SBI’s penalties on minimum account balance discouraging as govt moves for digital economy

In recent weeks, steps introduced by some major banks have betrayed one of the key purposes of demonetisation--large-scale adoption and sustained use of banking services to move India’s cash driven economy to a digital economy.

Written by Kanishka Singh | New Delhi | Published: March 6, 2017 6:17 pm
State Bank of India, SBI minimum balance, SBI minimum balance mandatory, SBI news (Picture for Representation)

After doing without it for five years, the State Bank of India has announced that it will impose penalties on non-maintenance of minimum balance in accounts from April 1. It also announced a revision of charges on services like ATMs. But, does this step, one of many new changes in banking regulations imposed after demonetisation, help in achieving the government’s larger goal of currency recall–keeping the larger portion of people’s money in the banking system?

A number of changes in banking regulations have taken place since the November 8 announcement of demonetisation and currency recall. But, in recent weeks, steps introduced by some major banks have betrayed one of the key purposes of demonetisation–large-scale adoption and sustained use of banking services to move India’s cash driven economy to a digital economy. One of the prime achievements of currency recall was that a huge amount of money came back into the banking system which gave it a much-needed boost. What was needed were easier banking regulations as an incentive for people to keep their money in banks. Penalties were definitely not the wisest way to go.

According to SBI’s announcement, failure to maintain a minimum average balance (MAB) in SBI accounts (SAB) will invite a penalty of ₹100 plus service tax if the balance falls below 75 per cent of MAB. If the drop is 50 per cent or less, then the penalty levied will be ₹50 plus service tax. In other revisions, SBI will allow only three levy-free deposits in savings bank accounts in a month and after that it will charge ₹50 and service tax on each transaction. Levies on current accounts could go as high as ₹20,000. Charges at ATM transactions have also been set. The bank will charge ₹15 as SMS alert charge for people who hold debit cards and maintain average quarterly balance of ₹25,000 during a three-month period.

India is essentially a cash driven economy and after the push for digitization after demonetisation and currency recall, the dependence on cash is returning to previous levels. According to the Reserve Bank of India, ATM cash withdrawals in the months of October last year was ₹2.55 trillion. In November and December, it reduced to ₹1.24 trillion and ₹0.85 trillion, respectively.

However, as remonetisation kicked in and limits on cash withdrawals were removed, ATM withdrawals in January 2017 increased to ₹1.52 trillion. In subsequent months from October 2016 to January 2017, the number of ATM transactions in the country were 802.68 million, 561.76 million, 630.85 million and 712.79 million, respectively. In October 2016, out of the total currency in circulation worth ₹17,540.22 billion, currency with the public was ₹17,022.10 billion. The figure in January reduced to ₹11,067.91 billion in circulation and ₹10,635.27 billion with the public.

It is natural that the public would want to withdraw and keep as much cash handy as possible as enough currency notes become available. During such time, a move like a penalty on non-maintenance of minimum account will reduce the confidence of a poor, economically weaker or even a lower middle-class person who doesn’t earn enough or earn at all and hence is unable to maintain the minimum ₹5,000 balance.

Also, one of the problems witnessed after demonetisation was hoarding of valid currency notes. People were not willing to deposit the currency back into banks once it came in their possession. Imposing levies on deposits, essentially, seems illogical as it pushes people against depositing money in banks.

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

More From Kanishka Singh
  1. J
    Mar 10, 2017 at 7:10 am
    I disagree with what you have said. The poor ( marginal you said, but in numbers- each district has around a thousand families minimum, who go through their living by daily wages.) Should close their accounts you say! Is this a democratic country or not? It really disgusts me to see people like you who say things like that. I would say forcing people in such acts is a sign of fading democracy!
    1. Sudharsan R
      Mar 8, 2017 at 1:56 am
      Minimum Balance Charges is going affect Millions of people . Who will never turn back , Public Sector Bank-SBI should reconsider since it has millions of customers mostly middle cl / poor and average people who will get affected since they only use account to save little money for thier day to day use. Is this cashless economy and Digital India?
      1. K
        Mar 7, 2017 at 1:28 pm
        "purposes of demonetisation–large-scale adoption and sustained use of banking services to move India’s cash driven economy to a digital economy"lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;This was not purpose stated by PM on 08.11.2016lt;br/gt;lt;br/gt;Who knows the answer ?
        1. B
          B P
          Mar 8, 2017 at 9:20 am
          Is SBI discouraging account holder to put their money in Banks. The proposed changes in bank charges only promote people to their monies in bed rooms and lockers. PM advised all poor people to open accounts and it seems SBI is our burdened with new accounts. lt;br/gt;Do not discourage new bank account holder till they get some benefits and feel the convenience for opening operating bank accounts accounts.
          1. C
            Mar 6, 2017 at 2:14 pm
            I do not trust Banks anymore these days. If you are rich they are your true servent, else they are master of Rules.
            1. Load More Comments