The politics of vendetta in the BJP

Whenever the political churning for Opposition unity gets momentum, the BJP machinery unleashes a campaign to malign the image of Opposition leaders. This is how the investigative agencies are being increasingly seen as a new instrument in the BJP’s politics, under the present leadership.

Written by Manoj Kumar Jha | Updated: July 10, 2017 8:52 am
Lalu yadav, CBI raid, Lalu yadav CBI raid, RJD, BJP, IRCTC, Rabri Devi, The acceptance and legitimacy being manufactured for this kind of politics of vendetta does not bode well for our democratic political culture. (Source: PTI photo/File)

The politics of vendetta and witch-hunting got a new avatar on July 7 when the Central Bureau Investigation (CBI) decided to raid 12 premises of Rashtriya Janata Dal (RJD) president Lalu Prasad Yadav, his family members and some other people in pursuance of an 11-year-old issue following an FIR lodged at Delhi on July 5.

The utter haste and manner in which these raids were conducted underline the paradigm shift in terms of the standard operating procedures of these agencies, apart from the fact that the independence of these agencies appear to be under serious doubt. Under the rule of law it is presumed that law which is administered, and enforced is accessible, fair, and efficient. It is obvious to anyone that the nuances of rule of law have been compromised in this case — maybe at the behest of the whims of those at the helm of affairs.

We need to first understand the stated “merit” of the case by the CBI director in his press conference on that day. IRCTC, which awarded the lease to these hotels owned by the Yadav family, was constituted by then NDA government of Atal Bihari Vajpayee in 1999; its stated objective was to provide high quality of tourism and catering services to travellers. Since its formation, IRCTC has awarded leases to more than 150 food plazas and food parks on the basis of H1 bidder (Technically Qualified and Highest financial bidder).

According to the facts of this much-sensationalised case by the CBI, IRCTC invited open competitive bidding tender notice for four ‘Yatri-Niwas’ complexes at Delhi, Kolkata, Ranchi and Puri in the latter half of 2006. On the basis of established and prevalent norms i.e. awarding the lease to the highest bidder, the leases were accordingly awarded.

The present regime, which has directed the agency to investigate a “quid pro quo” in these awards, has chosen to ignore the fact that under the same process leases were awarded to the Tata group and Meghalaya hotels for 15 years at Delhi and Kolkata respectively. These leases were awarded in December 2006. Whereas, the alleged transaction of the land to Delite Marketing, owned by Lalu Yadav’s family, took place in February 2005 on the basis of reasonable and adequate compensation as per extant circle rate.

But the BJP government at the centre and its new alliance partner, the CBI, have gone in for a make-believe kind of “quid pro quo” just to tarnish Lalu ji’s image and also to silence his vocal posture against the right-wing authoritarian regime of BJP and RSS.

The CBI under the new director, wants us to believe that the sellers of the land in February 2005 had a divine revelation that two years later, they shall apply for the lease of the ‘Yatri-Niwas’ complexes and eventually become the H1 bidder. It is a mockery of the interpretation of the rule of law, when under direction from “above,” the agency choses to ignore the fact that once a policy decision is taken by the cabinet, routine issues like invitation for tender etc is executed by the corporation, in this case by IRCTC. They should have acknowledged the established precedent that the minister does not intervene in such matters, thereafter. The use of the phrase— quid pro quo and its strange interpretation is repugnant.

Thus, the rationale behind these high decibel raids by the CBI is quite apparent. Many people believe there is a direct correlation between the quantum of opposition against the BJP/RSS and the actions of investigative agencies against the person or political outfit opposing. These supposedly “independent” have begun to “collaborate” with the ruling regime which is making them function like qasi-political outfits. This signals that things are horribly wrong with the grand idea of the “rule of law.”

