Among various scientific terms that the Covid-19 pandemic has made part of the public vocabulary, one is the ‘Ct value’ in RT-PCR tests for determining whether a patient is positive for Covid-19.
This was the subject of a recent request sent by the Maharashtra government to the Indian Council of Medical Research (ICMR). The state sought clarity whether it was advisable to treat a person as Covid-negative if the Ct value is more than 24 and the person is asymptomatic. State officials said various ICMR documents had mentioned different Ct values and there were divergent views even among Niti Aayog and the National Centre for Disease Control.
Days later, the ICMR DG wrote back to the state Health Secretary that ICMR has taken inputs from virology laboratories across the country to arrive at a single Ct value cut-off. All patients with a Ct value less than 35 may be considered as positive while those with a Ct value above 35 may be considered as negative, ICMR said.
Short for cycle threshold, Ct is a value that emerges during RT-PCR tests, the gold standard for detection of the SARS-CoV-2 coronavirus. In an RT-PCR test, RNA is extracted from the swab collected from the patient. It is then converted into DNA, which is then amplified. Amplification refers to the process of creating multiple copies of the genetic material — in this case, DNA. This improves the ability of the test to detect the presence of virus. Amplification takes place through a series of cycles — one copy becomes two, two becomes four, and so on — and it is after multiple cycles that a detectable amount of virus is produced.
According to the ICMR advisory, the Ct value of an RT-PCR reaction is the number of cycles at which fluorescence of the PCR product is detectable over and above the background signal. Put simply, the Ct value refers to the number of cycles after which the virus can be detected. If a higher number of cycles is required, it implies that the virus went undetected when the number of cycles was lower. The lower the Ct value, the higher the viral load — because the virus has been spotted after fewer cycles.
Newsletter | Click to get the day’s best explainers in your inbox
To put that in context, let us look at the ICMR advisory and Maharashtra’s letter to ICMR. According to the ICMR, a patient is considered Covid-positive if the Ct value is below 35. In other words, if the virus is detectable after 35 cycles or earlier, then the patient is considered positive. If the benchmark were to be lowered to 24 — the value mentioned in Maharashtra’s letter — it would mean that Ct values in the range 25-34 would not be considered positive. A benchmark of 35, therefore, means that more patients would be considered positive than we would get if the benchmark were 24. The ICMR has said lowering Ct threshold parameter may lead to missing several infectious persons.
One can think of Ct value as a measure of transmission potential, said leading virologist Dr Shahid Jameel. “So if there is more virus in my throat and nose, I will transmit it better,” said Dr Jameel, who is Director of the Trivedi School of Biosciences at Ashoka University.
Globally, the accepted cut-off for Ct value for Covid-19 ranges between 35 and 40, depending on instructions from the respective manufacturers of testing equipment. The ICMR has arrived at the Ct value of 35 based on laboratory experiences and inputs taken from several virology labs.
There was no new advisory, but ICMR informed the Maharashtra government that it was not advisable to use a lower cycle threshold parameter as it would lead to missing several infectious persons and increase disease transmission, Dr Balram Bhargava, DG of ICMR, has said.
No. Although Ct value is inversely correlated with viral load, It does not have any bearing on the severity of the disease, experts have said. A patient can have a low Ct value, which means her viral load is high enough to be detected rapidly, but she may still be asymptomatic.
A small study published in the Indian Journal of Medical Microbiology in January this year found that there was no correlation between Ct values and severity of disease or mortality in patients with Covid-19 disease. It found that the time since the onset of symptoms has a stronger relationship with Ct values as compared to the severity of the disease.
The Ct value tells us about the viral load in the throat and not in the lungs, said Dr Parikshit Prayag, consultant for infectious diseases at Deenanath Mangeshkar Hospital, Pune. “The Ct value does not correlate with severity – only with infectivity. In the first report I do not really look at the Ct value, but for follow -up of patients in the hospital, I do consider the Ct value, as then I can decide whether to transfer the patient to the non-Covid building or not. From the infectivity point of view, it can matter, not severity,” Dr Prayag said.
While that may be the obvious inference, some experts stress that some patients can have a high Ct value and yet have a very significant level of Covid-19 infection, and vice versa. Many factors are important in interpreting an RT-PCR test, and the results may also depend on the method of specimen collection and time from infection to collection and to analysis.
An ICMR advisory in August last year noted that Ct values depend on how the sample has been collected. A poorly collected sample may reflect inappropriate Ct values. Besides, Ct values are also determined by the technical competence of the person performing the test, calibration of the equipment, and the analytical skills of the interpreters.
Again, Ct values may differ between nasal and oropharyngeal specimens collected from the same individual. The temperature of transportation, as well as the time taken from collection to receipt in the lab, can also adversely impact Ct values.
📣 The Indian Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel (@indianexpress) and stay updated with the latest headlines