The police had a photograph. They found the man in it and took him away. Checking whether he had written the offending Instagram comment came later, during a roadside halt on the journey to the station. That, according to police sources involved in securing his return, was how A Kalaiyarasan, an economist who studies the workings of the state, encountered how it really operates at 5 am on Wednesday.
Three plainclothes policemen arrived at his Adyar home on October 28, took his phone and put him in a rented car, he wrote in a complaint to the Director General of Police. Their destination was T4 Sankar Nagar police station in Pammal, south of Chennai city. The alleged offence: An abusive comment targeting Pallavaram TVK MLA J Kamatchi.
Their passenger said he did not even have an Instagram account. The sequence began with complaints from Kamatchi’s team about sustained online abuse, according to police sources. Progress was slow, but pressure from the MLA’s office grew, and local officers picked up some complaints for action.
ALSO READ | ‘Who are you?’: A simple introduction blows Delhi cops’ cover
One concerned an account with the display name Vijaya Manikandan (@youvijayamani) and Kalaiyarasan’s photograph. According to a senior officer, officers ran a Google reverse image search, identified the person and reached his doorstep. The search established whose face it was. Whether the account belonged to him remained unchecked.
“They did not furnish any document authorising the inquiry, not even a copy of the complaint or FIR,” Kalaiyarasan later wrote in his letter to the State Police Chief.
An associate professor at the Madras Institute of Development Studies (MIDS), he said he tried explaining that he knew neither the account nor the MLA. He was taken away in his nightclothes, without an opportunity to inform his family. A photograph ordinarily used to introduce a scholar had become, in the officers’ hands, a reason to remove him from his home before he could explain himself.
After the car crossed Guindy, repeated requests won him a few minutes with his phone. He contacted friends. Those calls changed the direction of the morning. “Our officers were at fault,” the officer said.
His friends alerted the state police’s highest levels, according to sources, after 7 am. Instructions travelled down the hierarchy as senior officers tried to locate the team that had collected a professor from Chennai before dawn.
The officers were traced near Chennai International Airport, travelling toward Pammal, and told to stop, the sources said. Kalaiyarasan’s complaint describes a roadside wait in Pallavaram lasting about 45 minutes, with several calls made and received.
The preliminary verification now began, with the person already in the car. Once the mistake became clear, the team headed home.
During the return journey, Kalaiyarasan said, officers showed him the screenshot. He suspected his photograph had been lifted from Harvard University’s website, where he had been a research affiliate. At his apartment, he had to provide a written denial of any connection with the account. His phone was returned. He was home around 7.45 am.
Dr M Suresh Babu, the Director of the Madras Institute of Development Studies (MIDS), said they came to know of the incident involving an MIDS faculty member. “As an academic institution, we are concerned by the hardship caused to the faculty member. I hope that the offenders are booked at the earliest,” he told The Indian Express.
ALSO READ | Sam Antony had a new name for every new life. Police chased him for 30 years
A political fallout
The episode soon acquired political explanations online. Kalaiyarasan co-authored ‘The Dravidian Model: Interpreting the Political Economy of Tamil Nadu’, published by Cambridge University Press, with M Vijayabaskar. Closely associated with Dravidian intellectual circles, he also appears occasionally in television debates.
One senior officer offered a less elaborate explanation. “TVK leaders or constables or officers in Pammal police station never knew about the existence of the professor, his book, and his academic works; they all came to know about it only after this incident,” the officer said.
For the professor, the experience involved a disturbing reversal. Someone allegedly stole his photograph, but he had to account for what the stranger did with it. “Moreover, I am the victim in this case,” he wrote.
His complaint seeks action over the alleged unlawful detention and the misuse of his photograph. He also warned of the effect on public debate. “It is frightening to think that the police can knock on someone’s door in the early hours and take them away for no fault of their own,” he wrote to the DGP.
By Thursday morning, the episode had reached former Chief Minister M K Stalin, who was unconvinced by the mistaken-identity explanation. He asked whether the police had deliberately collected a critic.
In a statement, the DMK president alleged that Kalaiyarasan had been targeted for exposing rising prices under the TVK government, questioned whether his work on the Dravidian model had also made him a target, and demanded a public apology from Chief Minister Vijay and the police.