Strong and small

Modi is a tall leader. Then why does his government sometimes act in petty, vengeful ways?

Written by Julio Ribeiro | Published:May 27, 2015 12:00 am
Narendra Modi, Narendra Modi government, Modi, Modi governmenr, Modi govt, BJP, BJP government, Modi BJP government, Modi news, BJP news, Julio Roberio, Indian Express, Editorial, India news In its anxiety to take revenge on Setalvad, the government has upset an acclaimed philanthropist organisation, Ford Foundation, which funded a nationally recognised centre of learning, Tata Institute of Social Sciences.

“Pseudo-secularism” is alive and kicking in our country. After I voiced my concern about the peaceful Christian community becoming a soft target of Hindu extremist elements, I received a pile of mail, overwhelmingly supportive but with the expected dose of hate messages. “Pseudo-secularists” outnumbered “secularists” by a wide margin.

What warmed the cockles of my heart was that the bulk of the support was from a wide assortment of Hindus, many of them old friends but many also individuals not known to me till then. A young Bengali executive I met at an airport came up to me to voice his agreement with my stand. The critics included a couple of my former colleagues in the IPS — incidentally, strangers to me — who, I learnt, had served in the country’s premier intelligence agencies. How could they have arrived at any objective conclusion in the course of their work if they were so steeped in a particular ideology?

Here, I must mention an honest, upright, remarkable police officer, a year senior to me in the service. S.E. Joshi, who hailed from a distinguished family in Amravati in Vidarbha, retired as chief of R&AW. When we were junior, he was the central intelligence officer covering Vidharba and Marathwada. I was superintendent of police of Parbhani district and then Nanded, both in the Marathwada region. Joshi would make half-yearly trips to review the work of his officers and stayed with me whenever he visited.

The Marathwada districts had been merged with the old Bombay state, later Maharashtra, from the nizam’s Hyderabad. The influence of the Razakars was still felt. The IB officer who patrolled my districts was a Brahmin from Vidarbha, as was Joshi. When I praised his deputy’s acumen, Joshi cautioned me to be careful in accepting all that he told me. “He is biased against Muslims,” he said, “and bias is a major defect in any intelligence operative’s armour”. It was a lesson I never forgot.

Contrary opinions, even extreme ones, should be taken seriously. They exist in every religion in all countries of the world. Religion brings out the best and the worst in human beings. We are lucky that hatemongers can be counted on one’s fingers. Among the voices which did not like what I had said was that of Jagdish Bhagwati, an internationally known economist, and of T.V. Mohandas Pai, the IT wizard. I got the feeling that they felt that my writing would denigrate Prime Minister Narendra Modi and weaken him in the eyes of the Western world, which he was so assiduously wooing for investments.

Actually, I want Modi to succeed. Let me make this clear. After Indira Gandhi, he is the only strong leader we have had. And the country needs a strong leader, a determined leader, a charismatic leader. Modi gives the impression that he is such a leader. Only he can change the mentality of a people. Many voted for Modi and not for the BJP — numerous Christians I know did. They voted for development and jobs. What needs to change if the country is to develop is the “chalta hai” attitude of the people when they routinely, though unwillingly, pay speed money to the lower rungs of the bureaucracy, when they disregard the rules of the road, when they litter public places without batting an eyelid and accept injustices without protest. Only a strong leader like Modi can lead a public campaign to rectify these innate defects in our collective psyche.

But instead of concentrating time and energy in bringing about such fundamental changes, his government seems to prioritise fixing Greenpeace and Teesta Setalvad, that intrepid champion of justice for the Muslim minority that fell victim to the 2002 Gujarat killings. In its anxiety to take revenge on Setalvad, the government has upset a universally acclaimed philanthropist organisation, Ford Foundation, which has funded a nationally recognised centre of learning and thinking, Tata Institute of Social Sciences.

Why is the Modi government wasting the precious goodwill it enjoyed after it was voted to power in small, mindless, negative acts of vengeance that do not behove a great nation? Is Modi the only giant among pygmies? We hear that he is the puppeteer who pulls all the strings from the PMO. In which case, how did this petty piece of governance get past him — especially when the complaint against Ford Foundation’s support to Setalvad’s NGO emanated from his own home state, Gujarat?

I hope Bhagwati is listening. He should advise Modi to refrain from acts of petty-mindedness that will only boomerang on all his other valiant attempts to reform the economy. And Pai should add his bit of advice. I am sure that on this issue, both of them think like me and numerous other fellow Indians.

The Modi government has completed a year in office. Its report card is positive. It has secured good grades in certain subjects — corruption in the higher reaches has gone down, noticeably down. In the lower reaches, it is business as usual. Modi will have to act drastically against those who refuse to reform. The voter must know that she can get what is legally due without having to grease palms.

And that brings me to the question that is uppermost in my mind. I run an NGO called Public Concern for Governance Trust (PCGT). It was established a decade ago in Mumbai by B.G. Deshmukh, a former cabinet secretary and a true servant of the public. The PCGT relies heavily on the Right to Information Act to fight the day-to-day corruption that troubles people.

