The Karnataka High Court on Friday stayed investigations in FIRs filed against BJP MPs Shobha Karandlaje, P C Mohan, and Tejaswi Surya. The matters were heard by a bench consisting of Justice Krishna Dixit.
Proceedings against Karandlaje were being pursued under provisions of the Representation of the People Act, while a case regarding a social media post by Surya was filed under provisions relating to outraging religious sentiments, promoting enmity as well as the aforementioned Act. Another case against Surya and P C Mohan was filed regarding protests in the wake of the recent Nagarathpete incident, where a shopkeeper had allegedly been assaulted for playing music at the time of azaan.
With regard to Karandlaje’s alleged comment, which was to the effect that people from Tamil Nadu and Kerala were involved in bombing and acid attacks, respectively, her counsel argued that election-related provisions raised against the MP did not apply to the specific comment. While the bench stayed the investigation against Karandlaje, orally observing that a ‘Nazi’ regime was not in place and freedom of speech existed, the bench also noted that political leaders ought to be measured in their speech.
Responding to the complaint against Surya’s social media post, which was also regarding the Nagarathpete incident, the bench observed that it was difficult to agree with the contention that there was a religious angle to the post.
Talking about the protests, Surya’s counsel argued that no illegal act had taken place, with people merely coming together and protesting against the assault of the shopkeeper. The bench observed that a similar matter involving a protest, wherein a case had been filed against CM Siddaramaiah, had been stayed by the Supreme Court and was being heard there.
An interim stay was, therefore, granted in this case.
