Farmers have got nothing in return for ensuring national food security

PM Modi had promised that all loans would be waived, as part of the ‘sabka saath, sabka vikas’ poll promise, yet the UP government decided to waive loans of only about 25 per cent of the farmers, whereas Maharashtra waived loans of Rs 30,000 crores.

Written by V M Singh | Updated: June 22, 2017 11:10 am
farmer, farmer loan, farmer suicide, farmer debt, farmer loan waiver, kisan credit card, narendra modi, UP government, UP loan, indian express news, india news The return from his produce is not enough and he cannot even repay the interest on loans taken under the Kisan Credit Card; yet, Banks and other financial institutions are willing to increase the limit of the loan. (Representational image)

The government cannot accept the fact that farmers who have suppressed their woes for decades are now agitating across the country. It is a clear indication that the farmers’ patience has run out. For generations, the plight of the farmers has gone from bad to worse. But governments, irrespective of the political party, have only used farmers as a vote bank.

Every single farmer is in debt today. The return from his produce is not enough and he cannot even repay the interest on loans taken under the Kisan Credit Card; yet, Banks and other financial institutions are willing to increase the limit of the loan. After some years the loan amount multiplies but the continuing inability to pay pushes farmers to commit suicide.

Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s promise to the farmers of Uttar Pradesh that if voted to power his party would waive their loans came as a blessing. Needless to say, the farmers voted for the loan waiver. Once the UP government was formed, its first cabinet cleared a loan waiver of Rs 36,359 crores.

The PM had promised that all loans would be waived, as part of the ‘sabka saath, sabka vikas’ poll promise, yet the UP government decided to waive loans of only about 25% of the farmers. Maharashtra waived loans of Rs 30,000 crores. In Madhya Pradesh, Chief Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan at first refused to admit that the police had fired upon protesting farmers – he said they were miscreants — and killed 6 people. Then he agreed and paid up Rs 1 crore to every farmer killed.

Meanwhile, the Punjab Government is said to be considering a waiver. But Tamil Naidu’s farmers, try as they might, did not succeed in their demand for a loan waiver. They brought skulls as props and put them on display in front of TV cameras at Delhi’s Jantar Mantar, they shaved their moustache on one side, they drank urine and ate rats, all through their 41 day agitation.

We call ourselves an agrarian society where the farmers who feed the nation get bullets in return. The farmers need to be respected.

But farmer agitations have almost withered away in recent decades. Even if some organisation tries something, the government is quick to crush it. The vacuum has meant that political parties have sought to divide farmers along caste lines and sometimes, even religious lines. But they have failed to fundamentally fix the problem, which is why has farming become a losing proposition?

If our forefathers were as complacent about farming the way we are, we would not have ventured into agriculture. Every farmer has contributed to feeding the country’s large population, but what has he got in return? An enormous debt. The situation is so grave that if financial institutions refuse to give loans against the Kisan Credit Card, we will have many more farmers’ suicides.

Finally, the farmers have begun to believe that their strength lies in numbers. On June 16, as many as 130 farmer organisations all over the country gathered at Delhi’s Gandhi Peace Foundation to forge a national alliance that would jointly agitate so as to mitigate farm hardships

This alliance’s two-point agenda is to push for loan waivers and increase the minimum support price (MSP) as per the recommendations of the National Commission for Farmers, popularly known as the Swaminathan Commission. Both agenda items must be synchronised to work simultaneously. If the loan is waived and the MSP isn’t increased, then next year the loans will go up; on the other hand if the MSP is increased and the loan not waived, then the money obtained from an increased MSP will be used to repay the debt. In either case, the farmers’ plight will remain the same.

The Prime Minister has understood the gravity of the problem and has promised both – a loan waiver and a remunerative MSP consisting of 150 per cent of the cost of production. Yet, for reasons best known to him or his government or the party, neither of the two issues are being implemented. The country remains a silent spectator to a suicide by a desperate farmer every half an hour in the country.