Why is Modi so wary of the RTI that he does not think it necessary to appoint a chief information commissioner and information commissioners at the Centre? Is this his idea of good governance? He was also reluctant to fill the posts in Gujarat when he was chief minister there. Does he feel that he can single-handedly fight corruption without institutions in place? There are many others like me who would like to know.

The writer, a retired IPS officer, was Mumbai police commissioner, DGP Gujarat and DGP Punjab, and is a former Indian ambassador to Romania.

For all the latest India News, download Indian Express App now

  1. I
    Ivian
    Jun 1, 2015 at 6:35 pm
    BTW, the Delhi high court disagrees with your judgment on Greenpeace. But we all know the Indian judiciary is a bunch of psedo-secular leftists.
    Reply
    1. M
      manohar sharma
      May 27, 2015 at 7:06 pm
      Dear Sir Do you still feel you are a stranger in your own country.i am sure your police friends may have told you the truth about church attacks in Delhi and new Mumbai .That it was a Bangladeshi Muslim who has been arrested for the rape of 70 years old nun. that the main stream media, who had hyped all these attacks as a proof for increasing intolerance towards minorities did not show the same energy in highlighting these truths is known to all in India but I certainly expected you to state thes facts.their absence in your second article is a clear proof that Bhagwati and Pai are absolutely correct in their essment of you. I w heartedly agree with them yet I do respect your work as DGP Punjab in those troubled times
      Reply
      1. V
        Venu
        Jul 1, 2015 at 12:22 pm
        I agree cent percent. Lower level corruption is on the rise. To get a new meter for electricity, getting corrections to records in landed property,and similar things u have to grease the hands of officials. The election commission does not have the wherewithal for issuing correct voter ideny. These and other things which affects the common man To cite a few.modi to modify approach if he wants to introduce real digital India.
        Reply
        1. M
          Matts
          May 30, 2015 at 7:40 pm
          Mr. Ribeiro, Why no comment from you on the misreported incidents of West Bengal, Agra and Delhi? No apologies from your end in getting carried away before evidence was shown.... Insn't that surprising? And as far as our lovely Ford Foundation is concerned, Honestly sir, I was expecting a more mature reaction from you. Ford Foundation has been regarded informally as a front for the CIA. This is well known in all the circles. Just google "Ford Foundation and CIA" to do some reserach for 5 min. So you really scare me. Also, as a policeman who has lived by the law for your entire life, kindly educate me that if the government is following the policies of the previous UPA government in targetting all NGOs who are either filing fraudulent tax returns or not filing them at all, is it incorrect on its part? Please don't hide away essential rebuttals in your article and spread falsehoods. Also, a humble suggestion. It is alright to aplogise for a mistake on your part earlier about the "plight of christians" after petty attacks by local goons on some churches. Everybody in India knows that political parties in India can attack this government on only one issue,,, that is communalism.. they can't attack it on corruption, on policy paralysis, on the kind of policies, on the reforms that it is doing. So apologise for jumping the gun as you did and judge "OBJECTIVELY" as you suggest in your article. Love and Regards
          Reply
          1. A
            Aditya
            May 27, 2015 at 11:51 am
            Mr. Ribeiro is clutching at straws to find something or the other to fault the Modi government with. Regarding NGOs, money being diverted to obstruct developmental projects and fund proselytization is a reality. Take the case of Kudankulam power plant for example. This is something even the UPA government called out, in a rare display of spine.
            Reply
            1. V
              Vikrant
              May 27, 2015 at 2:48 pm
              Mr Riberio, secularism cannot be onesided. Before teaching Hindus about secularism please ask priests of your own religion to stop maligning other religions. Will Christian stop preaching theirs is only the true religion and rest all are followers of Satan. Can you speak against your own? No. Then dont lecture others
              Reply
              1. V
                Vikrant
                May 27, 2015 at 2:53 pm
                Respect for other religions is not because of consution it is because hindus are tolerant towards other faith. If it was because of consution then why have christians and muslims not stopped their attempts for conversion?
                Reply
                1. V
                  Vikrant
                  May 27, 2015 at 2:51 pm
                  his point is simple conversion by christians should be encouraged speaking against it is crime
                  Reply
                  1. V
                    Vikrant
                    May 27, 2015 at 6:19 pm
                    Can followers of Christianity for once come out and say in open that they dont agree with the statement that Christianity is the only true religion that leads you to God and followers of other religion need to be corrected shown right direction and brought out of the influence of Satan? Will you Mr Rationale?
                    Reply
                    1. V
                      Vikrant
                      May 27, 2015 at 6:15 pm
                      Exchange of ideas cannot start with the position that you are right and others are communal. So what Riberio has said here is why he thinks RSS and others are communal and those opposing him are saying why they feel he is communal. It is rational discussion but instead of answering qurstions all that secular brigade always does is start with the stand that they are right and only their opponents need to prove his innocence
                      Reply
                      1. A
                        Ajay Sunder
                        May 27, 2015 at 1:21 pm
                        Mr.RIbeiro certainly does not deserve what is being said against him.Let us not forget what he did when he was holding forth in Panjab.At least for that, if not for anything else, let us respect him.He has every right to write whatever he has written whether certain people like it or not . Let us learn to listen to even those whose views we do not like.
                        Reply
                        1. a
                          ak.dev
                          May 27, 2015 at 5:50 pm
                          Why is this retired police officer always talking on single point agenda that serves his religion only? With Modi's victory, he seems to be deeply heart and trying to vent his frustrations like few others who wanted the Congress's hegemony to continue.
                          Reply
                          1. A
                            Anil Kumar
                            May 27, 2015 at 6:20 am
                            I admire you Mr. Ribeiro, for raising serious issues, and gently criticizing Mr. Modi's action/inaction. Do not worry of a set of those who immediately jump on any one criticizing Mr. Modi. We are with you.
                            Reply
                            1. L
                              ligesh
                              May 27, 2015 at 1:15 pm
                              He did and does nothing. i was happy when he became prime minister. oil price gone up. rupee not yet srengthen.
                              Reply
                              1. L
                                ligesh
                                May 27, 2015 at 1:19 pm
                                only one way we have we have to pray to god to improve honerable prime minister modis way of aproch for the country.
                                Reply
                                1. A
                                  Amrita
                                  May 27, 2015 at 5:35 pm
                                  I find your choice of phrases rather interesting and definitely controversy seeking. You refer to Mr Modi as 'gives the impression that he is a strong leader,'. You will get a response from the people, not sure which categories you put them in. I second Mr Bhagwati's opinion and that of Mr Mohandas Pai. Your last piece drew an angry response from deep inside of me. There is very clear evidence presented in the media that attacks on the churches etc were comparable to that of the UPA, a fact that even you may not accept. India is tolerant but do not abuse the position you have reached. Im sure that the MHA has very good reasons for its actions against certain NGOs. I have not seen pettiness in their actions because I was not looking for it. Let the law take its own course. If there are FERA violations let them be known to you and me. Our media does their very effective bit in highlighting issues and very little pes them. Otherwise the courts will step in. Stop worrying and getting others hyped up.
                                  Reply
                                  1. A
                                    Anil Maheshwari
                                    May 27, 2015 at 1:32 pm
                                    Mr. Ribeiro has put his point of views succinctly. But it is expected from a sane voice, for which he has earned laurels, to admit that isolated incidents on religious places (temples, churches and mosques) were exaggerated and blown out of proportion in the hostile media. What is the strength of the Hindu Mahasabha in the country? How many shakhas of the RSS are held at present compared to the fifties and sixties? Mr. Riberio you have been Superintendent of Police in your cadre. Please ask your friends and write again in these columns. The nation (to borrow the phrase of Arnab Goswami) expects from you to speak truth, nothing but truth. Don't rely on the 50-ood gang of commentators, masquerading as experts on each and every subject and jumping from one to other studio or giving their 'expert' opinion from their studies at home.
                                    Reply
                                    1. A
                                      Anil Maheshwari
                                      May 27, 2015 at 4:26 pm
                                      You wish to remain anonymous. No issue. It is your mindset. Secondly what point this brave policeman, who served the country in the right earnest, is making except taking brief on behalf of the liberal gang which is out to defame Modi, even neglecting the bare facts.
                                      Reply
                                      1. A
                                        Anurag Sharma
                                        May 27, 2015 at 8:22 am
                                        Mr Ribeiro.. All u write seems fine and makes sense. But just wonder where were u & Setalvads of this world (whom u stoutly defend) when sikhs were macred in daylight in Delhi & elsewhere. .. I guess u were serving as a trigger happy cop killing people in Punjab and serving the N/G dynasty and collecting accolades all the way. Why this sudden rise of voice of conscience. Mudde ki baat karo. It seems that u are troubled that a non-pseudo secular & a strong leader is in power after a long time. something worriers u and your tribe.. I am sure it is not secularism alone that worries u. Spell out your worries pls. Our respect for you will increase manifold if u do
                                        Reply
                                        1. S
                                          S Srinivasan
                                          May 27, 2015 at 10:49 am
                                          It is unfortunate to see a most celebrated Police Officer,who added more values to Maharastra Police,has stooped to this level.After all he has shown his true colours.The simple Law and order problem that go unchecked anywhere in the world,could be tackled by local police and for this blaming the great man of India(The present prime minister) is nothing but just a lunatic's outbusrt.
                                          Reply
                                          1. A
                                            anony
                                            May 28, 2015 at 1:43 pm
                                            CIC and CVC issue is stuck with courts.. The government recently got a go ahead to appoint the heads.. why report falsehoods?
                                            Reply
                                            1. Load More Comments