The chargesheet submitted by CBI in the Ishrat Jahan encounter case shows that most police officials,who testified before the agency,gave different versions to agencies investigating the case before. On the other hand,private citizens who testified have told the same story to the Ahmedabad crime branch,Gujarat HC-appointed SIT and the CBI. The latter gave details of the movements of Javed Shaikh,Ishrat and Amjad Ali Rana days before their killings.
One such witness is Alia Banu,sister of Javeda friend,Mohammed Meraj. In her testimony before CBI,recorded on March 29,2012,Alia stated that Javed was Merajs friend and had stayed at their village in May 2004,along with Ishrat and Amjad Ali Rana,who was introduced as Salim or Bunty. Alia also stated that while Ishrat did not talk much about her relationship with Javed,Rana had a shoulder injury at the relevant time.
Another witness from Ibrahimpur,Mohammed Wasi,friend of Meraj,also testified before CBI on March 30,2012 in which he gave a detailed account of Javed,Ishrat and Amjad Alis stay at Ibrahimpur village. Javed,Wasi said,was carrying an unusually big mobile phone which he later discovered to be a satellite phone. According to Wasi,Meraj used to live in Mumbra at the relevant time and had come to the village after marriage. He also stated that Meraj had asked him to arrange for a pistol for Javed. Wasi,however,could not manage it. Earlier,Wasi had said that his statement was recorded in Gujarati by Ahmedabad City Detection of Crime Branch (DCB) and also before a magistrate in Ahmedabad after the encounter.
Similarly,there are witnesses who testified about Javed buying a second-hand blue Indica car in the name of a friend,Faiyaz,from Pune. The car was bought from Suresh Kumar Ahuja,who identified Javed before Pune Police,Ahmedabad Police and CBI when photos were shown to him after the encounter. Other witnesses testified that Javed and Ishrat had stayed at hotels in Lucknow and Ahmedabad as husband-wife during different periods.
Among other unchanged versions are the statements of Shaikh Shabbir Tahir Mohammed,brother-in-law of Sajida,Javeds wife,in whose house Javed was last seen by the family before the encounter,and Asif Shaikh,Sajidas second husband after Javeds death.
According to Tahir Mohammed,Javed and Sajida had come to his place in Pune on June 8,2004 without informing him about their visit. He stated that on June 10,Javed got a call after which he hurriedly went outside the house. Later that day,he made a call from an STD booth. The next day,he added,Javed left for Mumbai for some urgent business matter. They got news of his death on June 16,2004.
Asif Shaikh testified that before going to Tahir Mohammeds place in Pune,Javed had gone to Kerala,along with his family. While they were in Kerala,Asif added,two policemen had come to him and inquired about Javed and some other Muslims. After the police officials left,I had called up Javed and informed him. Javed said he was on the way back to Pune and would handel it once her returned, Asif testified.