Sonu Nigam’s azaan tweet row: An unnecessary elongation that skirts around the civic issue

The Twitter imbroglio overall reads like an unnecessary elongation of a battle-of-egos that skirts around the actual civic issue.

Written by Nandini Rathi | New Delhi | Updated: April 20, 2017 10:55 am
sonu nigam head shaved, sonu nigam bald, sonu nigam azaan, sonu nigam fatwa, Syed Sha Atef Ali Al Quaderi, sonu nigam Syed Sha Atef Ali Al Quaderi, Syed Sha Atef Ali Al Quaderi fatwa against sonu nigam, sonu nigam 10 lakhs, sonu nigam shave, sonu nigam noise pollution, priyanka chopra azaan, sonu nigam loudspeaker ban, sonu nigam anti muslim, pooja bhatt sonu nigam, sonu nigam tweets, indian express, indian express news Sonu Nigam shaved off his head on Wednesday in response to a Muslim cleric who promised Rs 10 Lakhs as reward to anyone who would shave Nigam’s head, embellish and parade him around with a shoe garland.

A theatre of the absurd has been underway since singer Sonu Nigam tweeted up a storm Monday morning protesting against the use of loudspeakers for the call to Azaan, referring to the practice as “gundagardi”. For this, he was criticised, praised and trolled all day, which led him to attempt a clarification stating that his opposition was solely anti-loudspeaker. That however only stoked the non-event further, earning a smattering of jibes from within the Bollywood fraternity too. As if that wasn’t enough, a Kolkata-based cleric jumped right in on Tuesday with an award of Rs 10 lakh for shaving Nigam’s head. Syed Sha Atef Ali Al Quaderi, vice president of the West Bengal Minority United Council, stated: “If anyone can shave his [Nigam’s] hair, put a garland of old torn shoes around his neck and tour him around the country, I personally announce an award of Rs 10 lakh for that person.” As per a DNA report, Quaderi claimed that he would have done the same if “one had talked ill about the sound of bells coming from a temple as well … People like Nigam should be driven out of the country.”

A happily provoked, unfazed Nigam tweet-announced on Wednesday, February 19, “Today at 2pm Aalim will come to my place, and shave my head. Keep your 10 lakhs ready Maulavi” and recently followed through on that, putting the Quaderi and his brazenly comic fatwa in a rather absurd position. Nigam is now steadfastly claiming his earned reward. Most recently, the cleric has only emphasised his nonsensical demands instead of taking them back, by asking Nigam to carry through the shoe-garland and the parading too, in order the claim the reward.

It is certainly worth wondering whether this whole ensemble isn’t a bit too much drama, especially in the way a slumbering celebrity went about making it a personal issue out of the blue. It thus understandably comes off as a publicity stunt, complete with a bustling press conference this afternoon. Nigam did make efforts to clarify his issues as a secular, general issue and not limited to any particular religion. The issue of religious tolerance-intolerance got sucked into the cocktail anyway, because in India “secular” means all religions rather than non-religion.

The unfolding also put a spotlight on the laughing stock of absurdity that the idea of fatwa has become in the recent years. Fatwas, which are technically a legal opinion rather than a binding ruling, have frequently been issued as a pure rhetoric effect in vacuum of the real world and practicality. A Google search of “ridiculous” leads to the suggestion of “fatwa” as the next word, followed by an abundance of question threads and listicles about the most bizarre of them populating the search results. While his statement was eventually clarified as a non-Fatwa, cleric Quaderi in this case was clearly not concerned that his words could be interpreted literally – for announcing rewards on silly causes is easy but to produce the sum isn’t. Surely, something defined as an opinion by a legitimate body should try to be more discerning and incorporate real world sense into their invocations instead of diving headfirst at non-events.

