Thursday, Sep 29, 2022

‘Step to protect men from wives’ fake complaints not enough’

Taking cognisance of the increasing number of false complaints being filed under section 498A of the Indian Penal Code...

Centre’s directive to states say no arrests be made without proper investigation

Taking cognisance of the increasing number of false complaints being filed under section 498A of the Indian Penal Code (IPC),the Central Government recently issued directives to the state governments not to make any immediate arrests but conduct thorough investigations before taking any action. However,family court lawyers and activists feel that unless women are punished for lodging false complaints,this directive would not help.

“Though the directive is welcome,unless the women are punished by law for filing false cases under Section 498A,its misuse cannot be stopped,” said Mahesh Kalge,a representative of Save Indian Family Foundation (SIFF),who runs a helpline for men in distress caused by domestic disputes.

Mahesh (name changed),an IT professional from Chinchwad,had to spent a week in the lock-up after his wife filed a harassment complaint with the police.

Subscriber Only Stories
The Kohinoor, Cullinan and the enduring demand for reparations across the...Premium
Terror links to training sites to targeted killings: Govt’s case against PFIPremium
In Gujarat, the National Games, garba and the start of election feverPremium
G-20 presidency is an opportunity to position India as the voice of the G...Premium

“In most cases,the investigating officer immediately arrests the husband,mother-in-law and sister-in-law,as per the statement given by the wife. However,when the allegations prove false,the investigating officer is never held at fault. It is time the judiciary take this into account,” said Mahesh.

“This directive,if implemented strictly,will surely put a tab on the misuse of this section. Of the total cases filed under this section in one year,85 per cent turn out to be bogus,” said advocate Shailaja Kelkar,matrimonial counselor who practiced in the family court for 20 years. There should be a provision in the law where husbands can sue their wives for making false allegations. Women take to filing such false complaints with an eye on compensation or husband’s property,Kelkar observed.

In a letter to state chief secretaries,the Ministry of Home Affairs has asked the state governments to issue directives to the police not to arrest the husband and his relatives without checking the genuineness of the anti-dowry complaint.


The MHA wants the arrests to be the last resort and has asked the state police to ensure that the law doesn’t become a tool in the hands of disgruntled women to settle scores with their husbands and in-laws.

First published on: 17-11-2009 at 05:23:54 am
Next Story

Farmers’ new idea: arranging flowers to brighten their lives

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments