3 min readMumbaiFeb 25, 2026 11:05 PM IST
First published on: Feb 25, 2026 at 11:05 PM IST
Expressing “shock” over a Thane Municipal Corporation (TMC) officer seeking time to entertain a regularisation application for a hospital operating inside a residential society despite admitting it lacked permissions, the Bombay High Court on Wednesday initiated contempt proceedings against him.
A bench of Justices Ravindra V Ghuge and Abhay J Mantri was hearing a writ petition filed by New Devashish Co-operative Housing Society Ltd, argued through advocate Suresh Sabrad, against the continuation of a hospital inside a flat in a residential tower building.
The petitioner society had also alleged that LPG and oxygen cylinders were stored on the terrace of the building and that piping had been laid from the terrace to the hospital operating from a flat.
The HC noted that it had disposed of the plea on November 14, 2025, after Maheshkumar Jamnor, Assistant Municipal Commissioner, Naupada-Kopri ward committee, assured the court that the offending structure would be inspected and remedial action initiated and completed by February 15. However, the court observed on Wednesday that the said order had been “disobeyed” by the Thane Municipal Corporation.
Appearing for the civic body, TMC’s counsel, on instructions from Jamnor—who was present in court—submitted that the site had been inspected and that empty oxygen cylinders were stacked on the terrace. He further stated that no permission of the Corporation had been taken to operate the hospital and that a request for regularisation of a hospital inside a residential flat owners’ tower building could not be granted.
“Yet a request is made that the matter be adjourned for 15 days so that the regularisation application of the concerned hospital may be entertained. We are shocked by the conduct of the Corporation and we are amazed by the courage of the officer who is before the court seeking extension of time for disobeying our order on the ‘spacious’ plea that regularisation can be granted. We are therefore constrained to issue suo motu contempt notice under the Contempt of Courts Act to Jamnor,” the HC noted in its order.
The court granted Jamnor seven days to submit his affidavit in reply and “test the notice if he so desires”.
Expressing concern over the “demeanour” of the officer in court, the HC further observed, “Though the officer was standing in front of the court, he had the audacity of not even whispering an apology note. This is the level of arrogance of these officers. Somewhere the High Court’s discipline must go down deep into the roots of such instrumentalities and institutions.”
After the officer attempted to apologise, Justice Ghuge orally remarked, “You are losing respect for the High Court. As long as I am here, I will take it upon myself that these institutions will start respecting the High Court. Keep that in mind.”
A division bench of Justices Riyaz I Chagla and Advait M Sethna allowed a petition filed by anaesthesiologist Dhanashri Ramesh Karkhanis, who was employed on a contractual basis as an Assistant Professor (Anaesthesiology) at Seth G S Medical College and KEM Hospital (File Photo) 
Share
