This is an archive article published on April 29, 2025
Another Simple Favour movie review: Anna Kendrick and Blake Lively reprise their roles in the sequel that adds more twists
Another Simple Favour movie review: The story of a warped female friendship though mostly entertaining, runs out of steam when it crams too much into its proceedings
Another Simple Favour movie review: In this sequel to A Simple Favour (2018), the story shifts to the gorgeous Italian island Capri, surrounded by azure waters, from the cozy Connecticut suburb while retaining its pulpy tone and holding promises of multiple twists and turns. Never once the dark comedy, with a warped female-friendship at its centre, lets the audience be lulled by the fairytale-like setting. As Stephanie Smothers (Anna Kendrick) and Emily Nelson (Blake Lively) are back together — this time, as a maid of honour and to-be-bride — deception and vendetta are expected to spice up the cat-and-mouse game between them.
As the two leading actresses reprise their roles, they do what they do best — Lively struts around in bejewelled stilettos and attention-grabbing couture while Kendrick channels her ‘desperate housewife’ vibes. Stephanie is not seeking constant validation now that she has gained recognition as a ‘mommy blogger’ and self-appointed sleuth who tries to solve local crimes. She, however, is desperate to boost the sale of her book ‘The Faceless Blonde’, which is based on Emily and her unlawful activities.
When Emily, who was imprisoned for murdering her father and her twin sister, walks into Stephanie’s book reading at a store, and asks her to be her maid of honour at her wedding in Capri with a mob heir, Stephanie sees this as an opportunity to sell more copies. She even sees the possibility of writing another book based on her favourite subject — Emily — even though she suspects Emily is plotting revenge against her.
(L to R) Blake LIvely, Michele Morrone, Alex Newell and Anna Kendrick in Another Simple Favor.
The film retains its vigour as long as these two are engaged in a game of one-upmanship and quick on repartee. Some scenes border on being slapstick while some demand suspension of disbelief. Strangely, Kendrick and Lively in spite of sharing what can be described as a ‘toxic’ friendship are connected to each other. They make their connection believable. Both their characters are capable of doing something bizarre and introduce a turn in the narrative. It is this unpredictability that keeps the film edgy.
Kendrick, especially shines in the scenes where she doggedly tries to capitalise on her weird scenario by vlogging or going after things that might prove to be too dangerous for her. Lively’s performance brings out Emily’s slyness while her fashion game remains top-notch.
While A Simple Favour’s climax packed some crazy revelations and actions, the last half an hour of the sequel becomes a victim of its makers’ ambition to dial up the thrill. Writers (Jessica Sharzer and Laeta Kalogridis) cram the story with too many twists, turns and complex sibling emotions. With that, the narrative runs out of steam and drags.
Yet, the sequel bears the familiarity of the original’s tone and manages to weave an enjoyable thriller around two flawed mothers. It lets women be mean, manipulative, dangerous as well as loving and caring. With that, they are doing a favour when it comes to breaking the mould of women characters in a typical entertaining movie.
Story continues below this ad
Another Simple Favour movie director: Paul Feig Another Simple Favour movie cast: Anna Kendrick, Blake Lively, Henry Golding, Michele Morrone, Allison Janney Another Simple Favour movie rating: Two and a half stars
Another Simple Favour will stream on Amazon Prime Video from May 1.
Alaka Sahani is a prominent film critic and journalist based in Mumbai. With a career spanning over two decades, she has established herself as one of India’s most authoritative voices in cinematic journalism, known for an analytical approach and insights that transcend the standard cycle of celebrity journalism.
Expertise & Accolades
In 2014, Alaka was honoured with the National Film Award for Best Film Critic. Her Swarna Kamal (Golden Lotus) citation specifically lauded her for "highlighting facets of cinema beyond glamour and gossip" and for her ability to delve into the contemporary relevance of iconic filmmakers. Her commitment to journalistic integrity was further recognised in 2019 with a Special Mention at the Red Ink Awards for her investigative feature, 'In Search of a Star'. Her article titled 'People Like Us', published in The Indian Express on March 27, 2022, was shortlisted for Red Ink Award, 2023.
Global Industry Leadership
Alaka’s expertise is sought after by major international and domestic film bodies:
Golden Globes: In 2025, she joined the international voting body for the 83rd Annual Golden Globes.
National Film Awards: She served on the prestigious jury for the 68th National Film Awards, helping select the finest contributions to Indian cinema.
Global Perspective: Her work consistently bridges the gap between commercial Bollywood A-listers and emerging independent talents, offering nuanced insights into both Indian regional cinema and international film trends.
Focus & Vision
Beyond the screen, Alaka is a dedicated observer of Mumbai’s vibrant theatre scene and the historical evolution of the moving image. Through her long-form articles and deep-dive interviews, she continues to challenge "tried-and-tested" templates, providing readers with a deep understanding of the artistic and systemic workings of the Indian and global film industry. ... Read More
(L to R) Blake LIvely, Michele Morrone, Alex Newell and Anna Kendrick in Another Simple Favor.