‘Everyone has to be made accountable, this chalta hai attitude won’t work’

BCCI has wasted no time in jumping into action post the Indian team’s disappointing 3-1 Test series defeat.

Written by Devendra Pandey | Mumbai | Updated: August 22, 2014 8:59 am
The top three members of the coaching staff have been sidelined after the 3-1 debacle in England. (Source: PTI File) The top three members of the coaching staff have been sidelined after the 3-1 debacle in England. (Source: PTI File)

The Board of Control for Cricket in India (BCCI) has wasted no time in jumping into action post the Indian team’s disappointing 3-1 Test series defeat in England. Be it the appointment of Ravi Shastri as Director of Cricket for the ODIs or the changes made to the support staff. In an interview with The Indian Express, BCCI secretary Sanjay Patel talks about the board’s response to the debacle, the decision to bring in Shastri and about what lies in store for coach Duncan Fletcher and skipper MS Dhoni. Excerpts:

How upset is the BCCI with the Indian team’s dismal loss in the Test series against England?

We are of course very upset with the way some of the wickets were thrown during those Test matches. It is not that our boys don’t know to play cricket. I think what they lacked during the tour was mental toughness. Having said that, this loss was very alarming for the board. The 2015 World Cup is nearby and we all thought that the time was ripe to take some stern decisions. The BCCI had to draw the line somewhere and we just did that.

So is bringing in Ravi Shastri as Director of Cricket in line with the BCCI’s move to take stern decisions?

The first thing the BCCI felt was necessary was to create a comfort zone for the boys. And we thought that Ravi Shastri was the perfect man to create that kind of an atmosphere. So I requested Ravi to take up the job, and as always, he was ready to work with Team India and BCCI. After a discussion with my colleagues in the board, we decided that the team needed a support staff that was capable of bringing the boys’ focus back on the game, and to resolve their mental problems and weaknesses. For that matter, they also required a man who would be able to talk to them.

By bringing in Shastri as Director, and ‘resting’ Trevor Penney and Joe Dawes, is the BCCI sending a strong message that everyone in the team management is accountable?

Everyone has to be made accountable for the performance of the team. This chalta hai attitude won’t work. We generally wait to take such calls after assessing the tour reports. But it was clear that there was something wrong taking place this time around. And we thought that we shouldn’t wait before putting corrective measures in place. Some people might ask why not wait till the end of the tour to ring in the changes. But this is how I think, if you’re feeling unwell today, will you take your medicines now or do it after four days?

Did the BCCI consult the players in England before naming Shastri?

We didn’t do that. The current support staff has been there since long and there have been occasions in the past, where the team has performed well under them. But when something is not working out for you, it’s a good idea to employ a different route and the BCCI felt that appointing Shastri was a viable proposal.

But with Shastri now in-charge, where does it leave Duncan Fletcher?

At the moment, it will be unfair to say anything about Fletcher’s ability or his future. Everything will be decided after we assess the tour report that will be presented to us by the coach and manager.

How worried is the BCCI with regards to MS Dhoni’s captaincy in Test cricket?

My personal view is that I don’t doubt Dhoni’s captaincy credentials. Winning and losing are part of the game. The BCCI does look at the performance of every captain, but Dhoni’s leadership hasn’t really come up for discussion yet. Dhoni and his team still have our complete support and backing.

But if the support staff can be pulled up for the team’s performance, then why not Dhoni?

We have a selection committee in place, who will decide whether Dhoni is fit to be there as captain or not. I as a board secretary can’t decide on that. As a batsman, Dhoni did well but I believe the biggest issue was that we never got big runs from the top-order.

Is the BCCI going to call for a meeting with the players to discuss the debacle?

I’m going to be meeting with the players. I will be flying to England soon. We are all upset with the series loss and I’m sure so are the players.

Some experts like Sunil Gavaskar have questioned some players’ ethics and discipline?

I can’t comment on what he’s said. Whatever we do, we do for the betterment of Indian cricket. Before taking any decision, we always look at all areas and we have experts who chip in too. I can’t comment on the technical issues of the players, that’s not my area.

Considering that we went to England after two months of the IPL, did the team suffer from a lack of preparation?

IPL has completed seven years now and during that time, India has won and lost various tournaments. Blaming the IPL is a very easy thing.

For all the latest Sports News, download Indian Express App

  1. RK
    Aug 22, 2014 at 4:43 am
    And, what an action the board has taken! They have only found easy meats as scapegoats and spared the real culprits. What difference a coach can make? Does anyone here think, the star players will ever listen to any coach? They'll decide when to wake up, when to pick a bat or a ball and what sort of physical activity they indulge in and to get a clean chit from these "legends", a coach has to be a mute spectator allowing all nonsense, freaking outs, late night parties, booze...none can stop them as they're more than Gods to us fans.... Funny! the le of this article...."Everyone has to be made accountable..." Were the Kohlis, Shikars, Ashwins, Jaddus, Vijays (for his poor showing during later part of the series), Pujaras made accountable? They only picked poor, helpless support staff! I doubt if henceforth any foreign coach would ever think of coaching our team after seeing the treatment meted out to poor Duncan. If BCCI has any real guts, let them drop these useless players. Anyone can make runs at an average of 13. You don't really need a Virat to do it.
    1. P
      Aug 22, 2014 at 10:43 am
      Accountability doesn't just end with the coach. What about the players themselves? Kohli is in some kind of honey moon, Dhoni the lackluster captain bereft of any positive ideas to motivate the team. About Pujara, Gambhir, Vijay, Jadeja, Binny, Ashwin the less said the better.
      1. R
        Rashid Saood
        Aug 22, 2014 at 12:46 pm
        Cosmetic surgery is nit going to help team india . The test debacle leads to change the odi team management is laughing stock . Any issue regarding Dhoni is swept under the carpet by bcci and all retired senior players are in comfort zones and are weak to stand against bcci since they benefit from bcci one way or the another . A long term plan is required till than indian team will gave more problems and losses than solution and victory ...
        1. R
          Ramesh Shotham
          Aug 21, 2014 at 10:28 pm
          Neither here nor there kind of answers! Typical BCCI office- bearer. And why is Dhoni escaping any flak? He might have made some tough runs, but his captaincy is uninspiring and his wicket-keeping aweful.
          Live Cricket Scores & Results
          indian super league 2017 schedule

          indian super league 2017 points table