The Sonu Nigam Twitter imbroglio reads like an unnecessary elongation of a battle-of-egos that skirts around the actual civic issue. It goes on, but what is being achieved? Any enforceable curbing of noise pollution of urban India — defined by acceptable time slots and decibel limits, and manifesting in greater forms than just Azaan calls — is yet to come up in discussion.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

  1. R
    reshma thomas
    Apr 23, 2017 at 11:09 am
    Heres what I have to say to every loud speaker fanatic: Just as praying and playing religious music is your fundamental right, finding peace within my home is mine. Freedom to practise your religion is not a sufficient reason to steal my right to peace.
    Reply
    1. R
      Rici
      Apr 21, 2017 at 3:46 pm
      Spnu Nigam has put spot light on the violent cult of fatwas spewing kathmulls. Fatwa practice is not comical for zombie followers of katmullas. It put enormous fear in the mind of people who wants to confront katmullas for their law lessness and bigotry. This sikular as usual trying to make light of the issue of brazen rule braking by mosques and kathmullas. This pi g should know that one person was already stabbed in MP by katmulla zombie for supporting Sonu Nigam. This is exactly Sonu Nigam was indicating when he said 'sub gunda gardi hai.
      Reply
      1. S
        S.K. Express
        Apr 21, 2017 at 10:43 am
        Sonu Nigam said the right thing. However, he said something against a practice of the Muslims. How could he? Now, the entire "secular" brigade (including the Maulavi who being a Muslim cannot be non-secular) is after Mr. Nigam. Article after article, nonsense after nonsense are uttered about the practices of Hindus by columnists in this newspaper and elsewhere in the newsmedia. The "secular" brigade actually contributes to those articles without shame.
        Reply
        1. S
          Subodh
          Apr 21, 2017 at 1:01 am
          Why people are not able to differentiate between once a while noise to the daily noise? Which sound is most irritating when you hear it while resting or when you are engaged in work? (Hindu festival come once in a year. No temple play Bhajan before 6 AM as well as after 11 PM, also if someone complain about it the reduce volume immediately. Most of the celebration end before 12 AM.)
          Reply
          1. N
            Nikhil
            Apr 20, 2017 at 3:24 pm
            It is ludicrous that people create a controversy where none exists, and then each one gives an opinion that is distorted, illogical or biased. Sonu Nigam’s statement against azaan on loudspeakers is neither controversial nor anti-muslim. He objected to noise pollution which is illegal and torturous to inhabitants surrounding mosques, at least the non-muslims. No religion has a right to disturb public peace by forcing high decibel prayer calls five times a day. When decades of banning azaan has failed and even court orders are not enforced, any law abiding citizen suffering severe noise pollution will use the word “gundagiri”. Isn’t a law breaker loosely called a “gunda”? Don’t paint this statement with a religious colour, and mani te the valid intention. Why should azaan be allowed to wake me up at 5 or 6 am if I am a late riser, or torment me periodically for the rest of the day? No court should accept such disturbances as legally permissible even for 3 mins if above 40 decibels.
            Reply
            1. A
              Ankit Kumar
              Apr 20, 2017 at 12:38 pm
              If people have any problem than it should be... Because it is not related to any kind of prayer... It's not so important.. Sometimes it creates noise pollution ..
              Reply
              1. P
                Prof. S.V. Gedam
                Apr 20, 2017 at 12:34 pm
                Since I was asked to voice my thoughts, I am writing here. Now the Author should demonstrate propriety and read what I have to say. Making noise in the society thru use of loud speakers by ANY PERSON/RELIGION, amounts to creation of nuisance for at least some people. Why should any one suffer because a fraction of people want to propagate religion (Const Art. 25)? Any use of religious propagation is bound by public order and health. Unregulated loud speakers are for anyone with scientific orientation and conscious of his legal rights. I am an atheist and humanist. A few days before, I was planning to meet District Collector to urge in the interest of Public Order to prohibit all these loud speakers. In views of above legal position, ALL loud speakers should be banned in ALL religious places. P.S. Yes, we are a chaotic society with hundreds of festivals. But that entropy should not intimidate us from taking a first step in the right direction if we wish to make India more peaceful.
                Reply
                1. D
                  Diplomat