The fact that these investigative agencies are cherry-picking their cases – picking up some, ignoring others – is what raises grave doubts about them. The same CBI has maintained a worrying silence over the Vypaam matter, which has witnessed at least 50 unnatural deaths. The agency takes the same posture vis-à-vis the DDCA, where a BJP MP has been raising serious issues of financial embezzlement and money laundering involving a top minister in Narendra Modi’s cabinet. This list is getting only longer, what with Lalit Modi and Vijay Mallya, apart from the power tariff scam by private companies perceived to be in proximate corridors of power at the centre.

The reality is that the investigation going on against several leaders of the Opposition are largely based on false and malicious accusations. Many of these cases may not stand in a court of law. However, it provides certain short-term gains for the BJP in managing media headlines – the Vipaksh Mein Sab Chor Hain, or, All Opposition Leaders are Thieves point of view, with the help of some influential TV channels. In fact, the whisperings of the next target has already begun.

It is an established fact that whenever the political churning for Opposition unity gets momentum, the BJP machinery unleashes a campaigng to malign the image of the leaders of the Opposition. This is how the investigative agencies are being increasingly seen as a new instrument in the BJP’s politics, under the present leadership. That is, if you are incapable of dealing with your Opposition through political vocabulary or programmes, you take the cover of these agencies to malign and discredit them. Certainly, this might allow for a few moments of glee for a day or two but it shall destroy the very idea of independence of these agencies which is intrinsic to the rule of law.

The acceptance and legitimacy being manufactured for this kind of politics of vendetta does not bode well for our democratic political culture.

Manoj Kumar Jha is a spokesperson of the RJD.

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

  1. B
    bhupendra bhagtani
    Jul 11, 2017 at 12:07 pm
    Jee bhar ke chori karo. When investigated, shout VENDETTA
    Reply
    1. A
      amit
      Jul 11, 2017 at 11:27 am
      50 unnatural death...what a looser this writer is...sucking up to lalu yadav...jha types bihari...no self respect or shame
      Reply
      1. D
        D K
        Jul 11, 2017 at 7:33 am
        Instead of protecting political people, Hindus are only un protected in present circumstances and even military men are not safe without bullet proof jackets and Sophisticated wapons . What is the meaning of protecting cows and animals instead , women and public is unsafe in every city and militants and goons are active in the country
        Reply
        1. A
          Avinash
          Jul 11, 2017 at 6:26 am
          Sri Jha ji, I understand u r a Professor 🤓. Well then u must not be talking about a Lalu who is out on bail after having done little time in jail? Is he the same Laluji who stole from the COWS, and ask them to appear as his character witness? You r writing about a virtual Lalu who does not exist. The Lalu the world has come to know is a teacher turned politician with a large family and limited means who has devised a way to create wealth for his family far beyond the predictions of any theory any Professor has ever dreamt of .
          Reply
          1. S
            Suren Singh Sahni
            Jul 11, 2017 at 4:31 am
            Selective targets
            Reply
            1. K
              Kk
              Jul 10, 2017 at 10:27 pm
              Manoj Bhaiji, your leader is proven guilty for chara theft by supreme court. Now you are doing SEENAJORI. IE and NDTV will not be able to help in benami property case.
              Reply
              1. M
                Mj
                Jul 10, 2017 at 10:12 pm
                Hmmm.. Thats why 'laluji' came out of your mouth sir, because you are the spokesperson for the greatest party of bihar.. Or I should I say the whole nation. What laluji did for bihar.. Is something even modi wouldn't be able to do it for even Gujarat ever in his entire existence..! What do you think? The pretty and innocent picture you're trying to paint here.. Please do it in front people who don't know Mr. Yadav. Already everyone knows a lot about him. The fodder scam.. His name is still there isn't it.? If he wasn't involved in it,he should say that clearly and loudly in public. Why does our Great politicians think that their name is being maligned all the time ??? Do they really believe their name to be so clean actually!!! What I'm trying to say is clear.. Please work for the benefit the commoners, that'll help you more than playing blame game with each other sir..
                Reply
                1. G
                  Gulabchand Shah
                  Jul 10, 2017 at 10:05 pm
                  Convicted MAHA CHOR LALU should be in jail.
                  Reply
                  1. Load More Comments