Jayalalithaa, Mayawati and Mamata: Firmly in control, but with no backup

The three women leaders, all known to be in possession of an overbearing, dictatorial streak, have steered the uneven territory of politics with extraordinary craft. Undoubtedly, they are forces to be reckoned with.

Written by Radhika Iyengar | New Delhi | Updated: December 7, 2016 2:27 pm
Jayalalithaa, Jayalalithaa death, Jayalalithaa passes away, Mamata Banerjee, Mayawati, Tamil nadu chief minister, Jaya, West bengal CM Mamata Banerjee, BSP, BSP Mayawati, Ama, Politics, Indian politics, indian political system, women, women politicians, women in politics, O Panneerselvam, AIADMK, DIDI, Amma, Behenji, india news, indian eapress news Mamta Banerjee is often referred to as ‘Didi’. Mayawati is affectionately called ‘Behenji’, while Jayalalithaa was endearingly called ‘Amma’.

In India, Mayawati, Mamata Banerjee and the late J Jayalalithaa, have been prominent women political figures. In a predominantly male-dominated political landscape, the three were able to carve out individual, independent identities, single-handedly running their parties as authoritative, one-woman shows. However, while each of these leaders focused essentially on propelling their parties forward and devoted years into sculpting their larger-than-life personas, they overshadowed or squashed the possible emergence of their successors. To put it more bluntly, none of them has been able to groom a prominent heir of equal caliber who could have the same crowd-drawing prowess that these three women command.

WATCH | J.Jayalalithaa’s Life Journey

The three embraced their feminine identity, often reveling in images relating to either a mother-figure or an older sister, hinting at their ability to sweep their followers under their wing and fiercely protect them. Mamata Banerjee, whose name literally translates to ‘motherly love’, is often referred to as ‘Didi’ (elder sister). Mayawati is affectionately called ‘Behenji’ (elder sister), while Jayalalithaa was endearingly called ‘Amma’ (mother) by her supporters. However, while each enjoys an exalted standing, none of them have formidable successors who could take their legacy forward.

Take the late Jayalalithaa, for instance. As the news regarding Jayalalithaa’s spiraling health was relayed over the last few days, questions regarding who could most likely be her successor in the AIADMK, began ricocheting in newsrooms and households. There was a belief that her passing would leave behind an uncertain, unnerving vacuum. However, when she did pass away, Jayalalithaa’s trusted aide, O Panneerselvam stepped up and was elected as the party head. Within moments, he was also sworn in as the Chief Minister of Tamil Nadu. Many, however, doubt whether Panneerselvam will be able to command the torrential pull Jayalalithaa was able to command during her reign. Though he has had the experience of being chief minister more than once, Panneerselvam appears meek, more subdued in comparison to his predecessor’s towering stature. Although he displayed faithful allegiance to Amma, she never considered the idea of passing down her strategic and tactful political expertise to him.

Jayalalithaa’s overpowering persona, however, wasn’t an overnight creation. She grew into a political force under the tutelage of AIADMK’s founder M G Ramamchandran, who hand-held her towards political stardom. Under his wing, a politically shy and inexperienced Jayalalithaa transformed into a confident protégé, stealthily rising in the male-dominated ranks of politics. She eventually metamorphosed into a demigod – under MGR, she had learned how to artfully project herself as a larger-than-life phenomenon who was ought to be worshiped.

WATCH | O. Panneerselvam: 10 Things You Need To Know

When it comes to Mayawati, the story isn’t too different. Mayawati too, was groomed to become a political icon. When she met Kanshi Ram, the founder of Bahujan Samaj Party, he assumed the role of her mentor. Kanshi Ram carefully molded her into a fierce activist for the Dalits. In his eyes, she was to become a leader who would go on to be synonymous with the overarching identity of the down-trodden lower caste of India, the Dalits. As Kanshi Ram steadily gained political momentum, Mayawati piggybacked on his journey to fame. Ram inculcated in her a strong fighting spirit, leading Mayawati to eventually transform into a political Machiavellian who became well-versed with realpolitik. However, it all assumed a macabre tone when Kanshi Ram passed away. As Mayawati made herself comfortable in the chair of the party head, Kanshi Ram’s sister promptly began pointing fingers at Mayawati, holding her responsible for his death. The noise eventually drowned out. In October 2016 however, BJP demanded a CBI investigation into his death, prodding Samajwadi Party to look into the matter.

