On the day she would have turned 19,Arushi Talwars parents Rajesh and Nupur Talwar were charged with her murder and destruction of evidence.
A Ghaziabad court today framed charges against the dentist couple for the 2008 murder of their daughter and domestic help Hemraj under Indian Penal Code Sections 302/34 (murder with common intention) and 201/34 (destruction of evidence with common intention). Special judge Shyam Lal also charged Rajesh under Section 203(giving false information with respect to an offence committed).
Arushi was murdered on the night of May 15-16,2008. She was found dead in bed with her throat slit and injuries on the head. At first,the needle of suspicion pointed towards Hemraj who was missing. A day later,his body was found on the terrace of the house.
Ruling on the charges,the court said formal drafting of the charges would take place tomorrow after the Talwars are asked whether they plead guilty or not guilty.
CBI counsel R K SainiI said: Tomorrow is basically a procedural matter. The court will ask whether they want to plead guilty or not. After that,charges will be framed and a date for the beginning of trial in the case will be announced. The prosecution will be asked to begin the examination of evidence and witnesses.
On Wednesday,the counsel representing the Talwars had argued that simply because the Talwars were the only persons in the house could not be reason enough to charge them with murder. The counsel said injuries of the victims did not match those that could have been caused from a golf club the CBI had claimed that the golf club was the murder weapon.
The counsel claimed that Hemraj and his friends consumed alcohol,tried to misbehave with Arushi and,when she resisted,one of them killed her. Hemraj was then killed on the roof,the counsel said.
But the CBI maintained that the wounds matched the dimensions of a golf club exactly. Accusing the Talwars of destroying evidence,the agency alleged that the couple would have disposed Hemrajs body as well if they had access to a vehicle that night.
In a six-page order,special judge Shyam Lal said: There seems to be enough evidence against the accused to continue with proceedings as per the charges.
He said there seemed to be no provocation to discharge the Talwars as they were accused of not only killing their only daughter but their domestic help as well.
There is no requirement at this stage to examine all the evidence in depth as that is a matter for cross-examination during the trial, the judge said.