This soldier’s open letter on why it is right to ban Pakistani actors is going viral

'Are we so inured to the pain of our fellow brethren that making a movie or playing a cricket match takes precedence over a soldier’s mourning home?'

By: Express Web Desk | New Delhi | Updated: October 4, 2016 12:52 pm
india pakistan, uri attacks, surgical strikes, soldier's open letter, soldier's open letter facebook post, mns ban pakistan actors, mns bans pakistan artists, fawad khan banned, fawad khan atif aslam mahira khan banned, indian express, indian express news A soldier has opened up about what he thinks of the current state of turmoil in the country. (Source: Major Gaurav Arya/Facebook)

After the Uri attacks, which claimed the lives of at least 19 soldiers and the injured many civilians in Jammu and Kashmir, there has been a constant state of unrest across India. This is despite the momentary euphoria that followed the Indian Army’s surgical strikes that were conducted along the LoC, in response to the brutal attack.

Social media platforms were bombarded with messages of hate as well as those of love and peace in equal amounts, and from people from both countries.

ALSO READ: Google ‘namak haraam country’ and Indian flag will show; And here’s why we’re proud of it

Though the relationship between the two countries have been on tenterhooks since Independence, recent incidents have only led to further strain. In India, MNS (Maharashtra Navnirmana Sena) has called for a ban on Pakistani actors. Many have seconded the party’s decision, while many others in the industry and outside have supported the Pakistani artistes and questioned the MNS boycott. Karan Johar and Mahesh Bhatt have both spoken openly in support of Pakistani actors working in India.

Also read: People from India and Pakistan start #ProfileforPeace campaign to fight hatred

Also read: Mahesh Bhatt gets slammed for his #ProfileforPeace photo; Netizens say ‘India First’

While people are divided over the ban of the artistes, more and more former Army men are coming forth with their perspective on the state of affairs – both political and military. One such voice is of Major Gaurav Arya, who wrote an open letter on social media supporting the ban of the actors. “This conflict between India and Pakistan is not the soldier’s personal war. He is dying and killing for you and me. Imagine a situation in which the soldier felt, and behaved, like Karan Johar and Mahesh Bhatt? … How many of you would like it if a soldier felt that this was not his personal war”, he wrote.

See what else is making news.

Here’s the full text of his post.