Like Jayalalithaa, Mayawati does not have a successor in place. In August 2008, there was speculation that Raja Ram would be the possible heir of her legacy. That, in her absence, he would take the reigns of Bahujan Samaj Party. Back then, Raja Ram was more or less a marginal figure, even though he was functioning as BSP’s vice-president. He joined BSP at the behest of Kanshi Ram (founder of BSP and Mayawati’s predecessor) and then steadily mounted the political ladder within the party. Reticent of the media, however, he rarely found himself to be the focus of mainstream conversations. Not much therefore is known about him except the fact that he is 18 years younger to Mayawati and a Dalit. However, the same month, possibly due to an internal dispute, Mayawati stripped Raja Ram of his post and replaced him with Alok Kumar Verma – an unlikely and even more unknown figure.

WATCH | 5 Lesser Known Facts About Sasikala Natarajan

By pulling Raja Ram out as a party authority, it appeared that Mayawati ostensibly wanted to obliterate competition. It also hinted that she wasn’t prepared to be overshadowed, nor was she ready to groom anyone. Although Raja Ram continues to be the party’s vice-president even today, since 2008 there has been no news relating to who could be Mayawati’s likely political heir. Within the party, there is a firm belief that Mayawati holds her cards close to her chest and is unable to trust any leader.

Mamata Banerjee who is at present the sitting Chief Minister of West Bengal, leads the All India Trinamool Congress. Banerjee’s popularity is unrivaled in West Bengal, as she possesses an instinctive ability to rally the masses. A firebrand, Mamta severed her ties with the Indian National Congress to establish her own party, TMC in 1997. Unlike Mayawati and Jayalalithaa, Mamta Banerjee didn’t have a mentor. She carved her own political trajectory, learning the trick of being a master strategist on her own. However, like Mayawati and Jayalalithaa, Mamata Banerjee too, doesn’t have a successor in place.

The three women leaders, all known to be in possession of an overbearing, dictatorial streak, have steered the uneven territory of politics with extraordinary craft. Undoubtedly, they are forces to be reckoned with. However, throughout their political career, they’ve refused to take the backseat, and in doing so, stopped short of passing the baton to anyone to take forth their legacy, one they painstakingly worked towards building.

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

  1. C
    Chandu Shah
    Dec 7, 2016 at 8:43 am
    Jaya was a dictator and these two are the same
    (0)(0)
    Reply
    1. Debasish Sarkar
      Dec 7, 2016 at 11:31 am
      It is quite obvious that If some one [Male or female] is overtly over exposed [made] as a Macho Man/woman in his/her Party followers and some of those are successfully can developing a ring of coterie, then this special group will certainly make an aura around their chosen Leader as a Super MAN or WANDER WOMAN. And These Followers of His/Her will definitely induce divine qualities amongst their beloved Leaders. Then some how a chain reaction has been set up and eventually the augmented leader become all around pervasive GREAT LEADER. Same thing that happened in cases of Jayalalithaa, Mayabati and Mamata. Whoever in these trio' s parties you never see any budding second in command leader who can successfully carry out the respective party's leadership during the absence of their respective Superlative Superlative Leader's. lt;br/gt;These leaders [mentioned above] are unable to create or generate any successor to lead their respective party for the future generation. And in my view they [these leaders] became TIN POT DICTATORS. When they die HIS/Her party will die. lt;br/gt;Only Democracy can keep any party to survive or alive for long long time. Amen.
      (0)(0)
      Reply
      1. C
        Chirayu
        Dec 7, 2016 at 9:52 am
        mamta n maya r corrupt arrogant castiest n communal politicians. They never care for nation. Only money and votes is wat they want.
        (0)(0)
        Reply
        1. R
          Rakesh Pandit
          Dec 7, 2016 at 7:38 am
          When Mamta Banerji and Mayawati die, their funeral procession will never have such huge crowds seen yesterday in Tamilnadu. Mamta is arrogant and whimsical, while Mayawati cant speak one sentence without reading from given script !! Both look dishevelled and have a dirty appearance. No charishma at all.
          (0)(0)
          Reply
          1. N
            Niladrinath Mohanty
            Dec 7, 2016 at 2:38 pm
            Mayawati always reads out whatever she has to say and still she is a m leader. This has baffled me.
            (0)(0)
            Reply
            1. Load More Comments