                  Apr 21, 2017 at 10:21 am
                  Well said. No loudspeakers. Period.
                  Reply
                2. B
                  Binay
                  Apr 20, 2017 at 11:05 am
                  Dear author, You are right that the real issue is sound pollution, decibel levels, allowed time limits for music, etc. are the real issues. However if someone simply raise those issues, no one gives importance. Because the effect of sound pollution is like slow death. We may not react when we hear the loudspeakers for the first 10-12 times or 15-20 times. But when this goes on every day or week of the year, it gets intolerable. That's when a reaction similar to what Sony Nigam showed just happens. PLEASE DO NOT IGNORE THIS ISSUE IN THE NAME OF UNNECESSARY ELONGATION. DO SOMETHING IF YOU CAN.
                  Reply
                  1. P
                    Pitambar Sharma
                    Apr 20, 2017 at 9:26 am
                    Stupid article typical of IE.
                    Reply
                    1. D
                      Dan Mishra
                      Apr 19, 2017 at 10:49 pm
                      I nominate Sonu Nigam for Nobel peace prize.
                      Reply
                      1. J
                        John Abram
                        Apr 19, 2017 at 10:00 pm
                        If you consider 2 minutes of Azaan 5 times a day i.e. total 10 minutes from 24 hours something which is unbearable then it seems like we are living in heaven and Azaan is the last problem to be solved. Lets do some calculation and see: so 10 minutes x 365 days 3650 minutes / 60 minutes 61 hours / 24 hours 2.5 days per year 0.006 time of a w year. Why so much fuss over such a small fraction of our time. If this not intolerance then what is? Its not like we live in Norway or Canada where it is always quiet and slightest loudspeaker noise can be inconvenient. We are Indians, we live in constant noise pollution of traffic horns, vehicular engine sounds, hawkers shouts, children playing outside, marriage band procession p ing, neighboring family fighting and cursing, loud music, baba's sermons, TV, and what not? So, why make a fuss over nothing. Compare it to Diwali patakas, 10 days Ganesh songs, and every other festival in Hindu Calendaar, all are noisy.
                        Reply
                        1. M
                          Motivated History
                          Apr 19, 2017 at 11:21 pm
                          You are an . Add all that 2 mins × 5 times x 365 x ( number of hindu s noise number of christian s noise number of muslim s noise ..... number of secular s noise ) you will realize you are an or that you are already deaf.
                          Reply
                        2. G
                          G YAGNESWARAN
                          Apr 19, 2017 at 9:06 pm
                          We need many mare Sonu Nigams to call the bluff of Islamic fundamentalists and contain noise pollution of all kinds.
                          Reply
                          1. J
                            John Abram
                            Apr 19, 2017 at 10:04 pm
                            and to call the bluff of Hindu fundamentalist with Diwali crackers noise pollution, 10 days Ganesh festival contineous loud speakers, even aarti is done on loud speakers. All Hindu festivals make noise if nothing at least there will be bells ringing. Whereas Muslim festivals of Eids, there is no noise pollution.
                            Reply
                            1. S
                              Subodh
                              Apr 21, 2017 at 12:48 am
                              John Abram no one said he has problem with Azaan. But they have problem when loudspeaker in the early morning start blaring from all side. See I'm giving you one analogy Decide you answer: Suppose you are in captive of some terrorist. They gives you two situation to pick and will let you go: (1) Be in captive for one year with regular moderate torture. (2) Be in captive few days with heavy torture. Which one will you pick? I'm living in a metro city where 5 mosque within 3 km start blaring.. I generally due to work sleep around 2 PM. And need to wake up around 5 with frustration. Some can tolerate some can't. For your fact I woke up yesterday (20/05/17) at 5:05 AM check if time is correct as Azaan time.
                          2. A
                            Akshay
                            Apr 19, 2017 at 9:00 pm
                            #pres ute It's not unnecessary elongation by Sonu. Even common people had problem from this noise pollution. All kinds of noises whether they are emerging from temples or mosques should be banned.
                            Reply
                            1. D
                              devender
                              Apr 19, 2017 at 8:18 pm
