This is an archive article published on December 16, 2024
Madhur Bhandarkar says he is ‘not the flag bearer’ of women-centric cinema, reveals he was asked to add 6 item songs in Chandni Bar
At a recently held event in Mumbai, Madhur Bhandarkar spoke about the Justice Hema Committee report and the challenges women-centric films face even today.
National Award-winning filmmaker Madhur Bhandarkar was part of a panel discussion at Cine Talkies 2024 held by Sansar Bharti in Mumbai. At the event, Bhandarkar spoke about issues he faced while making women-centric films. While talking to SCREEN, the filmmaker also commented on the Hema Committee report.
He said, “A stringent law is already there. All the people named in the wake of Hema Committee are facing the law. So let that take its course. Even during MeToo a lot of allegations came about, a lot of people were banned too. So action was taken.”
Madhur Bhandarkar also spoke about how the female-led film Chandni Bar, starring Tabu in the lead role, was a game-changer for him. The filmmaker said, “When I started making films, the atmosphere was about commercial cinema. It needed to have a mass appeal. I didn’t want to make those films, but I did because I was getting a break. Chandni Bar was the sunrise in my career, from there, the perception changed.”
He added, “For Chandni Bar, I had to go to so many people. They said it was a good subject but asked me to put 6 item songs in it. I was reluctant to do that. Very few producers want to back women-centric cinema.”
While talking about the gender and pay disparity in Bollywood, Madhur Bhandarkar pointed out how Tabu, Kareena Kapoor, and Priyanka Chopra slashed their fees for him. “10 years back, they would say only Madhur can make a film in that budget, we cannot. People were reluctant. I remember Kareena Kapoor, Tabu, Priyanka Chopra cutting their fees to do my films. Higher fees would add to budget constraints. It has been difficult. Even male actors should consider reducing their fees for a woman-centric film.”
Madhur Bhandarkar further advised filmmakers to pursue women-centric cinema, adding that it is a work in progress. He said, “Everybody will keep giving free advice, but you should do what you like. Chandni Bar was trashed by critics; they called it depressing. During Fashion, people said it was better to watch a fashion show than this film. These things shouldn’t bog us down. Today, Laapataa Ladies is being talked about globally because its content was strong. Chandni Bar had to compete with Gadar, Kabhi Khushi Kabhie Gham, Lagaan, etc, but it still got nominated at all awards show.”
Story continues below this ad
“Women-centric films are not backed completely. Even today if I go with a subject to anyone, they will give a budget of Rs 20-22 crores. Then that producer will only propose to have the story male-led and will be willing to give a budget of Rs 50-60 crores. That gender and pay disparity still exist, so yes, it’s still a work in progress,” the filmmaker added.
Madhur Bhandrakar also recalled how he faced problems casting male actors in his films. “I have faced a problem casting heroes for my films. They didn’t want to do it because the focus was on women. I have an image that if I make a film, it would revolve around women only. Then we have to cast newcomers. In the past, Rishi Kapoor has done movies in which women had a bigger role, for example, Nagina. That time actor’s would do this, but now there is an entire facade where actors want to know how many scenes they have, etc. Now they want to just do solo hero/heroine films.”
On a concluding note, Bhandarkar stated, “I am not the flag bearer of women-centric cinema. Bimal Roy, Kamaal Amrohiji, Guru Duttji, Shyam Benegal, Raj Kapoor sahab also made such films. In the 80s came the wave of masala potboiler films, in which women-centric cinema got lost somewhere. Chandni Bar was the first film that released alongside big films and broke that mould about women-centric cinema. The percentage for women-centric films is still less because people have the tendency to ask who is the hero; nobody ever asks who is the heroine. That mindset needs to change. Actresses should get as big an opening at the box office as the heroes; they will be paid well then. Today actresses are scared that if they do a female-led film and it doesn’t work, it will affect their image. That is why they are okay to do a few scenes in a big film led by a hero.”
Nawaz Javed Kochra is a seasoned entertainment journalist at The Indian Express Online, bringing nearly a decade of expertise to the forefront of cultural reporting. With a focus on the television and Over-The-Top (OTT) landscapes, he has established himself as a prominent voice in the industry, known for his high-profile celebrity interviews and insightful coverage of the Indian entertainment sector.
Experience & Career
Nawaz holds a Master of Arts in Communication and Journalism from Mumbai University, providing him with a rigorous academic and ethical foundation. In his 11-year career, he has navigated through several of India's leading media houses, building a portfolio that spans digital, print, and broadcast media:
The Indian Express: Currently leads coverage of TV and OTT content, producing both written analysis and popular video interview segments.
Former Roles: He began his career at the iconic Stardust Magazine and later held key positions at Zoom TV, Zee Multimedia, MissMalini, Bollywood Bubble, and Raindrop Media.
Expertise & Focus Areas
Nawaz’s beat is characterized by a blend of exclusive access and trend analysis. His core areas of expertise include:
Reality Television: Specialized coverage of major franchises like Bigg Boss, providing behind-the-scenes insights and winner profiles.
OTT Ecosystem: Tracking the shift from traditional cable to digital streaming platforms, with a focus on web series and digital premieres.
Celebrity Profiles & Interviews: Nawaz is celebrated for his ability to foster candid conversations with industry stalwarts, from music composers like Amaal Mallik to other TV legends.
Investigative Entertainment News: Reporting on sensitive industry developments, including legal disputes and personal stories of resilience within the acting community.
Authoritativeness & Trust
With a reputation built on years of networking and credible reporting, Nawaz Kochra is a "known face" in the Mumbai media circuit. His work at The Indian Express adheres to the publication's "Journalism of Courage" standard, ensuring that even entertainment reporting is approached with accuracy, sensitivity, and transparency. His educational background and extensive tenure across diverse media platforms provide him with the authoritative perspective required to analyze the rapid evolution of Indian show business. ... Read More