The Film and Television Institute (FTII) of India’s student association has reiterated its demand to halt the admission process as it said that explanations provided by the university about alleged discrepancies in merit lists were not satisfactory even as authorities said full transparency had been provided to student representatives in a meeting with the Vice Chancellor on Monday.
The FTII has accepted that an initial merit list had ‘calculation-based errors’ and published a revised list, with extra candidates selected as a one-time measure. However, the student body on Sunday had raised issues with the final merit list, questioning deviation from government mandated reservation percentages and lack of clarity over when during the admission process were the reservation categories frozen. The Masters of Fine Arts (Screen Acting) final merit list had 8.7 per cent Scheduled Caste and 4.35 per cent Scheduled Tribe candidates, lower than the government mandated percentage of 15 per cent and 7.5 per cent respectively. FTII authorities held a meeting with the student body on Monday to provide clarifications. In its latest statement, the student body has said that the issue still remains unresolved.
Unlike the FTII admission process for this year, reservation is applied at the last round of admissions in most entrance tests, claims the student’s association. Further, it has questioned the application of 1998 Department of Personnel Training (DoPT) OM, which the FTII is relying on, which applies to job recruitments in government departments to an admission process.
A statement issued by the student association said, “The decisions made by the administration to rectify the errors through the revised merit lists are absurd and have been made in an opaque manner…The FTII administration must also immediately publish the results of Stage 1 and Stage 2 (with public disclosure of external experts’ signatures on the marks list of each course) of the FTII entrance test (Including the separate results of Paper 1 and Paper 2 with marking and reservation categories).
In response to this issue, the FTII shared a statement with The Indian Express, that said, “… these (added) seats are outside the purview of reservation matrix as supernumerary measure…In the nine extra supernumerary temporary seats spread over three courses, though they are outside reservation matrix, contain 1 SC, 1 ST, 2 EWS, 3 OBC NCL and 2 General category candidates.”
The statement also said that as per government rules, if a candidate has availed reservation benefits at any stage of a process, the candidate is ‘deemed non available’ for unreserved seats. “Legal and administrative provisions like 1998 DOPT OM guide the migration among the reservation categories. Comprehensive Reservation Policy is mentioned in the prospectus, which needs to be read in conjunction with existing Government of India rules,” it read. The statement added that the DoPT had a pan-government applicability.
The institute also wrote, “Furthermore, it may be noted that while first stage of written exam is used to eliminate some candidates but it is not a merely qualifying exam as the marks received at that stage are part of overall marks which decide merit.”
On the issue of seat preference, FTII said according to the admission prospectus, if a student is allotted a seat which is their “only seat/ preference – 1 of the seat allocation”, the same is auto-freezed, and the student does not have a claim on the second preference of seat in the further rounds.
FTII said that access to data and details about external expert marks had already been provided to student representatives for inspection, and that all candidates will be provided stage-wise marks. Cut off marks of every stage will also be published, the university has assured.