Jats, Marathas and now Patidars: BJP faces challenge from dominant castes

Though the party scraped through Gujarat, data suggests the BJP suffered electoral setbacks in Patidar-dominant areas of Saurashtra. This brings to the fore the fragility of the BJP’s strategy.

Written by Pradeep Kaushal , Ravish Tiwari | New Delhi | Updated: December 19, 2017 12:25 pm
After results, Hardik Patel threatened to revive stir.

The polls over, Prime Minister Narendra Modi and BJP president Amit Shah both cautioned people of Gujarat against the “poison” of caste — their euphemism for Congress gains in Gujarat riding on resentment among Patidars. This came shortly after Hardik Patel vowed to resume his agitation.

The next poll battle in Gujarat is slated for May 2019. It is difficult to gauge how the Patidar issue will play out but the 2017 Gujarat Assembly elections tested BJP’s calibrated electoral strategy to ring-fence the party’s electoral prospects against muscle-flexing by dominant castes in different states.

Though the party scraped through Gujarat, data suggests the BJP suffered electoral setbacks in Patidar-dominant areas of Saurashtra. This brings to the fore the fragility of the BJP’s strategy.

Also Read | BJP won due to EVM tampering, played dirty tricks, says Hardik Patel

The party warded off the dominant Jat community’s demands in Uttar Pradesh early this year. But that was possible because of their relatively smaller share in the electorate across the state as well as lack of overt enthusiasm on the part of rival SP and BSP to woo them during the elections.

But the rival Congress’s dalliance with dominant Patidar community seems to have undermined the BJP’s victory margin in Gujarat.

Likewise, the numerically significant and politically organised Jat community in Haryana and Maratha community in Maharashtra have been the two other examples against which the BJP has cobbled its electoral support base in both these states. The party signalled its intentions by installing a non-Jat and non-Maratha Chief Minister in Haryana and Maharashtra respectively.

However, both these communities have been restive in these states and have put the BJP government in a spot since the party came to power in 2014 in these states. Both have been demanding quotas. As a counter strategy, the BJP is experimenting a Mandal II with a committee for sub-categorisation of OBCs to ensure equitable distribution of quota benefits to non-dominant castes.

Also Read: Five reasons why BJP won in Gujarat; one is MODI, here are the other four

Marathas account for 35 per cent of the population in Maharashtra and are clamouring for inclusion in the OBC-category. Waiting in the wings are powerful Maratha leaders like Sharad Pawar who are neither short on resources nor muscle to make things difficult for the BJP. At stake are 48 seats, the largest chunk from any state other than Uttar Pradesh.

The 21 per cent Jats are the single largest caste-group in Haryana. The BJP won eight of the 10 Lok Sabha seats in Haryana in 2014. Normally, one-third of the 90 members of the Assembly at any given time happen to be Jats.

The Patidar movement and its impact on Gujarat election results may not only inspire these communities but could also nudge BJP’s rivals to tap dominant castes anxieties in both states. Unlike UP where the dominant Yadav community leadership did not court the Jat community during elections early this year, BJP’s rivals in Haryana and Maharashtra are likely to tap into the simmering political anxieties of the community in both the states.

The BJP has so far worked on ring-fencing its electoral prospects against the diktats of the dominant castes by a reverse polarisation of rainbow coalition of non-dominant caste communities. The party, in fact, successfully executed it in Uttar Pradesh against the Yadav community dominance early this year.

But the party’s similar hope of reverse polarisation against Yadavs failed in Bihar during 2015 Assembly elections. Partly, it was undone by the popular perception among these groups that the Sangh Parivar was opposed to caste-based reservations in the aftermath of a remark by RSS chief Mohan Bhagwat.

Anxieties among the dominant peasant communities like Jats, Marathas and Patidars among others have been building up in the wake of economic changes putting the domestic agrarian economy under stress.

For all the latest Elections News, download Indian Express App

  1. Jitin Ginotra
    Dec 20, 2017 at 1:44 pm
    If Bjp appease to Jats in Haryana, who cons ute 28 of population, then its popularity would tumble. The question of matter is that while Congress seats are mostly occupied by jats, bjp does represent saini, Punjabi, jain and other communities. The scams of chautala and hooda are well known, with all bureaucratic ins utions controlled through violent jats. Bjp doesn't have to worry in Haryana, as long as it takes care of other communities.
    (0)(0)
    Reply
    1. K
      Kris
      Dec 19, 2017 at 2:30 pm
      Yesterday I was watching the debate in one of regional news channels which was discussing about Gujarat and Himachal Pradesh elections. The Congress representative attending the debate openly admitted that dividing the Hindus along the caste lines is the strategy being adopted by Congress to defeat BJP at the national level. In other words, Congress feels that it has achieved some success in Gujarat through its divisive agenda and apparently it will try to replicate the same agenda in Karnataka, MP and Rajasthan where state elections will be held in 2018. BJP should work hard to defeat Congress's divisive agenda.Rahul Gandhi has already indicated in his first speech as Congress president that he will now ignite fire which engulf the whole country though he was saying the opposite that BJP is igniting fire and Congress extinguishes it.Congress knows that it cannot win under Rahul Gandhi's leadership capability so it will employ every dirty game to return to power.BJP must be careful.
      (6)(1)
      Reply
      1. Raghunathan Othayammadath Melath
        Dec 19, 2017 at 1:17 pm
        To be more obvious Congress has instigated all these agitations...
        (16)(87)
        Reply
        1. Tkr Nathan Thiruvoth
          Dec 19, 2017 at 1:17 pm
          The media should make a conscious effort to shun these casteists. Do not give space to these cunning politicians.
          (8)(78)
          Reply
          1. vikas vivek
            Dec 19, 2017 at 1:16 pm
            it was neck and neck between bjp and congress, but since people couldnt see hardiks neck, modi won
            (3)(6)
            Reply
            1. Load More Comments