• Associate Sponsor

Supreme setback for MI, Pune as top court quashes appeal for IPL in May

Mumbai, Pune and Nagpur were to host 13 IPL 2016 matches including final at Wankhede stadium in Mumbai on May 29.

By: Express News Service | New Delhi | Updated: April 28, 2016 1:26 am
ipl 2016, ipl, ipl news, maharashtra drought, india drought, water crisis, maharashtra water crisis, ipl matches in maharashtra, supreme court, indian premier league, sports news, india news, sports Supreme Court of India dismissed the plea by MCA. (Source: AP)

THE IPL organizers’ quest to find a feasible solution to the issue of hosting their displaced matches in May continues to hit roadblocks at every turn, and their logistical nightmare only continues to turn more ominous. On Wednesday, the Supreme Court dismissed the joint appeal by Maharashtra and Mumbai Cricket Associations against the Bombay High Court order to shift IPL matches out of the drought-hit state. To make matters worse, the status of Jaipur and Raipur, which were supposed to be the alternate venues once Maharashtra lost its hosting rights too now seem to be in limbo.

On the same day, the Rajasthan High Court asked the state government to file a comprehensive reply on how it planned to supply water for three IPL matches—as home ground for Mumbai Indians—as well as an action plan and policy for dealing with the water scarcity in the state over the next two months of harsh summer. If that’s not enough, the High Court of Bilaspur has taken cognizance of the petitions filed by Chandrashekhar Shukla, president of the Chhattisgarh Kisan Congress, citing the water crisis that seems to have turned into a national problem. And the BCCI now are left reeling with few options, not to forget tangled up in the mire of legal issues surrounding the IPL.

The issue had come to light when a PIL was filed in the Bombay High Court asking for all matches in the IPL to be shifted out of Maharashtra—Mumbai, Pune and Nagpur—citing the drought-like situation in major parts of the state. Then a fortnight ago, the High Court had ordered shifting of all IPL matches scheduled in Maharashtra after April 30 to another state. The direction had come even as BCCI had given an assurance that IPL franchises of Mumbai and Pune had agreed to contribute Rs five crore to Chief Minister’s drought relief fund.

That prompted the MCAs to file a special leave petition to reverse the order. But on Wednesday, a bench led by Chief Justice T S Thakur said that the matches be shifted out of the state after it did not get convinced by the arguments regarding use of treated sewage water in stead of portable water in cricket grounds. The court also noted that it had not initially countered the contention in the PIL about use of 60 lakh litres of water for maintenance of the grounds.

During the hearing, senior advocates Abhishek Manu Singhvi and P Chidambaram, appearing for the state cricket bodies, had sought a stay on the Bombay High Court order. They maintained that potable water would not be used for any cricketing activity in stadiums in Mumbai and Pune and treated sewage water would be used. The lawyers claimed the stadiums would need 10,000 litres a day for six days and potable water will not be used.

But the bench remained unimpressed with the arguments and observed it would be better to shift the matches out rather than to create a situation where all kinds of regulations would be needed.

Elsewhere in Jaipur, hearing a petition challenging the conduct of three Mumbai Indians IPL matches in Jaipur, a HC bench comprising Justices Ajay Rastogi and DC Somani asked the government to file a response by April 30.

While the state government sought more time to reply, the petitioner’s lawyer argued for an early response since the matches are scheduled for May 8th, 13th and 15th. The PIL was filed last week by city based journalist Mahesh Pareek, after the Mumbai Indians and BCCI chose Jaipur as the team’s home ground for holding the remainder of its matches after the Bombay HC moved IPL matches out of Maharasthra.

And a two judge bench of the Bilaspur High Court has asked all parties in the petition to return with detailed replies on May 4, when the petition will be delved into further. As per the IPL schedule, Raipur is set to host two matches, on May 20 and May 22.

Chandrashekhar Shukla, president of the Chhattisgarh Kisan Congress and the petitioner in the case said that he had filed the PIL, given the drought in the state. “In the petition, I have used several statements made my senior government officials and ministers when they are talking about the drought, as well as a report of the Central Water Resources Ministry which says that dams across the country, including those in Chhattisgarh are running dry. In the last session of the assembly, government representatives had also spoken about the drought, and that has also been submitted to the Bilaspur High Court. We have asked that in a situation as dire as this, how can IPL matches be held in Naya Raipur?,” Shukla said. Shukla told this paper that the parties in the PIL included the Chhattisgarh government, the Chief Secretary of the state government, secretary water resources department, Chhattisgarh Cricket Association, BCCI, IPL governing council, and the officer in charge of the international cricket stadium in Naya Raipur. “The Bilaspur High Court has asked for all the facts from all these concerned agencies. The next hearing in the case has now been set for May 4,” Shukla said.

(With inputs from ENS Jaipur/Raipur)


For all the latest Sports News, download Indian Express App

  1. A
    Apr 27, 2016 at 2:52 pm
    The supreme Court should not have taken up these cases. If IPL is shifted would these people get water.Its rather sad that supreme Court wastes its time on silly issues
    1. Balu Muthu
      Apr 28, 2016 at 6:38 am
      There is no positive purpose served by 'playing' this wasteful frivolty. This hangiver from the British colonialist era - which was a favorite of the conolial army officers whose job it was just to make Indian Jawans by the millions goats on the battle grounds - is a misnomer for sports. Surely we must be ashamed that we are virtually a cipher in Olympics and this fact no longer does not seem to agitate our youth. There are so many harmful consequrnces of permitting mammoth cricket matches going under different names - betting, match fixing, money laundering involvimg netas, babus, businesses, immoralities absolutely incompatible with our culture, ... and of course expenditure of enormous volumes of water overriding priority demands for agriculture, public uses, ... At the very least, we as a society with any sense of social interest must organise collective action to require thatthese matches bring desalised water from their own olants (outting up the necessary plants) laying the pipelines to their locations. The organisers must be made to make a mandatory contribution of a substantial percentage(15--30%)of the revenues from the frivolties for public benefits such as infrastructural improvements in the areas of power, efluent treatment from pllutioon generating industries, etc.
      1. R
        Apr 27, 2016 at 11:03 am
        thanks for rejecting the plea.
        1. S
          S. Gopalakrishnan
          Apr 27, 2016 at 10:37 am
          T20 is a mad savage wild mindless hitting with no technique involved .One can observe that no quality bowler or batsman has shown any consistency in T20game It is high time that T20 is to be banned not only from Maharastra but from India I am a vivid fan of cricket and am forced to make this statement as only speculation and gambling thrives and not cricket.The careers of so many youth are ruined because of T20cricket
          1. T
            Tetris Karo
            Apr 27, 2016 at 11:46 am
            Why SC is hearing such silly cases and wasting time. Why not SC concentrate on cases affecting consution and matters derailing democracy or grave injustice. SC need to manage their time and identify relevant cases to be heard instead of crying in public.
            1. Load More Comments
            Live Cricket Scores & Results
            indian super league 2017 schedule

            indian super league 2017 points table