By Anick Jesdanun
Two new Android phones will look and sound familiar to those who have been paying attention to phones. That’s because these two devices are replicas of Samsung’s Galaxy S4 and HTC’s One,except they lack most of the bells and whistles added to the original models.
And that’s a good thing.
The modifications Samsung and HTC apply to Google’s Android software are meant to be improvements. But I’ve complained before about how the changes actually make phones more complex to use. The S4 even has an easy mode for first-time smartphone users,an admission that the normal mode is too confounding.
Google worked with both Samsung Electronics Co. and HTC Corp. to come out with “Google Play” editions of the hit phones. Instead of customized software from Samsung and HTC,the Google phones run a pure version of Android,just as it was developed by Google.
Google lets any phone maker use its Android operating system for free. To set themselves apart from competitors,phone makers often add their own touches to devices. They rearrange the menu or load additional apps. Wireless carriers also like to add their own apps. Before you know it,phones are bloated with features and apps you don’t want and can’t get rid of.
Consider my experience with the original S4 over the weekend. As I tried to adjust the camera’s flash setting,I inadvertently made some postage stamp icon pop up. That activated the camera’s dual-shot mode,which snaps a shot of you with the front camera to superimpose over whatever you’re shooting with the camera on the back of the phone. I didn’t want that,but I couldn’t figure out how to get rid of it. My friend couldn’t either. So we bagged the shot. Taking photos with a phone is supposed to be fun,not a chore.
With Google’s version of the S4,I get a no-frills camera that is easy to figure out. It lacks gimmicks such as dual shots and the ability to combine several images of motion into a single shot. It offers about a half-dozen shooting modes,such as night,action and panorama,rather than the dozen or so on the original S4. But a half-dozen is about a half-dozen more than I need and use.
Google’s S4 also lacks the original model’s ability to pause video automatically when you look away from the screen or to scroll down an article when you tilt your head. Those features may sound cool,but they often don’t work properly.
The Google version of the S4 also has alarm sounds that I can actually wake up to. Samsung had substituted those sounds with soft,soothing melodies that I end up incorporating into dreams. I’ve overslept a few times as a result.
As for Google’s version of the HTC One,you don’t get a busy home screen filled with news articles and Facebook status updates your phone thinks you want to read. Instead,you get a clean page with few apps. It’s up to you to add the ones you want to see and use.
Both Google phones feel spare and minimal,which is great because it makes me …continued »