the BJP on farmers’ issues and mounting pressure on the JJP to blackout from the alliance.
Raking up the farmers agitation has already yielded results for the Congress in the recently-held Baroda bypoll, where, despite all strength infused by BJP and JJP, the ruling alliance could not win.
Punjab, on the other hand, is a Congress-ruled state led by Captain Amarinder Singh. The main opposition party, Shiromani Akali Dal (SAD), led by Sukhbir Singh Badal, has already shown its support to farmers with Harsimrat Badal even resigning from her ministerial berth.
Farmers enjoy immense support in Punjab from both ruling and opposition parties. That was the reason farmers in Punjab kept protesting, blocking rail and road networks, since the state government extended its full support to them.
The Centre and Haryana governments had outrightly failed to convince farmers. Despite assurances given by Prime Minister Narendra Modi, several Union ministers and Haryana CM Khattar, farmers have refused to accept the legislations. BJP’s efforts, from social media campaigns to tractor rallies, to convince farmers have failed badly.
Don’t miss from Explained | Why protesting farmers are still talking of two 2018 private member Bills
Punjab, Haryana farmers protest: What can be expected now?
The situation is extremely volatile since the farmers are determined to enter Delhi and camp there. Farmers are carrying ration that can last months and are in no mood to turn back. Any use of force by the state may lead to a major law and order disruption.
The BJP in Haryana, however, is in a catch-22 situation. To enter Delhi, farmers have to cross through Haryana’s territory. The Haryana government has failed to prevent the swelling crowds of farmers that are coming in from both Rajasthan and Punjab — Congress-ruled states. The ruling party in Haryana also cannot afford another law and order disruption, since it suffered immense loss in 2019 Assembly polls due to such incidents during its first term. Barring Khattar and Anil Vij, the entire cabinet was wiped out.
Between 2014 and 2019, Haryana witnessed three major law and order situations: the Jat agitation, in which over 30 people were killed; the arrest of Dera Sacha Sauda chief Gurmeet Ram Rahim Singh, during which over 41 persons lost their lives; and the arrest of self-styled godman Rampal, in which over seven persons were killed.
In the current situation, the police has already used water canons and tear gas to disperse the agitated farmers — but both methods have failed.
📣 The Indian Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel (@indianexpress) and stay updated with the latest headlines
- The Indian Express website has been rated GREEN for its credibility and trustworthiness by Newsguard, a global service that rates news sources for their journalistic standards.