Nepalis don’t share Indian ambivalence towards China

While India’s stated (and strong) opposition to BRI is that CPEC runs through the disputed Kashmir region, its nervousness runs deeper than that.

Written by Akhilesh Upadhyay | Kathmandu | Published:May 17, 2017 7:30 am
Chinese President Xi Jinping attends a news conference at the end of the Belt and Road Forum in Beijing, China May 15, 2017. Reuters/Jason Lee

Chinese President Xi Jinping, this past week, showcased his hugely ambitious Belt and Road Initiative (BRI) to heads of state and government from 29 countries in Beijing. Through trillions of dollars of expenditure on land, maritime, air and cyberspace connectivity in the next 10 years or so, China aspires to link Asia, the Middle East, Europe and Africa.

China believes that BRI will bring Asia, Middle East, Europe, and Africa closer through inland roads and maritime routes that retrace the old Silk Road that made China the center of global commerce and civilisation for centuries. The initiative spans more than 68 countries and encompasses close to 40 per cent of global GDP. This makes BRI the grandest infrastructure framework project humankind has envisioned to date – far bigger than the reconstruction of Western European economies through the US-funded Marshall Plan after the Second World War.

“History is our best teacher,” declared President Xi in Beijing on Sunday. “The glory of the ancient silk routes shows that geographical distance is not insurmountable. If we take the first courageous step towards each other, we can embark on a path leading to friendship, shared development, peace, harmony and a better future.”

Whether you buy into the Chinese vision depends on how you view the rejuvenation of China and your place within the new security architecture.

In attendance at the Beijing conference was Nepal’s deputy Prime Minister and Finance Minister Krishna Bahadur Mahara, who had only last week overseen the official signing of the BRI (or OBOR) framework agreement in Kathmandu.

The scale of the BRI Forum in Beijing should be taken into account to get a sense of President Xi’s ambitions. In attendance were Russian President Vladimir Putin, Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan and Pakistan’s Prime Minister Nawaz Sharif. Even the North Koreans, with whom China shares strained ties, were present. Though the world’s leading and third biggest economies, the US and Japan, were not represented by senior leaders, they did send their representatives. Both the US and Japan share strategic rivalries with China.

Other Asian luminaries present at the Beijing forum included Indonesian President Joko Widodo, Malaysian Prime Minister Najib Razak, Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte and Mayanmar’s Aung San Suu Kyi. Australia, which increasingly views itself as an Asian power, was also present.

India was conspicuously absent.

Nepal Prime Minister Pushpa Kamal Dahal with Prime Minister Narendra Modi at Hyderabad House in New Delhi. File/Express Photo by Prem Nath Pandey

There has been talk in Kathmandu that Nepal’s Prime Minister, Pushpa Kamal Dahal, had cleverly avoided the Beijing conference on the pretext that he could not leave the country as local elections were being held in Nepal. Elections were held across 34 of Nepal’s 75 districts on May 14, the very day President Xi addressed the Belt and Road Forum.

Dahal’s absence, according to this thesis, was aimed at placating New Delhi, which has its own fears of encirclement by Chinese allies in its neighborhood. China already enjoys Observer status with SAARC, the South Asian Association for Regional Cooperation, and China’s economic heft has won it new friends in Colombo and Dhaka, both of whom are signatories to BRI.

One of BRI’s core components is the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor (CPEC), which connects China’s western Xinjiang province with the Pakistani port of Gwadar, giving China alternative access to the Gulf region, and thus energy. But there’s surely more to CPEC than just energy access. It will bind the cash-strapped Pakistan and resource-rich China so closely, there are already both great expectations and deep anxieties in Pakistan, India and beyond.

Also Read | Manish Tewari writes: OBOR is the grandest failure of Indian foreign policy

While India’s stated (and strong) opposition to BRI is that CPEC runs through the disputed Kashmir region, its nervousness runs deeper than that.

Last week, when Nepal finally signed on to the BRI framework agreement in Kathmandu, it finally put an end to Nepali suspicion that Prime Minister Dahal would succumb to Indian demands and keep away from BRI. The news prominently featured in all newspapers and TV networks here. The PM has received some criticism for dragging his feet on the issue, since there is strong support for BRI in Nepal from across the political spectrum and Nepali public.

“New Delhi had committed a blunder of strategic proportions with the five-month long border blockade.” File/Express Photo by Prem Nath Pandey

We, in Nepal, feel that we urgently need to diversify our trade and transit dependence on India. This perception has been further fortified after New Delhi expressed unhappiness over the promulgation of our new Constitution promulgated in September 2015 by a sovereign Constituent Assembly through a two-third majority.

Expressing displeasure is fine diplomacy; imposing a five-month long border blockade is anything but that.

The blockade only compounded Nepal’s misery, as it followed shortly after the devastating earthquakes that struck our country in April and May that year. Reconstruction work was left in complete disarray. Around 9,000 Nepalis had lost their lives and around 750,000 houses were destroyed or damaged in the earthquakes. But the Nepali economy suffered more as a result of the Indian blockade than the earthquakes.

New Delhi had committed a blunder of strategic proportions.

During the border blockade, the government headed by CPN-UML leader K P Sharma Oli signed 10 framework agreements with China. And Nepal, for the first time, began to import its petroleum products from Chinese companies; it had otherwise been an Indian Oil Corporation monopoly. China and Nepal also agreed that Nepal would now be able to use Chinese ports for its trade.

Of course, we realize that the China’s eastern seaboard is hundreds of miles away, and that Nepal and Chinese industrial and urban hubs are separated by the vast Himalaya and by the arid and sparsely populated Tibetan plateau. But there is a growing sense that Nepal-China agreements have opened new doors for trade, transit and connectivity opportunities.

Also Read | C Raja Mohan writes: The politics of territory

The two sides have held talks about the possibility of expanding Tibet’s railways to Nepal. This will make trade and transit through China much more affordable than in the past. Indeed, the idea of trans-Himalayan railway connectivity is now firmly lodged in Nepali imagination. Unsurprisingly, it received widespread media attention during the Indian border blockade in 2015-2016.

If Oli’s party, the CPN-UML, fares well in the local elections (counting in major metros is expected to last for several days), his nationalist supporters will feel vindicated about taking a position against India.

This is where the colossal BRI becomes strategically significant to Nepal. If it comes into fruition according to plan, the Chinese will derive a groundswell of goodwill from Nepalis. As long as the US and the Western world view Nepal through India’s geostrategic prism, Nepal will always look to China as a counterweight, as happened during the recent border blockade.

Few Indian and Western analysts seem to realise that Nepalis don’t share their ambivalence towards Beijing.

