New Delhi | April 5, 2013 1:50:34 pm
Director: David Dhawan
The Indian Express rating: **
Half an hour into the film,I was in danger of actually liking Chashme Baddoor. The three boys were strenuously playing their parts,which ran on the expected ‘ladki- pe- line-maarna and- juvenile-jokes- crack karna’ tracks. The lines were cheesy but briskly executed,and the pace just as brisk,the way David Dhawan used to manage it back when he made zippy comedies filled with laugh-out-loud gags.
Yes,this was a copy of Sai Paranjpyes classic feel-good 1981 romance Chashme Buddoor,even though back then it was called simply a ‘family entertainer’. Yes,it was sacrilege,all this remake-‘shemake’ business,even if it was wrapped nobly in the guise of bringing a beloved story to an audience not born when the film first came out. But David Dhawan in his good days had his own way of making us laugh,and who knew,this could turn out to be a rib-tickler,inimitable DD style. I was quite prepared to see it as a film on its own,and when it began and picked up pace after a couple of hiccups,it seemed as if it was going to succeed. The vibe was youthful,and the trio plus the girl of their dreams were trying hard,and the laughs were flowing.
Sid,Jai and Omi (Zafar,Siddharth and Divyendu) are transplanted from the originals early 80s Delhi to todays Goa. Instead of a genial ‘paanwaala’,they perpetually owe money to a heavily- tattooed café owner Joseph Furtado (Kapoor) as well as to their landlady,Miss Josephine (Dubey). A romantic thread between Kapoor and Dubey is an add-on,and it starts with a smile,but these old-timers end up making you groan because they are responsible for ruining an iconic moment from the original.
And that is how the film pans out soon after the spry beginning,leaving you wincing. Because Dhawans film is a series of forced contrivances,not a story that grows out of a place and time. His characters dont feel like they are good friends who live together. They feel like they have just come together for the shot. Neither do they mesh well,nor do they work Individually as well as they should: Ali Zafars laid back tone is all too familiar,Divyendu is not half as funny as he was in his debut,Pyaar Ka Punchnama,and the very energetic Siddharth contorts himself a bit too much. Taapsee is the only one who feels real,and stays likeable despite the occasional fumble with lines.
The seasoned supporting cast is ill-used. Anupam Kher has been like this in too many movies. Bharti Achrekar can do better than go about administering slaps on assorted faces,that dreadful running thread in so many Dhawan outings. But it is Rishi Kapoor one feels most for: as a biker with a mobile waist-and-heart,he should have been one of the best things about the film. But except a move or two on the dance floor,Kapoor doesnt have a true moment. And his café,called Nostalgia,becomes an ironic descriptor,making us long for the original (Sai Paranjypes Chashme Buddoor is also out in theatres today : do watch if you havent already).
Why remake a classic if you cant improve upon it? Truly bad-door.
📣 The Indian Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel (@indianexpress) and stay updated with the latest headlines
- The Indian Express website has been rated GREEN for its credibility and trustworthiness by Newsguard, a global service that rates news sources for their journalistic standards.