“MALA FIDE INTENT
Our boys have just about returned from across the Line of Control after a very successful surgical strike. The entire nation is delirious with joy; the entire nation, except a few.
Today, I was part of a panel discussion in JNU, interestingly called “Intellectual Terrorism”. The term is self-explanatory, though wide-ranging. I will discuss one type of intellectual terrorism here. The proponents of this type of terror are to found in every walk of life, but the roots of this disease are embedded in some institutions of higher learning. More of that some other time.
Karan Johar wants to know if asking Fawad Khan to go back to Pakistan will stop terror. Mahesh Bhatt joins the chorus by saying “stop terrorism, not talks” implying that we must continue to talk to Pakistan. The cricket board will continue to play matches with Pakistan. Certain business houses will continue to do business with Pakistan. All this, while our soldiers are dying on the border.
Will sending Pakistani artists back, stopping cricket and business with Pakistan actually end terror from Pakistan? No, it most certainly will not. But there is an emotion called solidarity. You cannot make films, play cricket and do business as if everything is fine, because it is not. It makes the soldier wonder aloud, “Why should I alone bear the weight of conflict?”
This conflict between India and Pakistan is not the soldier’s personal war. He is dying and killing for you and me. Imagine a situation in which the soldier felt, and behaved, like Karan Johar and Mahesh Bhatt? Imagine if a soldier walked up to his superior and said, “Sir, while I am dying on the Line of Control, these people are going about as if everything is absolutely fine between the two countries.”
How many of you would like it if a soldier felt that this was not his personal war, and he, like Mahesh Bhatt, should walk across the Line of Control and shake hands with a Pakistani soldier? Why should he alone sacrifice for India, when others were making merry?
A soldier will die before the thinks of such treason, but it’s certainly food for thought, isn’t it?
Patriotism and sacrifice is not the sole responsibility of the soldier. India is Mahesh Bhatt’s country, as much as it is the soldier’s.
The United States boycotted the Moscow Olympics in 1980, and the Russians did likewise when they boycotted the Los Angeles Olympics in 1984. This is what happens when national interest is held paramount. And this is what must happen now.
For 70 years, Pakistan has been killing Indian citizens. Are we so inured to the pain of our fellow brethren that making a movie or playing a cricket match takes precedence over a soldier’s mourning home?
18 families have been shattered like glass. Not a word for them by our Bollywood royalty, mind you. But the pain of Fawad Khan’s departure is too much to bear, it seems. A tweet in support of Pakistani artists is mandatory.
These directors and producers will have you believe that before Rahat Fateh Ali Khan sang for Bollywood, there was no music of significance in the Hindi film industry. The cricket board is so busy making money that a widow’s silent sob and an orphan’s scream does not matter. What actually matters are day and night matches between India and Pakistan. The most keenly contested sporting event in history, they say; even better than the Ashes.
And the soldiers? Well, as far as they are concerned, they are on another planet, far removed from the glitzy Bollywood studios, and the teak-paneled walls of the stately boardrooms of the BCCI. The blood, the mud, the screams and the exploding gunpowder are just distant and inconvenient, not very different from traffic during the Mumbai monsoons. Life must go on.
It’s easy to ask for peace when you are a thousand miles away from the Line of Control, and your primary concerns are which party to attend this evening and where to get financing for your next film.
Peace is not a punch line. It is the end result of war.
There is a 10-year-old girl, Aditi, who understands the nation and its ebbs and flows far better than Mahesh Bhatt and Karan Johar. See her letter attached. Then see the poster made by Mahesh Bhatt, which he so proudly displays.
I leave it to you to decide who speaks for you. My vote goes to Aditi. This little angel has the spirit of a soldier.

soldier759in
The others have mala fide intent.
Jai Hind.
Major Gaurav Arya (Veteran)
#adgpi”

Here is the Facebook post.

The post has been shared over 3,500 times at the time of writing, with many commenting on it as well – most of whom agree with the Army veteran. Though, India and Indians seem to be still divided over the debate, Major Arya’s post gives us much to think about, since it comes from a perspective so close to the border.