Akhilesh Upadhyay is Editor, Kathmandu Post, in Kathmandu, Nepal

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

  1. P
    Pradip
    May 17, 2017 at 8:05 pm
    Hats off to Akhilesh Upadhya. You have bluntly sum up courage to tell india stay out of your business. India does what it has mastered over the years. Being so cynical, it has simply failed india to honor democratic values of neighbouring nations. India will be loosing it's friends more rapidly if it does not act wisely.
    Reply
    1. H
      HOMER
      May 17, 2017 at 6:36 pm
      Is this PRESS UTES being paid to Insinuate that India is isolated and has no support and hence wrong in not joining this -chini plan to colonize and dominate the fools who are too blind or have been bought like our previous PM and his master?
      Reply
      1. R
        raj
        May 17, 2017 at 6:13 pm
        India and Nepal should have equal relations and sovereignty of Nepal should never come under questions. Therefore, all Nepalis should get entry into India through passport and visa and vice-versa for Indians going into Nepal. Equal rules and equal facilities to all of them. Nepal must be treated like Sri Lanka, Myanmar, Singapore or any other normal bilateral country. Similarly, Nepal should be free to build relations with whoever they want.
        Reply
        1. V
          Vincent Chin
          May 17, 2017 at 3:14 pm
          China will drop to its knees to beg India for forgiveness in the future, just you wait and see. When CPEC, OBOR and other Chinese Initiatives are completed and the w region except India is lifted out of poverty into a burgeoning middle cl society, there won't be anyone left to take up such menial jobs like cleaning the toilets and garbage es. That will be the time when countries such as Nepal, stan & China will come running to India to beg the Indians to take up millions of low-paying janitorial jobs in their countries. And India will have no choice but to obliged in the millions to prevent massive unemployment at home.
          Reply
          1. H
            HOMER
            May 17, 2017 at 6:39 pm
            Right now that is what china is doing for the west! Why does it think India is like them? We didn't eat roaches rats and dogs to survive! And if the Americans decide to push, China will again go back to eating roaches rats and dogs!
            Reply
            1. B
              Bruce Halford
              May 18, 2017 at 4:18 pm
              Where do you live? I want your address. I'll come to you, at your place, and have a talk with you, and certainly by default I don't like you and during the conversation if I happen to dislike you even a bit more I'll chop ur in' disgusting head off. You don't say a word against my country. You get that aaswipe.
          2. M
            mayam
            May 17, 2017 at 2:45 pm
            Nepal doesn't count in anybody's calculations!
            Reply
            1. H
              Hedonist
              May 17, 2017 at 2:28 pm
              Nepal will not be able to repay $8 billion loan from China.
              Reply
              1. N
                Naveen Alish
                May 17, 2017 at 4:05 pm
                Really? Why does it bother India, Indians and Indian Media then as Nepal joins the OBOR?
                Reply
                1. H
                  HOMER
                  May 17, 2017 at 6:43 pm
                  What makes you think Indian are bothered by what a tiny worm of a county does for China? We don't even care that S have their daughters service America, their boys service Arabs and their women service China! If Nepal want to earn the same way that's their prerogative , just like becoming commie was and becoming Muslim was for many here!
                  1. M
                    Maha Bharat
                    May 18, 2017 at 10:30 am
                    Dear Mr. Homo, Sorry to hear about your frustrations regarding Nepal. It is indeed views like yours that has made India the slums of slums. Not to mention, India is more popular in the world as a rapist country than an annoying . Several popular nicknames are ' ' and ' chai-wales'. But let's not get into those details. We have so much respect for Mr. Homo and your kind....and we miss you dearly. Love you. Regards, TereBachcheKiMaBanneWali
                2. D
                  Dirgha Raj Prasai
                  May 17, 2017 at 1:58 pm
                  'One Belt One Road- between Nepal- China (?) Nepal China relations are as old as history itself, which has been further confirmed by the exchange of visits, several centuries ago, from both Nepal & China at the level of Buddhist, monks, scholars and artists. Nepal has been giving the primacy in its foreign policy to the preservation of national independence, sovereignty and territorial integrity and has consistently supported the one-China policy and has categorically started that Taiwan and Tibet are integral parts of the Chinese territory. Actually, China and Nepal have good neighborly and friendly relations and neither of them poses any kind of threat.But, in the context of 'One Belt One Road (OBOR) to link Nepal’s border with road and railways connectivity. may the Nepal China cordially. But, If the Nepalese people depends only on China, will be very dangerous the field of productions, Nepal must be sufficient to export the Nepalese goods in the international fields.
                  Reply
                  1. P
                    Pradip Thapa
                    May 17, 2017 at 7:40 pm
                    Then if you don't care then why the is always there on your news media when we are having agreements with China?
                    Reply
                  2. U
                    Upendra Gautam
                    May 17, 2017 at 1:52 pm
                    The best policy of Nepal is to treat its relations with China and India separately and distinctively. Only a developed and strong Nepal can deliver peace and security in the Trans-Himalayan region.
                    Reply
                    1. K
                      Kedar nath
                      May 17, 2017 at 6:38 pm
                      OBOR could be very good opportunity for Nepal but this ultimately tough job cannot drag by our foolish leaders, it could be like a stone bite . Also our anarchism democracy play negative role.
                      Reply
                    2. M
                      mahesh
                      May 17, 2017 at 12:52 pm
                      The road going to Indian servegenic Chinese start road construction they r facing terrorists and Taliban's after some years take over by India c then China mind block this is happen take some time
                      Reply
                      1. R
                        Rajan Parajuli
                        May 17, 2017 at 11:29 am