Certainly, these agitations will be peaceful unless the Government provokes the farmers by choosing to fire like in Mandsaur. I only wish the government, which has been extremely sensitive to the need of the corporate sector, who by waiving annual loans worth lacs of crores spares a thought for the farmers who on one hand feed the nation and on the other hand cannot even muster a meal for their family.

V M Singh is the president of the Rashtriya Kisan Mazdoor party

For all the latest Opinion News, download Indian Express App

  1. H
    Harminder Singh
    Jun 23, 2017 at 7:43 am
    If it comes down to the crunch he who has land will still eat and maybe survive only but what about the citywallahs in their concrete jungle?
    Reply
    1. P
      P.C.Kulkarni
      Jun 23, 2017 at 6:49 am
      Delay in impllementing Swaminathan committee report is the cause of agarian distress
      Reply
      1. K
        KSRao
        Jun 23, 2017 at 5:18 am
        The loans to corporate sector are not waived off, they are written-off from the accounts of the banks as losses but continue to be treated as debt, and recovered over time. Look at what's happening to the King of Good Times Vijay Mallya. One after another his properties are being seized. The downturn in business has affected sectors like steel and infrastructure (largely because of governmental failure in this case) and the loans lent will be collected over time, maybe with some waivers of interest. Yes, farmers too need relief for their contribution to the country, but endless waivers will destroy the creditworthiness of the country and the economy. The solution lies in the export of agricultural products to countries that cannot grow or where grown their cost is much higher than imports. Increase in MSP will push up inflation, and further weaken the currency. Farmer should not suffer during times of over production, and the government should guide them to profitable crops.
        Reply
        1. R
          Raj Parwani
          Jun 23, 2017 at 12:25 am
          Our farmers are suiciding every day, these are the real heroes of India who are feeding the nation by growing food, and see what the system doing with them? we should be ashamed about ourselves, stop boosting about becoming super power, first feed your poor, treat your sick, it's insane that the country which is so poverty ridden, half of it's population doesn't even have toilets while Sanghis and trollers day dreaming about making India super power. Don't waste money in fighting senseless war in Kashmir and feed your poor heroes please.
          Reply
          1. P
            proud to
            Jun 22, 2017 at 11:02 pm
            Why we have to wave the loans? The interest on loans can be wavedbut not the prin l.They do not pay income tax so the people paying taxes are subsidizing them.The government should not allow the loan to loan defaulters.It is ok to extend the loan at lower interest but loan waiver is no no.This loan waiver will make them habitual defaulters.
            Reply
            1. S
              Sanjay
              Jun 23, 2017 at 12:45 am
              Who's subsidizing the Big Business loan defaulters (Anil Ambani is going to default on Rcom debt to the extent of Rs 40000 crores)? Why don't any Big Businessmen commit suicide when the specter of loan repayment stares them in the face?
              Reply
              1. A
                amar singh
                Jun 23, 2017 at 5:27 am
                Absolutely no loan waivers for anyone BUT START RECOVERY WITH AMBANIS, ADANIS,RUIAS DHOOT, other corporates.
                Reply
              2. K
                Kuldeepak Deshpande
                Jun 22, 2017 at 10:09 pm
                Well said Mr. Singh. Farming has unfortunately become a thankless profession. Interest-free loans, remunerative prices for crops and free education healthcare for farmers is the only way forward out of the current crisis. And 'farmers' ought to mean only those whose livelihood depends on pursuit of agriculture. Term loans for asset creation in agriculture also needs to be soft it is outrageous that one has to pay 11-12 for digging of well or drip irrigation or farm mechanization this is almost on par with commercial rates, something that is unfair for someone who feeds the nation by working on nation's resources like water and soil fertility.
                Reply
                1. J
                  Jetharam suthar
                  Jun 22, 2017 at 10:00 pm
                  चिन्तनीय है।
                  Reply
                  1. L
                    Lucky
                    Jun 22, 2017 at 9:24 pm
                    Farming profession in India can survive only under organized sector. Small farmers have to perish. Only bigwigs with political clout can prosper. This is what has been true since the days of East India Company.
                    Reply
                    1. Load More Comments