FORMER Chief Minister Vijay Rupani has withdrawn a criminal defamation case he had filed against former Leader of Opposition, Sukhram Rathva, his personal assistant and two MLAs, one of who is now with the BJP, for accusing that his government had changed zoning of plot of land in Rajkot to favour a private firm.
This comes after the four, one of whom joined the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) this year, appeared in court on September 26 and tendered a written unconditional apology.
In February 2022, Rathva, Shailesh Parmar and CJ Chavda held a press conference in Gandhinagar, alleging the Gujarat government approved a change in zonation of 111 acres of land belonging to Sahara India Home Corporation on the outskirts of Rajkot on May 28, 2021, when Rupani was the CM and held the portfolio of urban development department. The three leaders alleged that the zoning of the land was changed from residential to industrial, increasing the price of the land. The Congress leaders had alleged that it was a scam worth Rs 500 crore, adding that it was the reason why Rupani was “removed” from the CM’s post.
Parmar was then deputy LoP in Gujarat Assembly while Chavda was chief whip of the Congress.
Rupani had denied the allegations. Rupani, who stepped down as CM in September 2021, had stated that the zoning of the area had been changed to promote industrial development of Rajkot. After the three Congress leaders levelled allegations against Rupani, Ansh Bhardwaj, the former CM’s advocate, had served a legal notice to them as well as Rathva’s personal assistant Pravin Parmar, seeking public apology. When the Congress leaders didn’t respond to the notice, Rupani filed a criminal defamation case against the four in the chief judicial magistrate’s court in Gandhinagar on March 22, 2022.
After they didn’t respond to repeated summons, the court had issued arrest warrants against the three Congress leaders and rejected their pleas for discharge. Eventually, they appeared in court on September 26. “The four tendered a written unconditional apology, stating that they had no evidence to support allegations they had levelled and that the allegations were politically motivated. The former CM accepted the apology and therefore, we gave a pursis to the court to close the case,” Bhardwaj told The Indian Express on Tuesday.
While Parmar and Rathva could not be contacted for comment, Chavda told The Indian Express that they relied on unreliable sources to make allegations against Rupani. “We were in the Opposition and made allegations against Rupani based on information provided by others…we could not independently verify facts of the matter. But after we met him, we came to know about the facts and therefore, apologised unconditionally,” said Chavda.
Chavda had quit Congress earlier this year and joined the BJP. While Parmar managed to retain his Danilimda (SC) Assembly seat in Ahmedabad in the 2022 and continues as deputy leader of the Congress Legislative Party , Rathva lost the elections.
Rupani said that he saw no point in pressing the case after the Congress leaders apologised. “…they apologised in an open court, tending they had no proof to support allegations they had levelled. The court asked me if the apology was acceptable to me and I said now that they are apologising sincerely, I had no hesitation in accepting it and withdrawing the case,” Rupani told The Indian Express.
“In Gujarat, there is a tradition of healthy politics wherein no one levels such baseless allegations. But in a break from tradition, such allegations were levelled against me and therefore, I had to seek legal remedies to clear my side and set my public record straight,” he added.