This is an archive article published on December 27, 2023

‘No copyright in ideas’: Delhi HC rejects interim plea against broadcast of Yash Raj Films’ ‘Shamshera’

The plaintiff, Bikramjeet Singh Bhullar, claimed that the film infringes the copyright in his script titled ‘Kabu Na Chhadein Khet’. The court agreed with Yashraj's contention that there can be no copyright in a story on account of it being a "period drama".

delhi high court on shamshera release(Representative/File Photo)

The Delhi High Court has dismissed an application seeking interim relief against Yash Raj Films from broadcasting, and distributing the film Shamshera in theatres, television channels or on OTT platforms in a lawsuit by one Bikramjeet Singh Bhullar, claiming that the film infringes the copyright in his script titled ‘Kabu Na Chhadein Khet’ (KNCK).

A single judge bench of Justice Jyoti Singh in its December 20 order observed that the treatment meted out to the story of Shamshera is in many ways, “makes it different from the script” of Bhullar.

“Analysing the script of the plaintiff and the film of the defendants closely on a prima facie view, the court finds that the KNCK script revolves around fights and battles between the Afghans who repeatedly made attempts to invade Indian territories and the Sikhs in the 18th century with the ultimate defeat of Ahmad Shah in 1763…The film, on the other hand, is a story of oppression of the lower caste at the hands of the upper caste and this thread runs in the entire film. From the beginning to the end, the oppression of the lower caste is inextricably woven into the story from their being outcasted into the desert and finally into the jungle from the main town and the other elements include, being tricked and taken captive in the Kaza Fort; looting the upper caste in retaliation and finding a leader to fight the upper caste etc,” the HC said.

Justice Singh said that the ideas in Bhullar’s script cannot be given copyright protection and more so in the stock elements and a comparison of the script and the film “does not leave an impression that one is a substantial copy of the other”.

The court also agreed with Yashraj’s contention that there can be no copyright in a story on account of it being a “period drama”.

The court held that there cannot be a copyright protection in themes, plots, or ideas.

“There are multiple examples of films in the past within this genre including the one with which the plaintiff initially had problem i.e. Kesari but had given up the objection fairly on finding the same to be substantially different. While the script is on the villages of Punjab and its inhabitants, facing oppression by Afghan invaders, the film (Shamshera) centres on casteism i.e. upper caste oppressing the lower castes and forcing them to leave the main town and live in forests,” the bench said.

Story continues below this ad

Comparison of locations set in North India, as rightly contended by the Defendants, cannot be a ground to hold infringement of copyright and similarly features such as burning oil, water, birds, star for the purpose of navigation, secret underwater tunnels horses, ghaghra and its unswirling, sensuous scenes etc., have been used in movies from times immemorial and very many movies come to mind on this aspect readily and are hackneyed subjects of almost every fiction and matters of common grasp,” the HC said.

Justice Singh who stated that there is no doubt that writers must be given their due, however, said the plaintiff had been unable to make out a prima facie case of copyright infringement and thus no relief can be granted in favour of Bhullar.

The court went on to reject Bhullar’s application for interim injunction.

The main lawsuit is next listed on January 16, 2024.

Advertisement
Loading Recommendations...
Advertisement
Advertisement
Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments