3 min readNew DelhiSep 16, 2020 09:08 AM IST
First published on: Sep 16, 2020 at 08:59 AM IST
The recent judgment of the Supreme Court on the licence fee payable by operators to the Department of Telecommunications (DoT), also known as the “AGR” decision, brings the curtains down on a case that has been under litigation since 2003.
The final decision gives telcos 10 years to make good the payment.
Where does this leave the market?
Vodafone-Idea or Vi is the most affected. Its liability is nearly Rs 54,000 crore and even with a 10-year horizon, it is unclear whether this will be enough to prevent a bankruptcy and establish a virtual duopoly. Vi has reported a net loss of Rs 73,878 crore in FY 2020.
Meanwhile, Airtel owes approximately Rs 26,000 crore in licence fee dues. For one of the lowest-priced markets in the world, raising tariffs would be an obvious strategy.
Explained Ideas: Could war with India be an attempt to restore Xi’s shaky political position in China?
According to estimates by Jefferies Equity Research, Airtel will have to increase ARPUs (average revenue per user, a surrogate for price) by 10 per cent and Vi by 27 per cent to completely offset the impact of AGR dues.
\This, however, is not a one-sided decision and will depend on its rival response. Given there has already been one round of tariff increase, there is little room for another hike.
What other instruments can one consider to stimulate and fortify competition in Indian telecom without which our $1 trillion digital ambition will remain on paper?
📣 Express Explained is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel (@ieexplained) and stay updated with the latest
With reports of network quality deteriorating by almost 20 per cent, the need of the hour is to augment network capacity immediately and be future-ready when 5G comes along. These investments are unlikely given the current financial health of the sector.
“One option could be to put some cash in the hands of operators by abolishing the licence fee based on AGR, prospectively. This could be the much-needed shot in the arm and could be treated as part of the stimulus package for telecom,” suggest Rajat Kathuria and Isha Suri of ICRIER.
“In any case, there seems to be little justification in auctioning spectrum and also levying additional charges,” they argue. “Having introduced spectrum auctions, the government could forsake other forms of licence fee. A nominal administrative fee could be charged instead to administer licences as is the practice in other countries”.
IPL 2020 begins: Here are plans offered by Disney+ Hotstar at discounted rates (Photographer: Dhiraj Singh/Bloomberg) 
Share
