April 19, 2012 1:13:09 am
Litigatious, argumentative and has done nothing in the interest of the university – one can never wish to be described in these terms in his academia. However,if ones character certificate reads like this,it is indeed startling.
When Hamidur Rahman,a final-year BA (Hons) students at the Jamia Milia Islamia,applied for his character certificate last month,he could not have been more wrong about the adjectives he anticipated his head of department will use to delineate him.
This is to certify that Rahman is litigatious and argumentative in his nature,as per the information and records available in this office… As an three year-undergraduate student,he has done nothing in the interest of the university and he is not an active participant in the campus life, stated Rahmans character certificate dated March 22.
Incidentally,the rationale behind calling him litigatious could be his petition pending before the Delhi High Court. In his PIL,Rahman has sought a direction to the university administration to conduct polls to the students union,which remains dissolved since 2006.
Subscriber Only Stories
Close on the heels of JNU students testing the political waters in their student election following the Supreme Court nod,a bench of Justices S K Kaul and Rajiv Shakdher had in February directed the university to file a detailed affidavit,incorporating its reasons why the election to the students union cannot be held.
On Wednesday,Rahmans counsel Sitab Ali Chaudhary not only argued against the stance of the JMI on not holding polls but also adduced before the Bench his character certificate,issued by the head of the Political Science department.
This is unjust and grossly unfair to a student,who has been the topper of his department for the last two years and has won several prizes in intra-college and inter-college competitions. How can he be described like this if not but for prejudice and bias since he has moved the court against the university, contended Chaudhary.
The bench said: This is not appropriate. It appears that such a certificate is issued only because he has filed a PIL in the court. One must not be harassed on this count. We would want the university to look into it and issue him a fresh certificate accordingly, Justice Kaul told the universitys counsel.
Jamias counsel Atyab Siddiq assured the court that he will take up the issue with the Vice-Chancellor to do the needful.
On the question of conducting students election,the university cited several untoward incidents in the past to underline that academic discipline shall be prejudiced with the holding of the election and claimed that existing system of forming subject associations for every department was god enough.
Chaudhary opposed this and said that Jamia students could not be deprived of democratic rights under these pretexts.
After hearing their arguments,the court ordered Jamia to form a committee to look into the issue.
📣 Join our Telegram channel (The Indian Express) for the latest news and updates
- The Indian Express website has been rated GREEN for its credibility and trustworthiness by Newsguard, a global service that rates news sources for their journalistic standards.