                        Nepal signed OBOR agreement at a time when India is widely perceived negatively than ever in the history and secondly it is signed by the Government which is strongly backed by India. The recent trend explains quite a lot about Indian Influence vs Chinese Influence in Nepali Politics, Nepali civil society and Nepali bureaucrats.
                        Reply
                        1. B
                          Bahubali
                          May 17, 2017 at 11:38 am
                          Nepal is run by Maoist party and they want very little to do with India. Current PM came with conspiracy theory and RA&W is responsible for kil of the Nepali King. They use it as propa a to make nepali hate Indians. They are more ideologically similar to China than India. Anyway, they will soon learn their lesson by being colonized or in heavy debt by China.
                          Reply
                          1. K
                            K. K.
                            May 17, 2017 at 12:45 pm
                            Bahubali should ask the Brown Sahibs of Delhi, why they had sheltered and supported the Nepali Maoists since 1996, Then he would know
                          2. B
                            Bahubali
                            May 17, 2017 at 11:38 am
                            Nepal is run by Maoist party and they want very little to do with India. Current PM came with conspiracy theory and RA&W is responsible for kil of the Nepali King. They use it as propa a to make nepali hate Indians. They are more ideologically similar to China than India. Anyway, they will soon learn their lesson by being colonized or in heavy debt by China.
                            Reply
                            1. P
                              prince
                              May 17, 2017 at 12:15 pm
                              If you are unaware, then get educated about background and history of "people's war". How and where it was conceived, who supported it with training and financial backing as well as providing shelters mostly in government shelters and training camp in chakrata. Geopolitics is more than what govt tells you and what meets your eye.
                            2. H
                              HOMER
                              May 17, 2017 at 6:47 pm
                              Ha ha ha! Nepal is a puppy of China and soon to be what STAN has been of american just a kept companion while away from home! You know what I mean?
                              Reply
                              1. B
                                Bruce Halford
                                May 18, 2017 at 4:23 pm
                                Tu to marega . ki maut marega. Bas tu address bol tera. Kaha rehta hai. Mai kasam khata hu tujhe to mai marunga hi marunga. Pata karke rahunga tu kaun hai. Tu marega .
                              2. H
                                HOMER
                                May 17, 2017 at 6:50 pm
                                Obviously you are as ignorant as a pappu trained in a madarassa! Nepal is a lap dog of China! A commie government not knowing communism is a fails system! But then a KEPT hardly has any choice but to be what the client wants it to be! Ha ha ha!
                                Reply
                              3. K
                                Kamal Pasha
                                May 17, 2017 at 11:12 am
                                A big slap on the face of India by a Hindu majority country Nepal. Nepal is more intelligent than India. India is getting isolated by BJP government of Modi.
                                Reply
                                1. B
                                  Bahubali
                                  May 17, 2017 at 11:32 am
                                  Nepal is run by a maoist party, they find China to be more ideologically similar than India. There is nothing about being intelligent. Nepal has no idea what he is getting into, to show animosity towards BJP and India. Look at Sri Lanka or Myanmar, both of these countries are suffering from huge debt after Chinese investment. The same will happen to Nepal. Sri Lanka denied the invitation, though Sri Lanka had bitter relation with India. Cards will unfold with time and Nepal will learn its lesson. Wait and watch.
                                  Reply
                                  1. B
                                    Bahubali
                                    May 17, 2017 at 11:33 am
                                    Nepal is run by a maoist party, they find China to be more ideologically similar than India. There is nothing about being intelligent. Nepal has no idea what he is getting into, to show animosity towards BJP and India. Look at Sri Lanka or Myanmar, both of these countries are suffering from huge debt after Chinese investment. The same will happen to Nepal. Sri Lanka denied the invitation, though Sri Lanka had bitter relation with India. Cards will unfold with time and Nepal will learn its lesson. Wait and watch.
                                    Reply
                                    1. N
                                      Naveen Alish
                                      May 17, 2017 at 1:38 pm
                                      If you are saying Sri Lanka denied OBOR Summit invitation, check your facts. In fact, Sri Lankan prime minister, right after saying goodbye to Modi flew to China for the summit
                                      1. B
                                        Bruce Halford
                                        May 18, 2017 at 4:33 pm
                                        First do some research then speak up. Your Mahan India imposed an embargo on petroleum and gas against Nepal. A harsh measure against a country that was recently struck with 7.8 M earthquake. Why would you do that? Why would you people want us to be on our knees and beg you for food and money? Why? Then you say Maoists of Nepal are commies. WRONG. They are more capitalists than any bourgeois you'll ever see. Nepal doesn't want to forsake any relationship ties with India. It's just that we want to be self dependent or at least interdependent on both our neighbors - China and India - but definitely NOT complete dependency on one so called (wanna be) BIG BROTHER i.e India.
                                      2. S
                                        sambath
                                        May 17, 2017 at 11:59 am
                                        You Porki, Your terrorist country has been isolated by the world. Don't sleep and make dreams, wake up and see the world. We have a own economic policy and we are not dependent on either you or china. We have a big market of china, and if we ignore chine goods then the loss will be to china and not to us. similarly, your country will be the colony of china very soon. Understand and write in the forum. This is a reply to you, if you are a stani, othrewise you are deshdroki
                                        Reply
