Premium
This is an archive article published on July 16, 2024

Doctors at DMCH refuse spine surgery on Jammu Army aspirant thrown out of train: ‘life-threatening’

Family's hope to see their son walk again now hinges on PGIMER and AIIMS Delhi; GRP gropes in the dark for a lead.

surgeryTushar Thakur at DMCH in Ludhiana. (Express photo)

Nearly two months after 23-year-old Tushar Thakur, an Army aspirant from Jammu, was allegedly thrown out of a moving train by a group of miscreants leaving him with a broken spinal cord, the world has once again come crashing down on him and his parents as doctors at Ludhiana’s Dayanand Medical College and Hospital (DMCH) refused to perform his spinal surgery, saying it might be “life-threatening”.

According to doctors, even if surgery is performed, he may not be able to walk, hence it won’t be worth taking such a huge risk. Tushar’s parents are now pinning their hopes on doctors at the Postgraduate Institute of Medical Education and Research (PGIMER), Chandigarh, and the All India Institutes of Medical Sciences (AIIMS), New Delhi, where they have been asked to consult for possibilities ahead.

However, even after nearly two months, the Government Railway Police (GRP) has failed to arrest or even identify a single suspect, who pushed him out of the moving train after he objected to their smoking on May 19 near Ludhiana railway station.

Speaking to The Indian Express, GRP Ludhiana police station SHO Sub-Inspector Jatinder Singh said, “We have procured the reservation chart of the train and sorted each passenger based on details provided by the victim. No such incident has been recorded by CCTV cameras as it possibly took place on the periphery outside of the CCTV cameras’ limits.

Train staff, including TTE, driver and GRP guards patrolling inside that day have denied witnessing such an incident. The victim is the only witness. Some locals saw Tushar lying by the tracks and called the 108 ambulance service.”

A resident of Greater Kailash in Jammu, Tushar was on his way to Ahmedabad to appear in an interview for the Service Selection Board (SSB) when the incident took place.

For Virander Thakur, an employee of the power department in Jammu, what is still keeping his hope afloat is the twinkling spirit in his son’s eyes. Even though he is unable to sit and has painful bedsores, Tushar is communicating well, speaking with his friends often and even taking care of his pet Beagle dog Bruni’s health by consulting the vet on the phone — all while being on the hospital bed. He even typed his complaint and mailed it to the police for registering an FIR.

Story continues below this ad
surgery Picture of Tushar Thakur with his pet dog Bruni.

“Bruni is very dear to him. He is in Jammu. We told Tushar that Bruni was feeling unwell and he immediately coordinated with the vet when he was fighting for his life. Though doctors at DMCH have refused to perform surgery, we are still hopeful. We will consult every doctor in the country or abroad who can make my son walk again. My heart breaks when I see what my son is going through. He wants to fill Army recruitment form again,” says the tearful father.

In his typed statement to the police based on which the FIR was registered on June 24 at the Ludhiana GRP police station, Tushar stated: “In the train, I went to the washroom, where three persons, including one turbaned man, all looked of my age were smoking cigarettes.

I asked them not to smoke inside the train. When I came out, the three boys held me and pushed me out of the moving train. I don’t remember anything after falling on the ground, but I can recognise them….” Speaking with The Indian Express, Ludhiana Deputy Commissioner Sakshi Sawhney said the administration was in regular touch with Dr Ashwani Chaudhary, head of the neurosurgery department at DMCH and his team. “The family has been informed about the exact situation,” she said.

“According to doctors, the portion of the spine located in the chest region, and very close to the heart, has broken completely. The vertebral bone has completely ruptured. The spinal cord is twisted beyond repair and misaligned. If they attempt to align and repair it, the risks will outweigh the rewards.

Story continues below this ad

Even if the surgery is 100 per cent successful, there will be no mobility in the lower limbs. It is very risky to operate due to the location of the spinal rupture. Yet if the family wants a surgery, they should first consult PGIMER, Chandigarh, and other hospitals in Delhi equipped with better machinery and live CT imaging with better precision that reduces the risk,” Sawhney said.

“The administration is providing all possible support to the parents and has mobilised funds of around Rs 1.60 lakh, including donations,” she added.

Divya Goyal is a Principal Correspondent at The Indian Express, based in Ludhiana (Punjab). She is widely recognized for her human-interest storytelling and in-depth investigative reporting on social and political issues in the region. Professional Profile Experience: With over 13 years in journalism, she joined The Indian Express in 2012. She previously worked with Hindustan Times. Education: A gold medalist in English Journalism from the Indian Institute of Mass Communication (IIMC), Delhi. Core Beats: She covers a diverse range of subjects, including gender issues, education, the Sikh diaspora, heritage, and the legacy of the Partition. She has also reported on minority communities in Pakistan and Afghanistan. Awards and Recognition Divya has earned significant acclaim for her sensitivity toward gender and social disparities: Laadli Media Award (2020): For her investigative report "Punjab: The Invisible Drug Addicts," which exposed the gender disparity in treating women addicts. Laadli Media Award (2023): For a ground report on the struggles of two girls who had to ride a boat to reach their school in a border village of Punjab. Signature Style Divya is known for "humanizing the news." Rather than just reporting on policy, she often focuses on the individuals affected by it—such as students dealing with exam stress, farmers struggling with diversification, or families impacted by crime. Her work often bridges the gap between West (Pakistan) and East (India) Punjab, exploring shared heritage and common struggles. X (Twitter): @DivyaGoyal_ ... Read More

Stay updated with the latest - Click here to follow us on Instagram

Advertisement
Loading Recommendations...
Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments