2021 Surat murder case: 6 witnesses who turned hostile, leading to acquittal of accused, get 1-month jail term

The police also submitted the chargesheet in a timely manner. The crime was the fallout of an argument between the two.

2021 SURAT MURDER CASE, SURAT MURDER CASE, Surat, Surat police, Ahmedabad news, Gujarat news, Indian express, current affairsA Mohali court granted bail to Jalandhar businessman Harpreet Singh Gulati, arrested by the Punjab Vigilance Bureau in a corruption case linked to a disproportionate assets probe against SAD leader and former minister Bikram Singh Majithia.

THE SURAT District and Sessions Court on Tuesday found six witnesses – who had turned hostile during the course of a murder case trial, leading to the acquittal of the accused –  guilty and sentenced them to one month’s imprisonment.

The case dates back to 2021. The Surat police arrested Dipesh alias Babu Kantariya in the murder (by stabbing) of one Kalu alias Kishan Baraiya, a resident of Bhagwan Nagar Society in Katargam, on November 5 that year. The police also submitted the chargesheet in a timely manner. The crime was the fallout of an argument between the two.

During the trial before the Additional Sessions Judge B K Avasiya, six witnesses turned hostile, and their depositions on oath before the judge were the opposite of what they had given to the police. Due to lack of evidence, the sessions court acquitted the accused, Dipesh, in January this year.

The sessions court subsequently issued notices to the six witnesses, asking why no legal action should be taken against them under CrPC 344, for helping the murder accused get acquitted. The witnesses are all residents of Surat. By January 22, 2026, all the notices had been received by six witnesses, and their replies had been submitted by their lawyers to the court.

After hearing both the prosecution and the defence, the Surat district court (Fast Track Special Court), of Justice B K Avashiya, convicted all six witnesses and sentenced them to one month’s imprisonment each.

In the order, the court observed, “In a serious crime like murder, when important witnesses declare false facts on oath and the accused gets the benefit of it, then in such a situation, this behavior of the witnesses cannot be taken lightly and if taken lightly, then any person can arbitrarily state false facts in a court of law by taking oath, which is tantamount to a direct attack on the process of justice and such behavior can never be accepted. So, strict action should be taken against the witnesses who deliberately give false evidence. The faith of the general public in the process of justice will be able to survive, or else they will lose faith in the process of justice, and in such circumstances, it will become very serious and bad for the society protected by the law. Thus, in such circumstances, it is the sacred duty of this court to see that the court of justice does not remain a mute spectator in the face of such deliberate wrongdoing and strictly punishes such witnesses.”

The court also observed, “Considering all the above facts and circumstances, the defence raised by the witnesses that they are ignorant of the law and that they are poor cannot be accepted. And thus, in the interest of justice, it is deemed necessary to pass an order against these witnesses, so that an example can be set…”

Story continues below this ad

Surat court Additional Public Prosecutor Dipesh Dave said, “We are very much satisfied with the order. The court set an example, sending a warning message to the witnesses.”

Kamal Saiyed is a senior Correspondent for The Indian Express, providing extensive, on-the-ground coverage from Surat and the broader South Gujarat region and the Union territories of Daman, Diu & Dadra Nagar Haveli. With a reporting career at the publication spanning back to 2007, he has established himself as a high-authority voice on the industrial, social, and political pulse of one of India’s fastest-growing urban hubs. Expertise Industrial & Economic Beat: Based in the "Diamond City," Saiyed offers expert reporting on the diamond and textile industries. His work tracks global market shifts (such as De Beers production changes), local trade policies, and the socio-economic challenges facing the millions of workers in Surat’s manufacturing hubs. Civic & Infrastructure Coverage: He consistently reports on urban development and public safety in Surat, including: Traffic & Urban Planning: Monitoring the city's 13-fold increase in traffic violations and the implementation of new municipal drives. Public Safety: Investigative reporting on infrastructure failures, fire safety NOC compliance in schools and commercial buildings, and Metro rail progress. Political Reporting: Tracking the shifting dynamics between the BJP, Congress, and AAP in South Gujarat and the neighboring Union Territories (Daman, Diu, and Dadra & Nagar Haveli). Crime beat: Armed with a good source network Saiyed has been able to bring out the human side of crime stories in his region ... Read More

Stay updated with the latest - Click here to follow us on Instagram

Latest Comment
Post Comment
Read Comments
Advertisement
Loading Taboola...
Advertisement