For all the latest Trending News, download Indian Express App

  1. P
    Pertama Chaudhry
    Oct 4, 2016 at 2:22 pm
    According to the article : "The m graves of Kashmir", published by The Guardian UK= "Men of the BSF lopped off the limbs of suspects and FED PRISONERS WITH THEIR OWN FLESH."
    Reply
  2. P
    Pertama Chaudhry
    Oct 4, 2016 at 2:10 pm
    What does Major Arya have to say about this?lt;br/gt;"M graves of Kashmir", The Guardian UK.lt;br/gt;I do not doubt the sacrifices of Armymen. But why are they running amock like Chengez Khan's Huns? Why are they not accountable for the atrocities on Kashmiris? Is the Army another holy Indian cow which is above scrutiny ? Jai Hind !
    Reply
  3. K
    Krishnan Madathil
    Oct 4, 2016 at 11:04 am
    We are sorry for the cr rhetoric and irresponsible behavior of our elected politicians and media who have created a situation and thrown it to the Armed Forces to handle. We fully support and are proud of the efforts of the Indian Army and are glad for their efforts which has kept us safe for 70 years - we hope also for the next 700 years. Please tell our politicians and media to tread carefully and stop making warlike situations and then leaving it to the Armed Forces to handle. The Armed Forces handle war, and they handle it very well. But politicians handle the peace, and they mess things up every time. Jai Hind! Jai Jawan!
    Reply
  4. K
    Krishnan Madathil
    Oct 4, 2016 at 2:46 pm
    It is probably a propaa piece by the Guardian devoid of facts as foreign press is not allowed to cover JK. That would be the reply. And from the description of the text, sounds like a had a hand in the editing.
    Reply
  5. K
    Krishnan Madathil
    Oct 4, 2016 at 2:41 pm
    Ok let's not get too carried away here - the state of JK is not known as a 'disturbed' state for nothing. Dramatic reporting of the type of Guardian have to be taken with a lump of salt. As for the holy cow, if there is one agency of the state that has delivered all these years for all India, it is the Army. Lapses may have occurred, and we may call for reform, but I would not go on like you to demonize them, simply because I feel safer with them at the border than a Burhan Wani.
    Reply
  6. L
    Lohit Acharya
    Oct 7, 2016 at 5:32 pm
    The Guardian will do propaa for s because no organisation of west world wants India to have a complete and peaceful control in Kashmir. Everyone is interested in that strategic location and hence everyone wants it to remain a disputed area. The west world very well know that until Kashmir is in India's control they can never intervene directly in its geography. These propaists will never tell you about the social works that army do in Kashmir, from education to medical facilities, from protecting them in odd times to sponsoring the special talents, army is actually changing the Kashmir on ground level. Days after Burhan wani killed, there were youths in Kashmir who joined army to serve the Nation. And you know why I don't believe the news of brutally-ties of army, because its only the Indian Army who fights terrorists to protect people who are abusing and discouraging them at the same time from behind by their pro pak slogans. Such is the patience our army holds.
    Reply
  7. R
    R.Mehta
    Oct 7, 2016 at 2:14 pm
    To keep peace and harmony in the Country and to avoid controversies on various issues,what needs to be done first is that media should be asked to refrain from holding panel discussions on TV with various people whether actors /social activitists / or others and should be asked to keep their task limited to reporting the news as was done earlier on DD .The media people from various channels invite people from various walks of life to hold live discussions on latest news /developments and when the panelist give their opinions / views ,it leads to one or the other controversy, leading to problem for the common people. Similarly media people whether on TV or in various functions involve celeberities / por people for their response to many questions related to various issues concerning the films,individuals,issue relating to happenings in the Country and if some or the other comment is made by anybody which is not liked by a group of people or people having other point of view ,it leads to controversy and adds to the problem. The media should not see every thing from commercial point of view and should make sure that ,it confines its role to reporting the news and having various programmes /serials on their channels which do not create controversies. .Only because media has become so desperate to have views of por people from various walks of life , on various issues taking place in the Country and in the process ,some or the other personal views of por people are known to the common people and people having different thinking on the issue,the controversies on various aspects are increasing leading to a wider divide in the people of the Country on the basis of religion ,caste ,depending on economic status of people .The only way to refrain from controversies is that por people /celebraties should not get tempted by media to give their views on controvertial issues and should themselves also keep their point of view to themselves and do what they think is right, without disclosing at the behest of media ,which is the main problem of issues going out of hand and adding to the problems.Such steps should not be taken by media as interference in their rights ,as they are for larger interest of every body in and belonging to our Country.
    Reply
  8. N
    nehal
    Oct 6, 2016 at 6:03 pm
    The biggest issue is, we seek directions celebrities and media is partly responsible for providing them so much coverage. Media should care less what Karan thinks or Salman Khan thinks. Their motives will never align with country's. They're in the business to make money. They need to remember that this wonderful country has given them ideny and made them rich.Their such actions are sending the wrong message to outsiders.lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;Also, let soldiers do their job and leaders to their job and we should provide them full support. On one side, we're complaining what happens on LOC an issue for the country for many many years now and on other side when it comes to taking actions and coming together as a nation, we're not one nation.lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;In china, i had read that if you go against nation's will, they will punish you and same needs to be brought to India.Also, I've witnessed entire US coming together as one voice during 9/11 and going on war in Iraq.lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;God bless India but Indian ppl need a wake up call.
    Reply
  9. Load More Comments