                                      3. N
                                        Nishant
                                        May 17, 2017 at 10:28 am
                                        Phase 2 of one belt will be completed by India. It will become a dominant industrial power surpassing China in the next 15 to 20 years. That will be a great balancer and justifier in itself, a counterweight built by US, an and India combined...producing innovative products of far superior quality that China can envision right now. One belt will be invested by China, but exploited to its fullest extent with Indian team's parti tion. What will be needed for this plan to succeed: 1. A belief in oneself. 2. Develop a vast industrial base of superior technology at break neck speed, so that we can be the leaders, rather than be dictated, once we start exploring the one belt in a way we would find most beneficial to ourselves. 3. By becoming the leaders of output, we should be able to avoid the pitfall of debt trap, and prevent ourselves from becoming exporters of raw materials, losing a w lot in the process. . .it is a prediction, which could soon become a necessity !
                                        Reply
                                        1. K
                                          Kamal Pasha
                                          May 17, 2017 at 11:09 am
                                          Nishant : Wake up man. In th next 20 years, India would have been divided in many different countries on the caste basis. Modi's policies is helping this future by creating hatred amongst different castes.
                                          Reply
                                          1. N
                                            Nishant
                                            May 18, 2017 at 2:54 am
                                            Mr Pasha: the world will realign due to what China is doing, and what other nations are getting into, as Chinese loans are not like IMF or WB loans which allow nations to build and improve their building capacity. You are caught with castes, but as u will possibly see, US, Europe, India and J a pan could have a combined industrial front in future competing with China-Pak and a bandwagon of very small countries. One belt would be Chinese investment, but others are likely to be smarter, and could be using it even more to their advantage. Unfortunately small and corrupt countries will lose, and a terroristhird country like P tan will have no chance surviving an economic chess game.
                                        2. C
                                          Case123
                                          May 17, 2017 at 9:43 am
                                          Nobody can bully the brave and clever Nepali like the past from now onward.
                                          Reply
                                          1. N
                                            Naveen Alish
                                            May 17, 2017 at 10:47 am
                                            India better focus on feeding its majority of population struck by poverty, population living in the slums, building toilets, stopping rape and so on. Leave such ambitious projects to 'real' superpowers, not 'self proclaimed' super power like India....
                                            Reply
                                            1. S
                                              sambath
                                              May 17, 2017 at 12:04 pm
                                              Thanks for advise from Porkistan and we advise you to take care of your useless terrorists. surely, they are going to strike at your country in CPEC routes. wait and cry. Your country is not a exporter of goods but exporter of terrorists.
                                          2. H
                                            Hari Prasad Shrestha
                                            May 17, 2017 at 9:00 am
                                            China has proved its global suprimacy through massive support of world leaders. India should not hide by citing its security in this intiative. Later or sooner, India would join OBOR initiative through Nepal because it can't ignore 40 global economy. Nepal will certainly join India and China economically.
                                            Reply
                                            1. T
                                              Truth
                                              May 17, 2017 at 8:02 am
                                              Modi A S S U M E S that he can dictate everyone like he did in dictating DeMon to Urjit Patel ........Our neighbours have refused to get fooled and dictated by him.......His Bhakts are of course a C L A S S apart ........As for the pathetic Opposition, the least said the better of them !
                                              Reply
                                              1. M
                                                M G
                                                May 17, 2017 at 7:59 am
                                                Ofcourse.. not surprising. What the Nepalese should read are the reports and articles on the following links below. All those countries now salivating about all these Chinese conjuring tricks should be aware of the real intentions of the Chinese... All they are interested in is raping and pillaging everyone to the benefit of the Chinese--- specially now that their economy is faltering.... Of course the s who are the concubines of China would agree with them, but I would urge everyone to read the following articles that I just happen to find.. ... but there are hundreds more.... s: www.africanpost /opinion/55-individual/1148-the-rape-of-africa-by-china : amanpour.blogs.cnn /2013/03/29/is-china-buying-up-africa/ : www.scmp /news/china/article/1254703/chinese-gold-miners-abused-and-raped-ghanaians-says-online-report Please spread these articles among all the Nepalese... thank you
                                                Reply
                                                1. C
                                                  Case123
                                                  May 17, 2017 at 9:41 am
                                                  For those who has never set foot on China and still thinks he or she knows China or Chinese or anything Chinese I have this to offer u, from one Canadian who has travelled to China extensively in the last 35 yrs. Btw this article was written recently. Pls google read this article led "Canada and China, a rapidly evolving relationship: Sears" s: www.thestar /opinion/commentary/2017/04/30/canada-and-china-a-rapidly-evolving-relationship-sears Happy Reading!!!
                                                  Reply
                                                2. Load More Comments