The Punjab and Haryana High Court on Tuesday asked the Chandigarh Administration to reconsider within one month its decision not to allot land opposite the high court museum for the construction of advocates chambers.
A division bench, comprising Justices S K Mittal and H S Sidhu, passed the order after the Conservator of Forests clarified that the five acre land, which the High Court Bar Association wants for construction of advocates’ chambers, is not a notified reserved forest area.
The court said that the administration should consider the case, “keeping in view the dire need of land for advocates’ chambers because proper dispensation of justice is not possible for the courts without the able assistance of advocates’’.
The bench observed there are only 131 advocates’ chambers in the high court whereas the total number of enrolled advocates with the bar association was over 10,000.
[related-post]
The administration’s counsel informed that the land in question was shown as a green belt in the master plan, which had been sent to the central government for approval. Therefore, the administration would have to take up the case with the central government for making amendments in the master plan.
Clarifying his submissions made before the high court on Monday that the land was a notified forest area, Santosh Kumar, Conservator of Forests and Chief Wildlife Warden, informed that there was confusion because the HCBA had, nowhere in its petition, mentioned that the land being asked for advocates’ chambers was near the Tourist Information Centre.
Rather, the petitioner had mentioned “there is sufficient land belonging to the Department of Forest, Government of Chandigarh, lying vacant adjoining the premises of the high court which can be used for construction of lawyers chambers, but….there are certain restrictions and limitations for using the said land for non-forest purposes.”
Kumar added, “The Forest and Wildlife Department interpreted the demanded land to be the reserved forest land near court room number 29/ramp extension wing.”
When Chandigarh’s senior standing counsel Sanjeev Sharma submitted, “At a point when we are vying for heritage status for the Chandigarh Capitol Complex, we should not destroy something.”
Justice Mittal remarked, “Three lakh cases are pending in the high court. See the advocates’ strength. How advocates will function. Chandigarh is not going to be destroyed if one more building comes in 20 metre distance from the high court.”
Addressing Chandigarh Chief Architect Kapil Setia, the bench said, “You have to have a progressive approach. Have you seen any high court where there are only 131 advocates’ chambers?”
The case was posted for next hearing to April 30.