                              What to do ? Because nobody in msm raised this issue for 60 plus years. Atleast abrurdity did. You should open a office in bandra kurla complex and see. Tens of mosques often within 50 meters of each other start screaming together by making every meeting every conversation come to standstill.
                              Reply
                              1. C
                                Citizen
                                Apr 19, 2017 at 7:49 pm
                                If every one keep quite who is going to bell the cat??? There are so many issues that need to be changed in the nation this is one the others are blocking the roads in the name of religion,functions etc like the same calling bandhs and destruction of ets both private/public let there be more Sonus Kudos to Nigam. We need a society who respects law including the elected guys who think they are above the laws they made recent incident of AI is one. Jaihind
                                Reply
                                1. R
                                  Raj Engineer
                                  Apr 19, 2017 at 7:18 pm
                                  EVEN IN OCEN CITY MARYLAND USA THERE IS NOISE CONTROL TAX $ 116 PER YEAR, POLICE DEPT. IS VERY STRICT WITH. LOUD NOISE DISTURBANCE. SONU YOU ARE REAL HERO !!!
                                  Reply
                                  1. D
                                    DA
                                    Apr 19, 2017 at 7:15 pm
                                    Secularism doesn't mean "non-religion" anywhere. It means separation of church and state. The concept of secularism is redundant in our country as we did not have any central papal authority equivalent which had powers over the state.
                                    Reply
                                    1. S
                                      s
                                      Apr 19, 2017 at 6:42 pm
                                      Sonu Nigam , plea is entirely justified . The rabble rousing Cleric tried to cushion his stupid statement by saying he would have said the same baout Sonu had he mentioned aboit temple bells. That is exactly what Sonu has been saying. As a practicing Hindu i firmly believe there is God in silence and the more we shout and create noise we are distracted from God and loose our bearings. Ganesh festival is a prime example of how we have commercailised God and how a purely religious function has been downgraded to Bollywood style hungamas.
                                      Reply
                                      1. G
                                        Gopal Kamat
                                        Apr 19, 2017 at 5:50 pm
                                        Ministry of Environment Noise Pollution Rules Nigthly 10pm to 6am only 45db allowed..Azaans are often 10 times that! Ratio of mosques to churches to temples creating night time noise pollution 10:2:0.2 or similar i.e. mosques and churches make the most noise.. and wake people early in the morning.. this must stop, for the right to life (good health) including for non practising muslims and christians, elderly muslims and christians, and simply those muslims and christians who may not need the noise to do their prayers, and can use a watch or a mobile phone are trampled over by the noise creating fanatics.. Sufferers can lodge a police complaint under the Ministry of Environment Rules and stop the noise pollution!
                                        Reply
                                        1. A
                                          Asmaulhusna Rakeeb Vavalam
                                          Apr 19, 2017 at 7:36 pm
                                          I am Proud to be a Muslim. In our street all are Muslim as well but at our street end is a temple build by a Muslim. We are living harmoniously, but on every Hindus festival there is loud speaker Bhajan through out the night. We never ever complain like you. We gracefully respect other's religion inspite of the area is centered around Muslim. We are not so intolerant like the RSS Bhakth and BJP, who find faults in other's religious practice only, when it is on their own religion they neglect it.
                                          Reply
                                          1. Z
                                            Zukum Koza
                                            Apr 19, 2017 at 8:28 pm
                                            --azan is an everyday affair...your sleep is ed daily...5-6 times a year I can understand...but everyday.. e on
                                            1. A
                                              Amna H KhAn
                                              Apr 23, 2017 at 12:52 am
                                              U R WI8...
                                          2. Load More Comments