SC gives BCCI an ultimatum: Srinivasan should quit or we will pass a verdict

The Supreme Court said BCCI president N Srinivasan must step down as the president of the cricketing body.

Written by Utkarsh Anand | New Delhi | Updated: March 26, 2014 8:50 am
The Supreme Court wants  BCCI chief to step down (File) The Supreme Court wants N Srinivasan to step down for a fair probe (File photo)

Raising the pitch in its bid to address allegations of corruption plaguing the IPL, the Supreme Court on Tuesday issued an ultimatum to the BCCI and asked it to remove its President N Srinivasan from his post to ensure a fair probe in the case and make certain that cricket remains clean. Indicating that its probe panel had stumbled upon traces of match-fixing and spot-fixing in the domestic T20 league besides betting, the apex court bench of Justices A K Patnaik and F M I Kalifulla made it clear to the cricket board that the court would be constrained to pass a formal order if Srinivasan did not step down on his own. “We feel that unless the President of the BCCI steps down, no fair decision can be taken. Why is Mr Srinivasan sticking to his chair? It is nauseating. Courts after courts have said he should step down…Srinivasan should step down else we will pass a verdict,” said the bench, referring to “very serious” facts disclosed by a confidential report submitted by the court-appointed probe panel. The panel has held Srinivasan’s son-in-law Gurunath Meiyappan guilty of betting and passing on team information during IPL matches last year. It also said the concerns about Srinivasan’s conflict of interest were “serious” and may have “large-scale ramifications on the functioning of cricket”. The panel had also submitted another report in a sealed cover with some details, it said, may require the bench’s consideration. As the hearing on the report began, BCCI counsel C A Sundaram sought to convince the bench that no further orders were required in the matter since an independent probe panel had already submitted its report and the BCCI was agreeable to almost all recommendations. Assuring the BCCI would take disciplinary action against erring players, Sundaram said that while the real worry was whether IPL players were involved in match-fixing or spot-fixing, the court-appointed panel had only found betting. The court, however, shot down his contention. “Don’t say that. You are saying this because you have not seen what is there in the sealed cover. We have seen it and so we are at the root of it. After going through it, we think there is a big question whether you will implement anything.” The court asked Sundaram to go through the confidential report as an officer of the court and “not as a lawyer paid by Srinivasan” and then argue whether Srinivasan should quit or not. “We don’t want to damage people’s reputation but in our opinion, Srinivasan must step down. The man at the top must go if there has to be any fair investigation…gist of the sealed cover report proves many allegations…allegations are such that the BCCI cannot be trusted with this,” it said after showing a portion of the report to Sundaram. The counsel contended that Srinivasan was a man of repute and that his stepping down may also impact the prospect of his taking over as head of the ICC in July. The bench, however, refused to entertain such arguments and asked the BCCI to come back with a response on Thursday. At one stage, the bench also compared the two reports – one by an earlier inquiry committee set up by the BCCI, and the other by the court. “Findings of the two committees are very different. Can we say report by your committee was managed? If people managed the report, what should be the consequences?” It regretted the state of affairs as unveiled by the panel, saying: “If cricket has to remain clean, why should all this happen at all? It is because the people who are in control are not taking the right decisions. Let us tell you there are no definite findings in the sealed cover but the allegations are very very serious.” The court had in July appointed the IPL probe committee, headed by Justice (retd) Mukul Mudgal and also comprising senior advocates Nilay Dutta and L N Rao. The panel submitted its report in February. While indicting Meiyappan, the panel had trashed the statements made before it by Srinivasan and India captain M S Dhoni that Meiyappan had nothing to do with the cricketing affairs of CSK and that he was just a “cricket enthusiast” supporting the team. It also recommended a further probe against Raj Kundra and Shilpa Shetty, part-owners of Rajasthan Royals, besides suspending them from participating in any activity of the BCCI, including IPL matches, pending a final determination of their role. Options before Srinivasan: He may inform SC Thursday about stepping down, but with conditions and for limited duration. He may oppose it, questioning what SC means ensuring “fair probe” since criminal investigation by police on and hence outside BCCI ambit. He may invite a speaking court order on removal, to enable him challenge it legally. Twiterrati reacts

For all the latest Sports News, download Indian Express App now

  1. S
    sona
    Mar 25, 2014 at 11:43 pm
    good one. Manmohan Singh need not step down for a fair probe on coal gate scandal. Sonia need not step down for fair probe on her son-in-law's scams. Anyone facing the heat of law and order is actually a victim, without political background!What else can you expect in a country where Azharuddin was thrown out of cricket, but was voted to power as MP? Public opposition to Srini is yet another expression of our stupidity, collectively, as a nation!
    Reply
    1. S
      Subarna Dutta
      Mar 25, 2014 at 10:45 am
      Celebrate each and every moments of togetherness with your lovable mother by sending clustered bouquet of seasonal flowers that fillthe environment with its vibrancy and liveliness. Send Mother's Day Flowers to Singapore.Send Just pay your visit to the online shopping store with the help of a single click Send Gifts to Singapore from any country without any headache.
      Reply
      1. S
        ss
        Mar 25, 2014 at 6:45 pm
        And if it is a question of moral responsibility, then it should always be voluntary - and "not as required by law" - otherwise it becomes a "legal resposnsibility" and not moral one.
        Reply
        1. S
          ss
          Mar 25, 2014 at 6:44 pm
          If no one has "seen" then how can one know what the report says? The courts should either punish if he is guilty,or leave it if he is not found guilty - and should avoid this demand of asking to step down etc - and should also avoid terms such as nauseating etc. Just because one cannot criticize court's decision, courts have a free for all commenting - and ignoring the law as such. When have the courts of law started punishing father in law and mother in law of the guilty? And sinc ebeting and fixing related investigations are being done by police, how will srinivasan's being in BCCI or leaving will affect the police investigation? Is the court suggesting that Srinivasan is controlling them as well? And if it is a question of moral responsibility, then it should always be voluntary - and "not re
          Reply
          1. V
            Vijay Ranade
            Mar 25, 2014 at 3:10 pm
            We all are happy that atleast SC is convinsed that something seriously wrong with the working of BCCI. In fact BCCI should be dissolved.
            Reply
            1. Load More Comments

            IPL Fixtures

            TODAY

            34th T20

            04:00 PM (IST) April 29, 2017 .

            Rising Pune Supergiant vs Royal Challengers Bangalore

            Maharashtra Cricket Association Stadium, Pune
            TODAY

            35th T20

            08:00 PM (IST) April 29, 2017 .

            Gujarat Lions vs Mumbai Indians

            Saurashtra Cricket Association Stadium, Rajkot

            36th T20

            04:00 PM (IST) April 30, 2017 .

            Kings XI Punjab vs Delhi Daredevils

            Punjab Cricket Association Stadium, Mohali

            37th T20

            08:00 PM (IST) April 30, 2017 .

            Sunrisers Hyderabad vs Kolkata Knight Riders

            Rajiv Gandhi International Stadium, Hyderabad

            38th T20

            04:00 PM (IST) May 1, 2017 .

            Mumbai Indians vs Royal Challengers Bangalore

            Wankhede Stadium, Mumbai